Understanding the Relationship Between Adaptation and Selection Processes Through the Lenses of Organizational Theories (original) (raw)
Related papers
A new perspective on: evolutionary processes and organizational adaptation
Journal of Organization Design
Levinthal’s (Evolutionary processes and organizational adaptation: a Mendelian perspective on strategic management. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2021) book is not only a helpful resource on the many facets of organizational adaptation, but also a source of inspiration that promises to revitalize research on organizational evolution. Taking inspiration from this book, I outline a perspective on three topics that may enrich management research: (1) Levinthal’s treatment of path-dependence is a much-needed candidate for a general account of selection processes across biological and social domains; (2) Levinthal’s idea that corporate diversification and technological disruption may be considered instances of speciation—i.e., branching of lineages—(re)frames an exciting research agenda at the intersection of ecology and evolution; (3) Considering executives as a population of fruit flies may, from the perspective of empirical research, be a useful complement to the idea of the Mendel...
Organizational Adaptation to Environmental Change
Hospital & health services administration
Through this series of working papers, the Institute of Governmental Studies, Berkeley, provides a channel through which scholars at work on prob lems of public oiganization may present their thoughts in a convenient form and without too much delay. We envision this series as a modest undertaking, but we hope that Studies in Public Organization" will make some contribu tions toward an understanding ofthe properties that describe the variety of public organizational systems that exist throughout the world. We want also to note that no single formula will dominate; the series will contain papers that are theoretical, methodological, comparative, or historical. It is open to faculty and student contribution alike, not restricted to this campus, and its objective is to publish papers that engage important problems and present interesting ideas.
2019
The text offers a review of the perspectives of Institutional and Resource Dependence, and shows a practical application based on the analysis of organizational strategic adaptation in the case study of a family-run furniture manufacturer and retailer. While the institutional perspective emphasizes environmental determinism as an influencer of the organization's strategic responses, the Resource Dependence perspective emphasizes voluntarism as a key aspect in the response of organizational decision makers. The key factors for the study of strategies proposed in the adaptation process range from the degree of organizational compliance, dictated by the former, to resistance to institutional pressures, explained by the latter. This article aimed to show that in the process of organizational adaptation, both are important aspects of the decision making of organizational leaders. This research is of the exploratory type, with a qualitative approach. This type of approach involves int...
Myopia of Selection: Does Organizational Adaptation Limit the Efficacy of Population Selection?
Administrative Science Quarterly, 2007
This paper develops and tests a model of the effectiveness of selection processes in eliminating less fit organizations from a population when organizations are undergoing adaptive change. Stable organizational traits, such as a search strategy or routine, do not imply that an organization's performance will remain stable over time or that cross-sectional differences in performance will persist. These properties create the possibility that population-level selection processes will be inefficient in that organizations with potentially superior long-run performance will be selected out. We theorize that organizational-level adaptation often results in fluctuations in current performance across time. These fluctuations may attenuate the degree to which current performance differences among organizations are indicative of future performance. As a consequence, search strategies that generate systematically different performance trajectories, even if they share a common long-run outcome, will generate differing survival rates. These ideas are explored using a formal simulation model employing the framework of NK performance landscapes. Our central finding is that selection may be systematically prone to errors and that these selection errors are endogenous to, and differ markedly across, firms' search strategies.
EXPLORING THE ORGANIZATION – ENVIRONMENT LINK: CHANGE AS COEVOLUTION
Building on coevolution theory and existing knowledge about strategic and organizational change, this paper develops a conceptual framework for studying change in organizations as coevolution. The focus is on how organizations create constructed environmental conditions, hence forming the context for themselves and other organizations and their environment. The paper illustrates this problematic by focusing on the interplay between public and private organizations. A set of propositions and an integrated framework laying the ground for future empirical research are developed.
Three Facets of Organizational Adaptation: Selection, Variety, and Plasticity
W hen considering the adaptive dynamics of organizations, it is important to account for the full set of adaptive mechanisms, including not only the possibility of learning and adaptation of a given behavior but also the internal selection over some population of routines and behaviors. In developing such a conceptual framework, it is necessary to distinguish between the underlying stable roots of behavior and the possibly adaptive expression of those underlying templates. Selection occurs over expressed behavior. As a result, plasticity, the capacity to adapt behavior, poses a trade-off as it offers the possibility of adaptive learning but at the same time mitigates the effectiveness of selection processes to identify more or less superior underlying roots of behavior. In addition, plasticity may mitigate the reliability with which practices are enacted. These issues are explored in the context of a computational model, which examines the interrelationship among processes of variation, selection, and plasticity.