Moral Judgement as a Method in Historiography: An Analysis of al-Biruni's al-Athar al-Baqiyah 'an al-Qurun al-Khaliyah (original) (raw)
2021, KEMANUSIAAN
The practice of moral judgement in historiography is a topic in critical philosophy of history. In general, there are two opinions on the practice of moral judgement in history: firstly, those who are against it, such as Croce, Bloch and Butterfield; secondly, those who are in support of it, such as Lord Acton, Ibn Khaldun and al-Biruni. Understanding the practice is crucial in facilitating "intellectual serenity" among historians in deciding on their research method. This article discusses al-Biruni's position and epistemic justification on the issue of moral judgement in research in history. The analysis of al-Biruni's perspective, based on his book, al-Athar al-Baqiyah 'an al-Qurun al-Khaliyah, shows that his epistemic justification on moral judgement in history was influenced by his religious tradition.
Related papers
On The Ethical Rationalism Of Al-Ghazali
Saruhan, MÜFİT S. . "On The Ethical Rationalism of Al Ghazali", Journal of Islamic Research, vol.3, pp.51-66, 2010." Journal of Islamic Research, , vol.3, pp.51-66, 2010 , 2010
In studies on social history, one has to consider a large number of sources, for instance, from the fields of literature, history, and geography. Books of statecraft (Siyāsatnāme) also fall under this category. Among the works that contain socio-historical knowledge and have received insufficient attention are some texts on Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), despite some references from Jean Sauvaget in the entry of The History of the Islamic East. Can such texts be used to understand historical and social issues and to discuss aspects in the history of Islamic societies? Undoubtedly, because of their strong connection to people’s daily lives, texts from the field of Islamic jurisprudence contain useful insights into social problems that can be of great use for socio-historical research. This article aims to present one of these works, the Ḥāwī li-l-Fatāwī by Ǧalāl ad-Dīn as-Suyūṭī, which reveals part of the social history in the field of material culture.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.