Book Review: Datta, Arunima (2021). Fleeting Agencies: A Social History of Indian Coolie Women in British Malaya (Global South Asians). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, July 2021, The Book Review, ISSN (Print) 0970-4175 (original) (raw)
Related papers
This article considers the abolition of the mui tsai (young female bondservants) as it unfolded in British Malaya, and challenges the overemphasis on Hong Kong as the primary focus of mui tsai scholarship. While the mui tsai system was defended as a time-honoured Chinese tradition, this paper uses new material to show that transracial considerations figured prominently in mui tsai abolition in Malaya, particularly in helping to recast it as a wider problem of child welfare. This neglected aspect of its abolition, the paper argues, only comes clearly to light in the Malayan case; for it was in the intensely multiracial conditions of peninsular Malaya that such a question could be asked: ‘Do you own non-Chinese mui tsai?’
Kit Marek de Thurveton Hildyard Trinity College This dissertation is submitted for the degree of Master of Philosophy Word count: 17,008 2 Declaration This dissertation is the result of my own work and includes nothing which is the outcome of work done in collaboration except where specifically indicated in the text. Both the hard copies and electronic version of the submitted work have identical content. The thesis does not exceed the word limit. Bibliography 56 4 Female migration to India: femininity, gender, race, religion, nationalism, and internationalism, 1879-1947 Introduction 'The British Empire always seemed a very masculine enterprise,' Philippa Levine writes, 'a series of far-flung sites dominated by white men dressed stiffly in sporting and hunting clothes, or ornate official regalia.' 1 If the British empire was masculine, it was, however, not male, being inhabited by hundreds of thousands of women, as Mary Procida has pointed out. 2 Four of these womenand their associates and collaboratorsare the focus of this essay. Helena
Against Multiple Hegemonies: Radical Malay Women in Colonial Malaya
This article seeks to redress the established scholarly boundaries that have thus far characterized Malaysian historiography through a detailed analysis of a Malay radical women's movement, the Angkatan Wanita Sedar (AWAS). Although much has been written in the last few decades about Malay political activism during post World War II Malaya, radical female groups that emerged during those event- ful years, and their efforts to carve autonomous spaces within emerging projects of national liberation has suffered from considerable neglect. By blending the use of colonial and vernacular sources to contextualize the activities of AWAS within the changing social and political landscapes of its time, this article shows that female radical activists in post World War II colonial Malaya were confronted with multiple hegemonies that worked to stifle their development. These hegemonies originated, first, from within their own society in the form of customary conventions and practi- ces associated with class differences. AWAS also had to contend with censure and disciplinary actions from their male compatriots, who regarded them as threats to male dominance in radical politics. Finally, AWAS came under the watchful eye and proscriptive measures of the colonial state that sought to regain its control over its Asian subjects in an age of decolonization. The members of this radical collective struggled to overcome these hegemonies by drawing upon a whole array of relation- ships and connections to advance their cause, albeit with limited success.
2017
The coming of British to Malaya and the opening of rubber plantations, in the late 19th century, paved way for many people from India who were looking for a better life. To many Indians especially the Southerners, coming to Malaya was an escapism from the dire poverty that hit India at that time. Little did they know the struggle that they will have to go through in establishing a new home in a foreign land. This paper will probe into the struggles of these immigrants in Malaya during the pre and post independence years. This study will be based on the novels of two popular Indian writers, K.S. Maniam and M. Kumaaran. Maniam’s, In a far Country (1993) and Kumaaran’s, Semmannum Neela Malargalum (1971) which is written in Tamil, depict on the painful journey encountered by the immigrants and their descendents. They had to wade through displacement, frustration, poverty, rejection and caste system in order to establish a home in the new land. This paper will discuss the journey of thes...
Gender and History, 2021
This article traces the gendered entanglements of migration, intimate relations and law among itinerant Indians in colonial Singapore between 1900 and 1940, when Indians began consolidating their roots. Singapore did not legislate marriages for migrants, but the courts had to rule on the validity of migrant marriages in marital disputes and offences, resulting in legal ambiguities. Through a close reading of legal reports, newspaper archives and oral histories focusing on cases of wife enticement, this article formulates a gendered understanding of the migration process and intimate life for Indians. It builds on the scholarly literature on intimate life and legal governance in colonial societies, makes a set of analytical descriptions that reveal tensions of race, class and gender in legal negotiations and underscores how the processes of migration and law impacted on the social life of Indians. The cases discussed illuminate how intimate relationships, especially of Indian women, animated communal and patriarchal anxieties, and they establish the role of Indians in the legal history of marriage and family laws in Singapore. Moreover, the context of an urban free port with a predominantly itinerant population highlights mechanisms of colonial rule that were different from the exigencies in other colonies.
Emigration of Women Domestic Workers from Kerala: Gender, State Policy and the Politics of Movement
2011
Restrictions imposed by the Government of India on the emigration of women in 'unskilled' categories such as domestic work are framed as measures intended to protect women from exploitation. Special protection for certain categories of emigrant women workers makes way for gendered conceptions of citizenship and sovereignty through the use of gender to assert control over space in ways that curtail women's access to mobility and emigrant work opportunities. However, restrictions have directed potential migrants to the use of informal / illegal processes in connivance with state agencies. Whereas, intermediaries, including recruiting agents and government officials, profit from the use of informal / illegal processes by prospective emigrants and hence they have an interest in rendering these more effective than formal processes established by the state, we argue that the gender politics around movement provides an enabling condition for both state restrictions and the burgeoning of informal / illegal processes. To spell out the implications of state policy on emigrant women domestic workers, the paper compares their position and experience of migration with that of emigrant nurses on the one hand and outmigrant fish processing workers on the other. It also explores the nature of women's agency involved when domestic workers resist state policy and social norms to emigrate through informal / illegal means.
Postcolonial Indian Labour Migration to Malaysia: Trajectories, Trends and Tensions
International Migration in Southeast Asia
Malaysia has always been the centre of attraction for Indian skilled and unskilled labourers from the colonial phase to present times, given its geographical proximity, viable economic opportunities and cultural similarities. The colonial phase was marked by liberal immigration policies coupled with the state acting as an agency for transporting, regulating and managing Indian labourers. The regular mobility of Indian labourers has gradually led to permanent settlement of an Indian community in Malaysia. After the independence of Malaysia in 1957, there has been a shift in foreign labour immigration policies to the diminishing role of state in regulating and controlling foreign labour force under a neoliberal economic regime. In the face of stringent foreign labour immigration laws of the country, Indian labourers embark upon myriad ways and means for their mobility given the perennial demand for foreign labourers in certain critical economic sectors of Malaysia. Successive structural economic changes have propelled the increasing inflow of skilled and unskilled Indian migrants; this has eventually resulted in dichotomization of Indian community into 'Old Indian migrants' and 'New Indian migrants'. This chapter sheds light on the emerging trajectories, trends and tensions of postcolonial Indian labour migration, especially with regard to unskilled Indian labourers. I also highlight the continuities between colonial and postcolonial Indian labour migration to Malaysia. Keywords Postcolonial indian migration Á Skilled and unskilled indian labourers Á Labour trafficking Á Labour exploitation Malaysia has been a host country to Indians even before the British established their presence in the nineteenth century. There has been a symbiotic relationship between both the countries in terms of goods, ideas and inflow of people given their geographical proximity. Indian migration to Malaysia has historical precedents. A miniscule community of Indian traders made their settlements in pre-colonial Malaya. Later, an influx of Indians to Malaysia began during the colonial period M. Marimuthu (&) Centre for Policy Analysis,