Citizenship, minorities and the police: attitudes of Jewish Ethiopian Israelis toward police reforms (original) (raw)
Related papers
Race, Racism, and Policing: Responses of Ethiopian Jews in Israel to Stigmatization by the police
Ethnicities, 2017
Immigrants who believe they suffer from stigmatization and discrimination may still demonstrate positive attitudes toward government authorities. We explore this trust–discrimination paradox by examining perceptions about police and policing among Ethiopian Jews in Israel, an immigrant racial minority. Drawing on data collected from focus groups and survey results, we find that levels of trust in the police among Israelis of Ethiopian descent are equal to or higher than among veteran Jewish Israelis. Nevertheless, Ethiopian Israelis also report negative perceptions of the police that are rooted in strong feelings of stigmatization by these government agents. While trust in the police may reflect Ethiopian Jews’ desire for integration, participation, and inclusion as legitimate and equal members of nation and state, we demonstrate that they use various de-stigmatization strategies whose aim is to downplay the importance and depth of their discrimination by the police. These strategies, we argue, allow Ethiopian Israelis to maintain positive attitudes toward the police.
Police relations with Arabs & Jews in Israel
Remarkably little research has been conducted on police relations with citizens in Israel compared with other societies that are deeply divided along ethnic lines. This paper examines the views of Arabs and Jews regarding several key aspects of policing in Israel. The fi ndings indicate, fi rst, that Arabs are consistently more critical of the police than Jews, and these ethnic differences persist net of the infl uence of other variables. Second, in addition to the role played by ethnicity in explaining public assessments of the police, a number of other variables infl uence such attitudes. The results are interpreted within the context of the divided society model of policing, which originated in research on other ethnically polarized societies. Policing Ethnically Divided Societies Ethnic minorities and the police have troubled relations in many societies (Antonopoulos 2003 ; Bowling and Phillips 2003), but, in deeply divided societies , such confl icts are especially deep-rooted. These societies are characterized by extreme polarization along ethnic lines, and policing is organized fi rst and foremost ' for the defense of a sectarian regime and the maintenance of a social order based on institutionalized inequality between dominant and subordinate communal groups ' (Weitzer 1995: 5). This model of policing has the following features: (1) police policies or practices are institutionally biased against members of the subordinate minority group; (2) over-representation of the dominant ethnic group within the police force, especially in the top ranks; (3) polit-icization of the police force and police repression of the regime's opponents; (4) dual responsibility for ordinary crime control and internal security; (5) legal powers giving police great latitude in their control of the minority population, including the use of force; (6) an absence of effective mechanisms of accountability; and (7) confl icting ori-entations to the police among the subordinate group and dominant groups: on key issues of legitimacy, trust, confi dence and support, the dominant group is a champion of the police and the subordinate group is largely estranged from the police (Weitzer 1995: 3 – 9; see also Brewer 1990 ; 1991). Some of these factors are present, in varying degrees, in many nations, but what distinguishes deeply divided societies is their magnitude and combination — constituting a distinctive policing model (Brewer 1990). In divided societies, citizens ' relations with the police are shaped, in large part, by their allegiance to or alienation from the state — a factor that is less prominent in shaping perceptions of the police in more integrated societies, where the state enjoys diffuse legitimacy and is not an object of fundamental contention (Marenin 1985). In other words, it is not just what the police do, but also what police represent to people. In ethnically divided societies, the symbolic status of the police force, as pillars of state domination over ethnic
Israel Affairs, 2013
Discriminating police practices (e.g., by racial profiling) are thoroughly studied in order to understand their underlying sources. It is argued that police racism and prejudices against minorities impede police agencies' ability to supply policing services based on equality. One factor that influenced police agencies throughout the world to adopt community policing was their will to ameliorate relations with minorities' communities. Community policing and Allport's "contact hypothesis" share some common assumptions that are discussed in this article. This hypothesis is tested in the environment of the Israeli National Police (INP). A sample of 643 police officers and police managers completed attitudinal questionnaires regarding their attitudes towards Israeli Arab citizens and community policing. Findings showed that positive attitudes towards community policing correlated with positive attitudes towards Arab citizens. The implications of these findings are discussed.
Police Relations with Arabs and Jews in Israel
British Journal of Criminology, 2007
Remarkably little research has been conducted on police relations with citizens in Israel compared with other societies that are deeply divided along ethnic lines. This paper examines the views of Arabs and Jews regarding several key aspects of policing in Israel. The fi ndings indicate, fi rst, that Arabs are consistently more critical of the police than Jews, and these ethnic differences persist net of the infl uence of other variables. Second, in addition to the role played by ethnicity in explaining public assessments of the police, a number of other variables infl uence such attitudes. The results are interpreted within the context of the divided society model of policing, which originated in research on other ethnically polarized societies.
William and Mary journal of women and the law, 2021
die-gray-baltimore-police-federal-charges.html [https://perma.cc/YQK4-BJXH\]. 2. TOI Staff, Cops Beat Ethiopian IDF Soldier in Alleged Racist Attack, TIMES OF ISR. (Apr. 27, 2015), https://www.timesofisrael.com/cops-beat-ethiopian-idf-soldier-in-al leged-racist-attack [https://perma.cc/75W7-TG7A\]. 3. See Ruiz, supra note 1; Stuart Winer and Marissa Newman, Cop who beat Ethiopian-Israeli soldier won't be tried, TIMES OF ISR. (June 14, 2015), https://www.times ofisrael.com/cop-who-beat-ethiopian-israeli-soldier-wont-be-tried [https://perma.cc /E3BL-TDR7]. 4. See Sue Surkes, Deal offered to cop accused of beating Ethiopian soldier, TIMES OF ISR.
Policing alienated minorities in divided cities
Regulation & Governance, 2018
Minority groups frequently challenge the legitimacy of legal authorities, particularly the police. Without trust and legitimacy, the police encounter constant conflict and cannot function effectively. While past research has examined minorities' perceptions of the police, national minorities provide an interesting and under-investigated test case because of their inherent identity conflict with the state. The current research examines three factors to explain minority-majority disparities in views of the police: (i) police effectiveness and fairness; (ii) intergroup discrimination (termed relative deprivation in policing); and (iii) identification with the state. Findings from a survey of Jewish and Arab residents of nationally mixed neighborhoods in Israel (n = 394) suggest that while all of these factors account for minority-majority discrepancies in views of the police, perceptions of police fairness are particularly important. Furthermore, feelings of discrimination and low levels of identification with the state are less important than evaluations of fairness in explaining minorities' negative perceptions of the police.
Police, Politics, and Culture in a Deeply Divided Society
Policing in Israel, 2015
This Article deals with minorities'perceptions of the police in "deeply divided societies." These societies are generally characterized by political disagreements, and the literature shows that most researchers emphasize the centrality of the political variable in order to understand policeminority interactions. This Article acknowledges the centrality of the political variable and adds a cultural variable that may improve the understanding of police-minority relations in a deeply divided society. In some societies, the disparity in the perceptions of majority and minority groups cannot be attributed solely to the political variable, but also to cultural differences. This is especially prominent in the case of native or immigrant minorities. Hence, it is reasonable to expect that this cultural pluralism will be reflected in minorities' interaction with and its perception of the police. Findings from a survey conducted in Israel indicate that political disagreements between Jews and Arabs have negatively affected the Arab minority's perceptions of the police. This Article also shows that the Arab minority group is not homogenous in regard to their relationship with the police; there are significant political and cultural differences among Arab subgroups (Muslim, Christian, and Druze). The Druze hold similar political orientations to the Jewish majority, and consequently their perceptions of the police were found to be more positive than those of Muslim Arabs. Nevertheless, both Druze and Muslim Arabs expressed
Is there "Black Panther" Movement in Israel? Protests of Ethiopian Jews -Sources of Conflict and Policy Implications, 2019
The migration of various ethnic groups creates a challenge for policymakers in general and civil society in particular. The concerns, as well as maintaining the status quo, could present obstacles in creating a homogenous and equitable civil society. As an immigrant-absorbing state, Israel is challenged both socially and economically in these realms. The Melting Pot concept was one of Israel's founding blocks since the 1950's fail. Has it failed? Is there truth to the protesters' allegations of institutionalized racism? In light of the demonstrations and accusations of racism in Israeli society, what changes should be set in motion?