Beyond the Rhetoric of Recognition or Separation: Two Swiss Cantons' Attempts at Governing Religious Superdiversity (original) (raw)
This text offers a careful description and sociological analysis of two legal innovations undertaken to govern religious diversity (in 2007 and 2019) in the neighboring Swiss cantons, Vaud and Geneva. Although the two cantons have very similar social and cultural conditions, they offer legally opposite solutions—one based on a notion of secularity implying separation, the other favoring recognition of religious diversity. The author argues that beyond an initial appreciation in terms of differences, the two cases are surprisingly similar in their logic of recognition, revealing a sense of deep suspicion towards religious diversity. Drawing on the concept of “recognition” as a multi-dimensional concept including legal, civic, and intimate/person levels and more importantly, on a Foucauldian perspective, this text concentrates on how control is involved at a practical level beyond the rhetoric of empowerment.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research.
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Related papers
Moves towards Authentic Freedom. Church and State in Switzerland, and Beyond
“Moves towards Authentic Freedom – Church and State in Switzerland, and beyond,” Saint Anselm Journal 10.2 (2015): 47-64 Many of the Swiss Cantons have regulated the relations between church and state by establishing, in their public law, corporations at the levels of the municipality and of the canton. The role and the rights of these corporations, especially obligatory membership in them, is the object of ongoing political and legal debate. Both on the side of the courts and of the church, the present system has come under scrutiny, while the corporation representatives and also a majority of the population seem intent on maintaining it. This paper explains and examines the presently valid church-state relations, focusing on the Canton of Zurich, and looks at the suggestions for reform elaborated by an experts' commission instituted by the Conference of Swiss Bishops. In conclusion, it presents some more general reflections on the challenges to individual and corporative religious freedom today, in Switzerland and beyond.
Religion and the Secular State in Switzerland
2019
Religion and the Secular State in Switzerland I. INTRODUCTION Today, Switzerland is a secular state in which state and religion are in principle separated. This does not mean, however, that religion is totally banned from public law. On the cantonal level, the state acknowledges a privileged status to different important religious communities. Moreover, the state reacts to the rise of religious plurality. It tries to solve the legal and factual problems which occur due to the emergence of non-western religious communities. The focus of the state policy is to a lesser extent on the laity of the state than on the religious neutrality; in areas which are of interest for the state, it cooperates with the religious communities. The present contribution explains the basic norms concerning the regulation of the relationship of the state and the religious communities in the Swiss Confederation. Along with the description of the current development and some exemplary court decisions these norms will illustrate the secular state's position concerning religious matters. II. HISTORICAL AND SOCIAL CONTEXT Like elsewhere, the constitutional law on religious matters in Switzerland is the result of a long historical development. It responds to more recent denominational developments as well. Without any claim of completeness, this paper begins with a few references to the historical development. This may provide for better understanding of the current system. At the beginning of the 16 th century, the Swiss Confederation consisted of a conglomerate of brought to you by CORE View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk provided by RERO DOC Digital Library 2 autonomous counties which were connected by a network of alliances. 1 Depending on their positions, these counties were either fully autonomous or only allocated. Other parts of today's Switzerland were tributary districts of one or several of these counties. Until the end of the Middle Age, people in the counties naturally identified with the one and only Christian church. The splitting of belief of the churches in the wake of the Reformation was an important test for the system of alliances of the Confederation. Some of the counties turned to the Reformation, whereas others stayed with the old belief. To solve the conflict of belief in the common tributary districts, the first Landfriede (land peace) was concluded in Kappel near Zurich in 1529. This grew from the religious principle of territorial exclusivity (cuius regio, eius religio). The denominational variation among groups from from county to county was recognized on the level of the constitution. The living together of the two Christian denominations in the tributary districts nevertheless led to several armed conflicts. The complete constitutional equality of the two denominations (parity) in the tributary districts was not established until the fourth Landfriede (land peace) of 1712. In the fully autonomous counties, however, the denominational exclusivity remained until the end of the old Confederation in 1798. Whoever did not want to be part of the official religion could move away, but had to leave his possessions. Only a few protestant counties mercifully granted an ius emigrandi. Even until 1847, denominational disputes led to armed conflicts
Churches and Federal State in Europe: the paradigm of Germany and Switzerland
Stato, chiese e pluralismo confessionale, 2011
Facing a renewed role of religion in the public square, we can say that Germany and Switzerland are facing off a “positive secularism“ which implies, for the State legal system and for its institutions, the respect of religious facts, having its embodiment in the neutral and pluralistic acceptation of cultural differences and aiming at shaping their coexistence and the construction of their meaning. Positive secularism implies that the factual presence of religious confessions in the civil society is an essential condition to the positive start of a process of "secularisation of secularism", implying first of all the overcoming of political hegemony on every dimension of human experience - thing to which any thought open to the hypothesis of transcendence can effectively contribute. According to this concept, the secularism of a democratic State must free itself more and more from any ideological assumption, in order to open to cultural and religious pluralism and to let this pluralism become an instrument of promotion of the development of a person. For this reason, the State ruled by positive secularism cannot be completely indifferent to the religious phenomenon - even if it guarantees the free practice of religion by individuals - and only qualify confessions as simple expressions of the associative autonomy of private citizens.
Visibility or Invisibility: The Dilemma of the Muslim Associations of Switzerland
The Muslim associations of Switzerland are in the throes of a dilemma: should they remain invisible in order to avoid social stigmatization, or become visible in order to speak out and gain fair recognition? This invisibility especially relates to the local level and the impact and interactions that the associations have with their immediate environment. The visibility is characterized by the decision of the 'representative' associations to bring Muslims out of obscurity. It touches on the supra-local level of federal cantonal representation. The analysis in this article will illuminate the two levels of the dilemma, based on observations and interviews conducted with the Muslim religious communities of a large representative region of Switzerland. Keywords Muslim – Mosques – Visibility – Recognition – Switzerland
"Church and State in the Swiss Reformation"
Calvin Theological Journal, 2021
"Church and State in the Swiss Reformation," Calvin Theological Journal 56, no. 1 (April 2021): 11-36. The Swiss Reformation represents an intriguing crucible for both theoretical and practical manifestations of the perennial challenges of the relationship between church and state. Although many influential interpretations of the Reformation view it essentially as a liberation of the individual conscience from external control, the views of the magisterial reformers in Switzerland shared many points of fundamental agreement with the dominant tradition of the medieval tradition as well as the contemporary Roman Catholic church. A survey of the confessional standards in the Swiss context and its neighbors shows elements of continuity with the received tradition as well as diversity within Reformed confessional identity. The models of church and state associated with Zurich and Geneva can help to identify nuances and differing emphases. At the same time, the variety of Reformed approaches to the relationship of church and state-including church discipline and excommunication-provide important insights into the challenges of pluriformity not only in an early modern European setting but for succeeding eras as well.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.