Expressed Sexual Assault Legal Context and Victim Culpability Attributions (original) (raw)

2012, Journal of Interpersonal Violence

Legal scholars have argued that laws have an expressive function, specifically that sexual assault laws may convey social-level messages that victims are culpable for crimes against them. In a university sample, we conducted the first experimental test of legal scholars' proposal, hypothesizing that legal messages-specifically their clarity and effectiveness in conveying that sexual assault is a crime-affect victim culpability attributions. Results demonstrated that greater culpability was attributed to a victim of sexual assault within a context expressing unclear and ineffective sexual assault law than within a context clearly and effectively expressing that sexual assault is a crime. We also garnered empirical support for a mediation model, that is, negative affective reactions to a victim statistically accounted for the relationship between expressed legal context and victim culpability attributions. Implications for future psycholegal research and potential legal reforms are discussed. Keywords sexual assault, expressed legal context, victim culpability, victim blame Article Keith D. Markman is an associate professor of psychology at Ohio University, Athens, Ohio, United States, where he is a member of the Social Judgment and Behavioral Decision-Making program. He received his PhD in 1994 from Indiana University and completed a 3-year postdoctoral fellowship at the Ohio State University. He conducts research in the areas of counterfactual thinking, emotion and motivation, judgment and decision making, and psychological momentum, having published 40 articles and book chapters in these areas. He is currently an associate editor of Basic and Applied Social Psychology and Social and Personality Psychology Compass. He was nominated for the 2003 Theoretical Innovation Prize in social and personality psychology and won the outstanding junior faculty award at Ohio University in 2004. Amanda M. Amacker is a clinical psychology doctoral student at Sam Houston State University. Her research interests include social reactions to victims (specifically, culpability attributions), posttraumatic victim growth, and sexual assault psycholegal issues. Tasha A. Menaker earned a master's degree in clinical psychology from Sam Houston State University and is currently a doctoral student in Sam Houston State University's College of Criminal Justice. She is interested in the integration of psychology and public policy, particularly with regard to juvenile justice and the commercial sexual exploitation of children. Other research interests include gender issues and feminist criminology, forensic assessment, and violent crime and victimization.