Institutional Control of Faculty Research: Issues Emerging in the Academic Environment. ASHE Annual Meeting Paper (original) (raw)
Related papers
Institutional Control of Faculty Research: Issues Emerging in the Academic Environment. 2SHE Annual
2016
Changes in the institutional control of faculty behavior are examined, stressing that such control includes not only control by a faculty member's own university, but also, increasingly, regulation and othe- influences exerted by institutions outside the university. The review of the literature focuses on tays in which changes in the external environments of universities have affected professors ' research. These changes are considered from three perspectives: (1) complications associated with different types of external organizations--academic associations, the federal government, private industry, and the organized public; (2) issues related to different disciplinary sectors internal to the university; and (3) aspects of the relationship between external and internal parties based on two types of theories of organization-environment interaction--resource dependence and institutional theories. It is
The Practice of Institutional Research: Perception vs. Reality
1987
A pilot study was conducted to: examine the beliefs of Institutional Research (1R) managers and senior administrators concerning the function, purpose and priorities of IR; determine if beliefs have been translated into practice; ascertain the extent of congruence between perceptions and beliefs held at each level of management; any examine whether the beliefs of IR managers and current practices are consistent with what senior administrators believe should be the role of IR. Using a population of university centers and arts and sciences institutions in large, multi-campus, state-supported systems, 33 surveys were administered, 17 to IR managers (100% response rate) and 16 to senior administrators (64.7% response rate). Results included the following: (1) only 26.7% of IR managers and 54.5% of senior administrators believe that general institutional expectations are realistic and clear; (2) only 37.6% of IR managers and 72.7% of senior administrators believe that faculty members possess a positive perception of IR; (3) both groups believe that IR functions should include data collection, analysis and dissemination; state and federal reporting, policy-oriented research, serving as a clearinghouse for data, defining the institutional database and projecting enrollment; and (4) 100% of senior administrators and 73.3% of the IR managers believe that IR should measure outcomes. Data are provided in four tables. Contains 10 references. (KM) XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document. X
Research in Higher Education, 1989
Fragmentation in the academic profession derived from differences among academics in different types of colleges and universities suggests a need to identify possible compensatory integrating mechanisms. This study seeks to determine whether faculty conformity to the four norms of science identified by Merton are such integrating mechanisms or whether they are forces of further fragmentation. The 1977 Survey of the American Professorate conducted by Ladd and Lipset was the data source for this study. The results indicate that the norms of universalism and communality serve as a compensatory integrating mechanisms, while the norms of disinterestedness and organized skepticism function as forces of further fragmentation among academics in different types of colleges and universities.
2009
The chapter traces some relevant changes in the way research and teaching is performed in Brazilian higher education since the end of 1990s and the end of 2000s. Its focuses on exploring how institutional diversity as it is found in Brazilian higher education frames academics engagement on teaching and research. The chapter also explores how much these activities are prized by Brazilian academics in different institutional environment. Results from this analysis show that the efforts, started in the 1970s, to turn the academics in Brazil into researchers has succeeded in part in terms of beliefs, but do not seem to be converging in practice. Today, more than in the past, Brazilian academics believe that they should have a doctoral degree and get involved in research, and the incentives created by the national authorities go in that direction. However, in practice, only a minority of researchers in research institutes and in research-intensive public universities can meet these values and incentives. For the others, the alternative is either to give up, and place more emphasis on teaching, or to make some gestures signalling their adherence to the research ideals -attending conferences, writing research reports, and trying to publish an article every year so. The need to comply with the research ideal, and the instability to do so is a fertile ground to accommodation and cynicism, which can affect the quality of the missions higher education institutions are supposed to perform -teaching, research, and services.