HCI-Evaluation of the GeoCitizen-reporting App for citizen participation in spatial planning and community management among members of marginalized communities in Cali, Colombia (original) (raw)
Related papers
Nowadays, citizens increasingly make use of mobile devices to access the internet, share their geographic location and to get in touch with other users in their everyday life. The suggested geospatial web- platform (the GeoCitizen platform) takes advantage of these technological achievements and brings together citizens allowing them to collaboratively identify, report, discuss, solve and monitor problems in their living environment using one single web-platform that combines geo-web technologies and social media tools. Currently, the platform is implemented and tested in two case studies with two different problem focuses. The first case study refers to a rapidly growing suburban area of Quito, Ecuador where the platform helps citizens who are facing a lack of support by public administration to start their own participatory spatial planning initiatives. The second case study focus on Colombian smallholder farmers exposed to changing climates, in order to provide them with a collab...
The GeoCitizen-approach: community-based spatial planning – an Ecuadorian case study
Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 2014
Over the last years, geospatial web platforms, social media, and volunteered geographic information (VGI) have opened a window of opportunity for traditional Public Participatory GIS (PPGIS) to usher in a new era. Taking advantage of these technological achievements, this paper presents a new approach for a citizen-orientated framework of spatial planning that aims at integrating participatory community work into existing decision-making structures. One major cornerstone of the presented approach is the application of a social geoweb platform (the GeoCitizen platform) that combines geo-web technologies and social media in one single tool allowing citizens to collaboratively report observations, discuss ideas, solve, and monitor problems in their living environment at a local level. This paper gives an account of an ongoing participatory land-zoning process in the Capital District of Quito, Ecuador, where the GeoCitizen platform is applied in a long-term study.
ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information
Recent research indicates that information and communication technologies (ICTs) can support social participation in the planning, design and maintenance of public spaces (PDMPS), specifically to create comprehensive knowledge among different stakeholders. However, critics point out that the use of ICTs by planners and decision-makers often ignores the needs of local residents. For this research, we inquired how ICTs can support social participation in PDMPS. Our case study combines a literature review and 21 semi-structured interviews with government officials, non-governmental organisations, academics and architecture/urban planning consultancy companies in Mexico to understand how different stakeholders use ICTs to improve the quality of public spaces. We developed an approach that facilitates the analysis of ICT aspects related to hardware and software supporting social participation in PDMPS. The findings show that Mexico has a base of digital tools requiring technical capaciti...
2013
Town planning is highly a community initiative, if community efforts are sought-after in the most convenient approach, sustainable plans are produced. In this study, an interactive screen, pen and web 2.0 are used in an urban planning exercise to enhance public participation in Uganda. PPGIS applications are increasingly used in disciplines related to Geographic Information science in most parts of the world. However, developing countries with low technological advancements, experience only a glimpse of the GIS benefits. The study is based on a combination of traditional methods and a web 2.0, this is inspired by studies done by Al-kodmany 2001. The web application is developed from open source software, firstly because the software is readily availability, secondly to create a simple interface that is more user friendly and meets the aim of improving participation levels. The method follows a traditional community meeting, where participants gather to make comments about a neighbou...
ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information
Web-based participatory mapping technologies are being increasingly harnessed by local governments to crowdsource local knowledge and engage the public in urban planning policies as a means of increasing the transparency and legitimacy of planning processes and decisions. We refer to these technologies as “geoparticipation”. Current innovations are outpacing research into the use of geoparticipation in participatory planning practices. To address this knowledge gap, this paper investigates the objectives of web-based geoparticipation and uses empirical evidence from online survey responses related to 25 urban planning projects in nine countries across three continents (Europe, North America, and Australia). The survey adopts the objectives of the Spectrum for Public Participation that range from information empowerment, with each category specifying promises about how public input is expected to influence decision-making (IAP2, 2018). Our findings show that geoparticipation can leve...
2012
Citizens are very valuable observers of problems and conflicts that occur in their own living environment. In order to empower them to be part of the solution, especially in regions where the government lacks information, administrative power and transparency, the GeoCitizenframework allows citizens to identify, report, discuss, solve and monitor problems related to spatial planning and community services using a platform that merges geo-web technologies and social media in one single, comprehensive and interactive tool for participatory spatial planning at a local level. It establishes an open access entry point for every citizen to identify geographically a problem, connect to a thematically specific problem solving process, find collaborators in their neighborhood, get informed regarding the spatial context of the problem and related conflicts, reach experts and best practice role and process models, get aware of the spatially related synergies of both problem scopes and the reso...
Web-based geographic information systems and their usability
Usability of web-based geographic information systems (GIS) applications is very important because these applications are mostly focused on end users, i.e. on people who may have only a very limited knowledge of GIS, if any. Many various usability evaluation methods have been developed. Some of them involve real users or their representatives, some of them are based only on GIS experts evaluation. Advantage of deploying real users or at least their representatives is clear – they even can identify usability problems which need not to be identified as usability problems by experts. On the other side, usability evaluation in a real situation done by real users is quite difficult. Experimental user usability testing done by representatives of users is a next possibility. In this case environment is artificial and the whole experiment must be precisely conducted and controlled. In any case usability testing method must be precisely proposed for the given situation and conditions. Aim of...
Citizen Participation via Digital Maps: A Comparison of Current Applications
GI_Forum, 2019
The effects of digitization on social coexistence have been a subject of controversy not only since the increased use of social media for political campaigns. Digital platforms are also being developed which, from the perspective of spatial planning and geography, enhance communication between administrations and citizens at the local municipal level. These applications are being developed in relation to three areas: (1) the everyday experiences and competences of citizens in dealing with geomedia, especially the use of smartphones; (2) the individual process design for a particular participatory case; (3) the desired societal or local political benefit. This paper deals with these three aspects and discusses five selected examples of how digital participation platforms can be designed to include the use of geomedia. Based on experiences with the proprietary development of the web application PUBinPLAN in particular and on its comparison with other platforms, insights can be derived with regard to success factors as well as to opportunities and risks.
Australian Journal of Social Issues, 2020
It is increasingly common for urban planners and local policymakers to adopt interactive technologies, such as geographical information systems (GISs), to inform their decision making and to enhance performance. This paper aimed to assess the role that interactive technology can play in enhancing urban governance to meet social needs by improving local organisations' capacities, client access, and service effectiveness and responsiveness, as well as community building. Using the previous research framework on mapping community capacity developed by Brudney et al. (Community Development Journal, 2016, 52, 354) and C ߀ oltekin et al. (Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 2009, 36, 5-17), we examined a simulated online interactive map for service provision in Hong Kong and interviewed around 20 local community organisations and 100 local residents about their user experience, their willingness to support its long-term adoption and their challenges. Our findings reveal that local residents find the interactive map helpful, particularly in improving service access, whereas local organisations are more reluctant to adopt such technology due to high maintenance costs. The implications of our study include the need to develop incentives to encourage technology adoption, to improve the capacity of local organisations and to establish better links between community organisations and local residents to