A Study of User Perception, Interface Performance, and Actual Usage of Mobile Pedestrian Navigation Aides (original) (raw)
Related papers
Use and Perceptions of Pedestrian Navigation Apps: Findings from Bologna and Porto
ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information
Pedestrian Navigation Applications (PNAs) provide assistance in terms of self-localization, space recognition, and turn-by-turn navigation. The use, motivations and perceptions associated with these applications have been under investigated due to users being insufficiently involved in their design and development. This paper analyses the extent to which PNAs are used for assisting people to walk, the frequencies and reasons of using these applications, the perceptions about them, and the barriers preventing them from being used. The study is supported by a questionnaire (N = 1438) that was administered in Bologna (Italy) and Porto (Portugal). Results indicated that 42% of the respondents use PNAs mainly on an occasional basis to find locations and the shortest routes. Google Maps was the preferred navigation service. Statistical tests showed that PNAs were more likely to be used by younger adults and students. The lack of need was the main reason for not using these apps, due to th...
Impact of navigation tools on pedestrian navigation: preliminary results
Impact of navigation tools on pedestrian navigation: preliminary results, 2019
Since some experiments analyzed the impact of navigation tools on pedestrian navigation (Ishikawa, Fujiwara, Imai & Okabe 2008; Wang & Worboys 2016) little research has studied how interactive devices between mobile participants can possibly transform their cognitive maps. After many years of interactive artistic experiences between participants in distant cities, the goal of the present research is a better understanding of the links between mental, instrumental and shared maps. The question is whether connected and dynamic applications renew our shared mental representations of urban spaces. We will approach the notion of mental maps (introduced by Tolman) in its individual and collective dimensions with regard to the new uses created by connecting devices. Hypothesis: new access to cartographic tools is likely to produce new kinds of individual mental representations. Method: in these preliminary results, the objective is to compare the mental maps evidenced by maps drawn after the exploration of a single urban district between 2 groups of participants: 1) a group of individuals equipped simply with a passive GPS tracking tool, 2) a group of individuals equipped with an urban navigation application (Google maps). Measurements will include: 1) Comparison of landmarks hierarchies, 2) Comparison of routes traces and icons, 3) Direct comparison by distances between geographical landmarks and drawing landmarks by superposition of the two kinds of maps, 4) Relative comparison between internal distances in geographical landmarks and internal distances between drawings landmarks. We will compare the two groups relative to these measurements. In these preliminary investigations, and contrary to some assumptions (Ishikawa, Wang) we cannot find obvious confirmation that pedestrian users of Google maps have worse results from cognitive mapping that others without this device.
Pedestrian navigation aids: information requirements and design implications
Personal and Ubiquitous …, 2003
Recent years have seen an increased interest in navigational services for pedestrians. To ensure that these services are successful, it is necessary to understand the information requirements of pedestrians when navigating, and in particular, what information they need and how it is used. A requirements study was undertaken to identify these information requirements within an urban navigation context. Results show that landmarks were by far the most predominant navigation cue, that distance information and street names were infrequently used, and that information is used to enable navigation decisions, but also to enhance the pedestrianÕs confidence and trust. The implications for the design of pedestrian navigation aids are highlighted.
2007 4th Workshop on Positioning, Navigation and Communication, 2007
Context-enabled applications are more and more establishing on the market. A key feature for those tools is the ability to connect the current user state and position to possible activities nearby. Thus it is crucial to a mobile application to be able helping the tourists to find and guide them to appropriate activities. This paper will separately address the navigational component and evaluate the efficiency of several systems currently available. All of these systems are based on current state of the art approaches and are easily expandable to different locations meaning there isn't any adaptation needed, running the system in other cities. At the end the paper will come up with a recommendation for the most suited system to be integrated into mobile applications under current conditions.
Assessing the Usability of a Wearable Computer System For Outdoor Pedestrian Navigation
The paper outlines a pilot test on the UCSB Wearable Computer developed in conjunction with Project Battuta. The UCSB Wearable incorporates geographic context information (location and orientation) to display an electronic digital map to a user via a Heads-Up Display (HUD). Features of the custom designed Geographic Referenced Graphic Environment (GEORGE) software allow the user to switch between types of maps, and automatically center and rotate the map. The pilot study used pre and post-experiment questionnaires, performance records and interaction logs to evaluate which aspects of the system were most useful both in terms of user attitudes and objective performance on a navigation task. Zoom, pan and auto-rotate features were shown to be well used, while subjects showed indifference to map type and perspective view options. Performance on the wayfinding task generally improved over each segment of the trial, with subjects approaching normal walking speeds at the end of the trial.
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE), 2020
Fast-paced mobile technology development has permitted augmented reality experiences to be delivered on mobile pedestrian navigation context. The fact that the more prevalent of this technology commonly will substituting the digital map visualization to present the geo-location information is still debatable. This paper comprises a report on a field study comparing about user experience when interacting with different modes of mobile electronic assistance in the context of pedestrian navigation interfaces which utilize location-based augmented reality (AR) and two-dimensional digital map to visualize the points of interest (POIs) location in the vicinity of the user. The study was conducted with two subsequent experiments in the Zhongli District, Taoyuan City, Taiwan. The study involved 10 participants aged between 22 and 28 years with different experiences in using smartphones and navigation systems. Navigation performance was measured based on a usability approach on pragmatic quality and hedonic quality like effectiveness (success rate of task completion), efficiency (task completion time) and satisfaction in real outdoor conditions. The evaluation findings have been cross-checked with the user's personal comments. We aim at eliciting knowledge about user requirements related to mobile pedestrian interfaces and evaluating user experience from pragmatic and hedonic viewpoints. Results show that in the context of pedestrian navigation, digital map interfaces lead to significantly better navigation performance in pragmatic attributes in comparison to AR interfaces. Nevertheless, the study also reveals that location-based AR is more valued by participants in hedonic qualities and overall performance.
Navitime: Supporting Pedestrian Navigation in the Real World
IEEE Pervasive Computing, 2007
PERVASIVE computing 29 the AUTHORS Masatoshi Arikawa is an associate professor at the Center for Spatial Information Science at the University of Tokyo. His research interests include cartography, spatial information technology, databases, virtual reality, user interfaces, and developing new spatial communication tools to enhance people's spatial ability. He received his PhD in computer science and communication engineering from Kyushu University. He's the chair of the Geographic Information Systems Association's special interest group on Spatial Information Technology. He's a member
TASclient: An accessible Application for Pedestrian Navigation
2006
This paper describes an application for pedestrian navigation and its implementation using JAVA J2ME CDC Personal Profile. TASclient is one part of a distributed assistance system for mobility impaired persons.[1] Based on an user profile a personalised route planning can be used to find the best path to a certain goal or to find a way around the most interesting tourist locations.[2] The application described in this paper is designed to match the requirements of peoples with different kinds of impairments while offering not only navigation details but also information about points of interest. Special attention is turned on techniques to overcome the limitations of small hand-held devices.
Towards More Universal Wayfinding Technologies: Navigation Preferences Across Disabilities
Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
Accessibility researchers have been studying wayfinding technologies for people with disabilities for decades, typically focusing on solutions within disability populations-for example, technologies to support blind navigation. Yet, we know little about wayfinding needs across disabilities. In this paper, we describe a qualitative interview study examining the urban navigational experiences of 27 people who identified as older adults and/or who had cognitive, visual, hearing, and/or mobility disabilities. We found that many navigation route preferences were shared across disabilities (e.g., desire to avoid carpeted areas), while others diverged or were in tension (e.g., the need to avoid noisy areas while staying near main thoroughfares). To support design for multiple disability groups, we identify four dimensions of navigation preferences-technology, route, assistance, experience-and describe how these might usefully inform design of more universally usable wayfinding technologies.