Rediscovering the Law of Negligence. By Allan Beever. [Oxford: Hart Publishing. 2007. xxxi, 515, (bibliography) 10, and (index) 4 pp. Hardback £50.00. ISBN 981841136868.] (original) (raw)

Few commentators would express satisfaction with the current state of the tort of negligence. The case-law is unpredictable, lacks clarity and the tests provided applied in an inconsistent manner. It is easy to blame such uncertainty on the desire of the judges to achieve 'justice'. In White v Jones, Lord Goff accepted that 'The question therefore arises whether it is possible to give effect in law to the strong impulse for practical justice. .. For this to be achieved. .. the court will have to fashion "an effective remedy".' 1 Lord Bingham in Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd (t/a GH Dovener & Son) demonstrated that such an approach is far from unique. 2 In so doing, the judiciary demonstrate a willingness to look far beyond the case itself and consider its wider implications to society as a whole. 3 Yet, in so doing, recognition is still made of the need for such decisions to exist within a doctrinal framework. In Fairchild, Lord Nicholls stated: 'To be acceptable the law must be coherent. It must be principled. The basis on which one case, or one type of case, is distinguished from another should be transparent and capable of identification. When a decision departs from principles normally applied, the basis for doing so must be rational and justifiable if the decision is to avoid the reproach that hard cases make bad law'. 4 The question remains whether the current state of the tort of negligence is a natural result of its breadth as a tort or represents 'the disintegration of the modern law'. In his book, Beever asserts the latter view. In a forceful thesis, he argues that the current lack of transparency, uncertainty and, he claims, illegitimate assertion by individual judges of policy concerns, can be avoided. One simply needs to 'rediscover' the principled basis of the tort. To do so he focuses on five "great" cases: