Investment Processes or Information Technologies Investment Evaluation. Information Technology Evaluation Practices in … (original) (raw)
Related papers
From our point of view, we consider that evaluation is another aspect of the IT implementation process, which permits us to justify the investment to be carried out, to choose between different alternatives, to serve as an instrument of control over the implementation process, over its costs and benefits and, in short, over the success of the project. However, there are in practice some difficulties in evaluating all of the costs and benefits associated to IT investments, and especially in the long term prospect. Moreover, the evaluation constitutes an aspect that, in economic crisis situations and in the context of SMEs, acquires, if one might say so, more importance. Therefore, in this work we intend to find out how Andalusian SMEs carry out their IT investment process, which will permit us to contribute empirical evidence of the evaluation practices of IT projects in this type of enterprises, which haven't been sufficiently researched in the empirical studies carried out conc...
Management of information technology evaluation – the development of a managerial thesis
The aim is to address the approach and identify the assessment of the effectiveness of IT investment used by organisations, to develop a thesis of good practice in this area; and to test this thesis by reference to a focus group consisting of practitioners.The research began using the case study method to collect evidence and then content analysis was employed to analyse this evidence to identify empirical generalisations and thus develop a theory of IT investment, IT investment evaluation and IT benefit identification. Correspondence analysis was used on the case study data as one step in establishing the theory. A focus group was used to present the relevant theory and the models that were created. Finally, the practical management guidelines suggested by the research and the models and content analysis figures were presented to practitioners as a cross-validation process and the results reported. The results of this research are an objectively developed theory of how IT investments are formulated and evaluated and how IT investment benefits are identified.
A Concept of Information Technology Investment Evaluation Framework
The need for the current application of Information Technology has led to an increase in corporate spending to invest in Information Technology. The most common issue for companies that want to implement systems and Information Technology is the magnitude of the risks and costs that must be incurred. IT investments have special characteristics, which are high risk, considerable cost, and the perceived benefits are largely intangible. This also applies to companies located in developing countries, especially Indonesia. A common problem that makes IT investment difficult in Indonesia is the imbalance of costs and benefits and the results are very uncertain. The existence of problems related to the difficulty of making IT investment is the reason for the need to evaluate IT investment. The IT investment evaluation is not only limited to knowing whether the investment is feasible or not, but also prioritizing the investment. Information Economics (IE) method is a comprehensive method used to analyze the feasibility of IT investment. However, in Indonesia alone there is no method that can directly prioritize IT investment with the criteria that have been set in accordance with the needs of developing countries. Based on these problems, this study aims to provide a prioritized IT investment framework that will be implemented in one company in Indonesia, which uses components in the IE method as criteria for prioritization. Using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) method to weight and compile the IT investment prioritize framework tailored to the needs of companies in Indonesia. This research uses a qualitative method and the result of this research is a prioritization hierarchy framework based on IE component. Through the prioritization of IT investment framework, it is expected to improve the accuracy of IT investment decisions to support the company's business processes, especially in Indonesia. It is also expected to answer the problems that occurred during this time related to the unbalanced funds needed and funds issued.
A strategy-based method of assessing information technology investments
Purpose -The purpose of the paper is to present a theoretical framework and the preliminary results of a research on how to assess information technology (IT) investments so as to deliver maximum business value. Design/methodology/approach -To see whether IT projects fit strategy, the Strategy Map provides a framework for defining the portfolio value and data envelopment analysis (DEA) is used to measure the efficiency of project portfolios. Subsequently, an application that illustrates the value of the framework is described. Findings -The authors offer a framework that integrates the Strategy Map and IT project portfolio management (PPM) and suggest that this conceptual framework will allow an organization to enhance the value of IT investments. Research limitations/implications -This paper is supported by a case study using secondary data only. Practical implications -The suggested method could help CEOs to understand the interactions between projects and strategy and thus supports decision making to prioritize and track IT investments. The paper illustrates how the proposed framework is applied. It also provides the basis for further research. Originality/value -By explicitly linking IT investment with organizational goals, this approach produces results that differ from those of previous studies and provides a strategy-based approach to PPM.
Investment i IT Managing Investment in Information Technology: Mini Case Examples and Implications
2016
While businesses are investing enormous re-sources in information technology (IT), there little evidence linking IT investment to organiza-tional performance. The purpose of this article, therefore, is to increase understanding of the basis for IT investment in firms. Six mini case studies of companies in five different industries address questions of how they define IT for the purpose of determining the level of investment, how they track IT investments, and what other factors influence IT investment decisions. Each organization uses a different definition of IT, but there appears to be an overall trend to broaden the definition. Although companies track IT investment with varying degrees of rigor, they appear to be generally moving toward centralized tracking of all IT investment. Political considerations are important and sig-nificantly impact investment decisions. In all cases, the effectiveness with which IT invest-ment is converted to useful output is acknowl-edged to be affec...
IT INVESTMENT EVALUATION PRACTICE: USING A.N.T FOR ANALYSIS IN MALAYSIAN LOCAL AUTHORITIES.
This research is to understand how evaluation is being used in managing IT investment. IT investment evaluation is an area to investigate mainly in the rise of computerized information system usage that rapidly growing with the support of latest technology, customer’s demand and investment by the organization. In fact, it is not completely understood and valued by organization or government. In order to be competent, the evaluation should be assessed and justified. However, its implementation is hazy yet few organizations are aware of such evaluation implementation. Evaluation research is inadequate in public sectors and hardly reported especially in Malaysia. Actor Network Theory (ANT) is used to study the agents involved in IT evaluation practices and determine the influence of evaluation practices in local authority in Malaysia. In addition, this research will identify the impact of evaluation methodology employment towards the current issues from the ANT perspectives. This qualitative study approach was conducted in local authorities, focusing on pre and post evaluation of information system invested. ANT offered heterogeneity in describing and understanding the interrelationship of socio-technical aspect in IT investment evaluation analysis for Malaysian local authority. The findings revealed that lack of formal IT investment evaluation, low awareness level on the importance of evaluation, less exposure on the evaluation methodology and inappropriate appraisals of the proposed IT investment projects caused certain local authorities unable to deliver the benefits expected. With lack of formal IT evaluation, organization loses benefits and waste resources.
Use of Knowledge in ICT Investment Decision-Making of SMEs
2007
Purpose -In this paper we discuss how managers use knowledge when making ICT investment decisions. ICT investments are complex processes and also have strategic implications for organizations. The focus of the study is to reveal how the organizational process of knowledge creation affects the individual-level of decision making and how knowledge conversions between tacit and explicit knowledge occur in this process.
IT investment evaluation: why hasn't it become an organization routine?
2006
In this study we attempt to understand why formal evaluations of IT investment projects have not yet become an organizational routine. Using survey data gathered from business and IT managers in Sweden, we tested the research hypotheses about the factors influencing the attitudes and behaviour of managers towards using formal evaluation methods based on the theory of planned behaviour. We found that the intent to use formal evaluation methods in an organization is determined by the attitudes of the managers towards the formal methods, the common beliefs of the organization about the formal methods, and the perceived ability to perform formal evaluations. Interestingly, we found that the attitudes toward formal methods are determined mostly by the perceived usefulness of the methods and not by the perceived ease of use of these methods, suggesting that the decision to use formal methods is most likely based on rational analyses rather than individual preferences. We also found that a...