The moratorium on loan repayments during the Covid-19 Pandemic in Europe: a comparative analysis of loan moratoria in selected European countries (original) (raw)
Related papers
Experiences with the Introduction of a Payment Moratorium in Hungary
Financial and Economic Review, 2021
The payment moratorium, which was introduced in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic in Hungary as well, has become an internationally widespread crisis management tool. In our study, we analyse the demographic and income characteristics of bank clients who have participated in the payment moratorium and the direct impact of the payment moratorium on the liquidity of debtors and on bank profitability. The analysis is based on transaction-level data available to the Magyar Nemzeti Bank (the Central Bank of Hungary, MNB) that is detailed in international comparison as well. Based on our examination, the payment moratorium has proven to be an effective tool for mitigating the short-term default risk of potentially vulnerable debtors. It has also provided significant additional liquidity at the level of the national economy to offset the negative impacts of the pandemic, while causing only moderate direct costs at the level of the banking system. On the whole, the payment moratorium can be considered an effective and efficient crisis management tool for exogenous economic shocks similar to the coronavirus pandemic, which is also confirmed by its international prevalence.
Does Banks’ Moratorium Alleviate the Burden of Borrowers? Case of the Pandemic COVID-19
Malaysian Journal of Business and Economics (MJBE)
The COVID-19 crisis has devastatingly affected the Small and Medium Enterprise (SMEs) cash flow. Subsequently, the employee was laid off as the SMEs could not sustain themselves. To address these issues, governments globally embrace moratoriums to alleviate the hardship. However, there is a clash between the borrowers' expectations, the government agenda, and the current banking system. Therefore, this study undertakes a study on why there is a need for Islamic financial institutions to undertake a similar approach to conventional banking in discharging their moratoriums. In addition, the study shall also suggest possible alternatives that would protect both the customers' and the Banks' interests while upholding Maqasid-Shariah. The study applies a case study approach. The primary data was collected through in-depth interviews. The applied thematic analysis (ATA) was then employed in analyzing the narrative provided by the participants. The findings conclude that the mo...
Białostockie Studia Prawnicze, 2021
The COVID-19 pandemic restrictions introduced in 2020 in many countries on economic activity and gainful employment have in many cases, reduced the incomes of individual households. As a result, the actual ability to meet credit obligations has declined, particularly for those who have lost their jobs or livelihoods. The COVID-19 pandemic has become a significant challenge for economies, national authorities, and entrepreneurs, including borrowers. This article aims to analyse the legal regulations in Poland, and Vietnam, introducing instruments to support borrowers, consumers, and entrepreneurs, in connection with the COVID-19 pandemic. The authors will present the legal basis for the instruments to support borrowers provided in the studied countries, indicate their legal nature, forms, and conditions of using them. They also compare legal solutions introduced in connection with the pandemic aimed at mitigating its adverse effects on borrowers in Poland, and Vietnam, to indicate wh...
Early Repayment of Loans Under EU Law: The Lexitor Judgment
SSRN Electronic Journal
Recent changes in EU law provide flexibility and protection to consumers, facilitating early repayment of loans, when the consumer is no longer interested in continuing a credit relationship. From an economic point of view, early repayment of loans should be facilitated, because it allows money that is no longer needed to be put to other desirable uses. Under current EU law, as recently interpreted in the Lexitor judgment by the Court of Justice of the European Union, upon early repayment of a loan, consumers can obtain a pro-rated reimbursement of all the up-front and recurring costs of the loan, including origination fees and ancillary service costs. In this brief article, we take a critical look at the current EU approach to this issue, suggesting that, while the legislature made the pragmatic choice in permitting partial reimbursement of up-front costs, this leads to several economic inefficiencies that can ultimately hurt the consumer. Repayment of up-front costs, and of any other sunk cost associated with the creation of the loan, can lead to a suboptimal mix of lending contracts. Some consumers could, in fact, take out a lower interest rate long-term credit, even though they may only need a short-term loan, and this would create a disadvantage for the overall class of consumers. In order to actually protect the economic interest of consumers and carry out the intent of the legislature, we conclude that the up-front costs for non-mandatory ancillary services (such as brokerage fees, etc.) should not be included in the costs that are eligible for reimbursement in the event of early repayment of the loan. By excluding these costs, consumers will not be incentivized to overconsume such services, minimizing the negative externalities imposed on other consumers. 8 See, eg, Intesa Sanpaolo, 'Information on risks and relative hedging policies', available at https://tinyurl.com/t262ujx6 (last visited 30 June 2021) (stating that it believed the Italian banking law Article 125-sexies could not be interpreted in a manner that complies with the Lexitor ruling and that while it would comply, it 'reserves the right to reconsider this operational stance in light of future developments'); Prawo, 'Polish banks are disregarding the Court of Justice of the European Union judgment regarding loans; Civil Rights Ombusman set to intervene', available at https://tinyurl.com/54nvvyzs (last visited 30 June 2021) (discussing that some Polish banks 'are proving loath to refund all the costs incurred by them' despite the CJEU's decision). 9 Case C-383/18, n 6 above, paras 33-34, 55, 63-65, 68. In para 53 of his Opinion, the Advocate General stated that the rule establishing that up-front costs are not reimbursable while
International Journal of Engineering Business and Social Science
Online loans during the Covid 19 pandemic have caused serious problems because of the many threats, extortion and even leakage of personal data by illegal online loan companies. However, that doesn't mean that legal online loans don't have their own problems. The author then conducts research to understand the causes of this phenomenon from the point of view of normative juridical analysis. The results of the study show that the legal system in Indonesia does not provide adequate legal protection so that people are not encouraged or forced to apply for online loans. In addition, the legal protection system from the government to the community and online loan debtors has not been properly systemized.
Realizing Justice through the Credit Restructuring Policy Due to The Spread of Covid-19
2020
This study aims to find an overview of the bank credit restructuring policy and the realization of the fair value of the government policy. The stimulus provided was in the form of restructuring bank credit due to the spread of Covid-19. The research method used is a normative juridical research method with a statutory approach and a conceptual approach. This study uses secondary legal data in the form of primary legal materials, namely POJK No. 11 / POJK.03 / 2020, and secondary legal materials, namely books, journals, and other literature related to research problems. Based on the results of the study, it is known that the credit restructuring policy is an attempt by the government to provide legal protection for bank debtors who cannot fulfill their obligations to banks due to the spread of Covid-19. The realization of the value of justice in this credit restructuring policy is felt by all parties, the bank, and especially the debtor. The existence of a bank credit restructuring ...
Pena Justisia: Media Komunikasi dan Kajian Hukum
The purpose of this research is to identify and analyze Covid-19 as a form of comparative advantage and the consequences of the advantage method in loan agreements and loan termination policies due to the Covid-19 pandemic. The research method is norm-law. It is a legal research method that examines and studies the provisions of legislation as a basis for subsequent analysis of the issues discussed. The research uses primary and secondary legal material for analysis through the study of relevant documents and literature. The analysis is a qualitative analysis that addresses the question in question. According to the research, Covid-19 is an unnatural disaster and thus can be classified as a measure of superiority. As a priority relationship, the laws governing the spread of Covid-19 result in a priority relationship with the loan agreement, which means that the debtor must continue to meet his obligations to the debtor even after Covid-19 is over. When it was implemented following P...
Financial Crises and EU Credit Access Policy
Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks, 2016
The Palgrave Studies in Impact Finance series provides a valuable scientific 'hub' for researchers, professionals and policy makers involved in impact finance and related topics. It includes studies in the social, political, environmental and ethical impact of finance, exploring all aspects of impact finance and socially responsible investment, including policy issues, financial instruments, markets and clients, standards, regulations and financial management, with a particular focus on impact investments and microfinance. v Contents List of Boxes xi List of Charts xii List of Figures xiv List of Tables xv
Strategy to Combat the Unintended Non-Performing Loans During COVID-19: An Impact Analysis
• Hiteshkumar Thakkar, Makkar, S. & Goyat, P. (2022). “Strategy to Combat the Unintended Non-Performing Loans during Covid-19: An Impact Analysis”, pp. 61–78, Journal of Economic Policy & Research, Volume 17, Issue 2. [ISSN: 0975-8577], 2022
COVID-19-the sorrow of the world, the melancholy of 2020-2021, has not left any sector untouched. It has impacted the world economically and financially. In this paper, we have analysed the economic impact of COVID-19 with a specific attention on Non-performing Loans (NPLs). There has been a catena of policies of Govt. of India to mitigate the impact of the pandemic on Creditors. The reasonable prudent policy would protect a genuine borrower who is not capable pay its due to the adverse effects of pandemic but default can sometimes be intended and deliberate. In this paper we have analysed the probable impact of intended NPL and unintended NPL on the financial system. The objective of the policy makers should be to restrict economy to the efficient NPLs or low risk NPLs. But there can be some evaluating errors and other cross dynamic events which might lead to systemic unintended NPL or moderate risk NPL stage. In such cases, the policy makers should do advanced preparatory planning in order to restrict NPL to moderate risk and not allow the system to reach high risk NPL stage. In this paper we discuss a model which provides framework of intended NPL stage and unintended NPL and the respective consequences of both. Finally, the paper provides policy implication with regards to restraint NPL in the low risk NPL category.
Insolvency Law in the EU: New Thoughts on Old Ideas in the Wake of the COVID-19 Pandemic
International Insolvency Review, 2021
The COVID-19 crisis, which hit the world with full force in 2020, represents one of the greatest health and economic crises in recent history. The pandemic paralysed the world economy, forcing many countries around the globe to take emergency measures. Countries’ emergency responses to the crisis uncovered a tension between the continuous phenomenon of global economic interdependence and the tendency for nation-state governance during the crisis. Although this dichotomy was quite acute in the European Union (EU) at the onset of the pandemic – reflected overall by Member States’ preferences for national solutions over common multilateral solutions – governments eventually converged towards similar responses to the spread of the virus. These responses to the crisis included partial or total isolation of populations, travel bans, and the temporary closure of non-essential businesses. This so-called phenomenon of ‘copycat coronavirus policies’ was the result of regulatory emulation, which occurred spontaneously, with limited direct impetus from the EU. Our paper investigates whether insolvency and restructuring laws, policies, and measures followed a similar pattern. The study focuses on six selected European countries: Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom (UK). From a methodological perspective, our contribution relies on a case study approach. Building on the findings of this case study, our paper, then, draws more general conclusions on the process of harmonisation across the EU.