A Multi-level Review of Engineering Ethics Education: Towards a Socio-technical Orientation of Engineering Education for Ethics (original) (raw)
Related papers
Curriculum analysis of ethics in engineering: a case study
DYNA
For several decades, there have been warnings about certain ethical faults in engineers regarding corruption in different works, which lead to collapses and the death of people, calling engineering into question and affecting the social development of communities. Ethics is an educational responsibility, the ethical debate must take place inside and outside the classroom, since studies carried out in different universities indicate that ethics continues to be a pending subject in engineering programs. This study seeks to contribute to educational innovation for the teaching of ethics in engineering through documentary review and interviews with students and teachers. It was found that the education of ethics in engineering should be included in the curriculum as an important factor in the training of engineers, from a practical dimension, which includes the study of cases, moral dilemmas, and based on problems applied to the environment.
Meeting the ethics challenge in engineering education: re-accreditation and beyond
Conference on Frontiers in Education, 2004
Our experience has shown that one of the most effective and efficient ways to meet the ABET EC 2000 ethics challenge is a program of ethics across the curriculum integrated with an elective stand alone course in engineering ethics. In this presentation we describe the tools and strategies we have used to foster ethics across the curriculum in engineering at our university and to instantiate its continuous improvement. We highlight faculty training by focusing on the two-day workshop we have developed that has proven to be effective in providing engineering faculty with the skills to enable them to integrate ethics into mainstream engineering courses. We argue that our approach effectively fosters the ethics integration aimed at by ABET criteria. An integral part of our approach has been the use of ethics tests which allow for the integration of ethical considerations into engineering decisions and projects without requiring that engineers master the underlying ethical theory.
Repositioning ethics at the heart of engineering graduate attributes
Australasian Journal of Engineering Education
The integration of ethics in engineering education has largely been focused at the curriculum design level. The authors posit that this integration be done at the accreditation level and investigate how ethics may be more extensively incorporated in the documentation of a particular engineering accreditation body's qualification standards. The paper proceeds, by means of a narrative review, to justify an expanded conception of the teaching of ethics within engineering education. It builds a synthesis of contrasting conceptual approaches to the teaching of ethics within engineering and proposes a conceptual framework to guide both regulators and educators to identify and engage with different elements of the ethics across the curriculum within an engineering programme. The South African case study provides a context to engage with existing policy formulation around programme accreditation and to demonstrate the application of the proposed conceptual framework across the graduate attributes so to indicate how ethics might be more comprehensively integrated within a programme. This demonstrates that ethics needs to be repositioned at the centre of the preparation of engineers, rather than at the periphery. The expected consequence of this integration is the more extensive incorporation of ethics within and across accredited engineering programmes.
INTEGRATING ETHICS INTO ENGINEERING EDUCATION
Ethics and professional conduct are vital to engineering undergraduate curricula. Many programs struggle to ensure that students are given exposure to and appreciation of ethical and professional conduct issues. Ethics in engineering practice is about professional responsibilities of engineers. Professional ethics have been recognized as an important foundation in the practice of engineering for several decades in Malaysia. Codes of ethics have been invoked as a basis for professional engineering licensure. Violations of such ethical codes have led to many well-known tragic engineering failures that endangered human life and jeopardized public welfare. Generally engineering education produces technically competent graduates by demanding extensive and rigorous course and laboratory work. However, there is a demand to equip the graduate with soft skills to become a holistic, dynamic and multi-skill engineer as future leaders in the industry. In order to ensure the graduates engage in a life-long pattern of ethical and professional behavior, College of Engineering (COE) has taken a pro-active measures by providing them with a correspondingly deep education in (i) the underlying theory and practice of ethics and professionalism (as taught from an engineering perspective), (ii) historical or case study context along with the impact of technology on society and (iii) PBL approach for professional development in engineering education strategy that enable students to evaluate a given scenario, identify, search & gather relevant information, work in teams, reason and justify to form opinions, apply various known tools, convince others and reflect regularly on whatever they do. Hence, the engineering program will definitely meet EAC criteria related to ethics and professionalism. This paper describes an experience to develop engineering ethics in engineering student. This experience was part of the upgrading of the engineering undergraduate curriculum, at College of Engineering, with a systematic program design to develop the ethics in students while studying at UNITEN. In this paper we also identify resource materials, background information, a syllabus, and outline for teaching a course on professional and ethical aspects of engineering education. Results indicate that most students after taking Engineers in Society (EIS) subject will be more tactful in making decision when face with moral dilemma due to appropriate preparation to face these issues through EIS subject and highly appreciated having a course at university that would assist them to handle moral and engineering dilemma in future.
Ethics in Engineering Education
1. ABSTRACT Assessment data from internal and external stakeholders show that professional ethics is one of the top six desirable general education outcomes for graduates of Indiana Tech. A pilot study was conducted to determine the current level of professional ethics among traditional and adult learners in an eng ineering program. S tatistical tools were used to explore the similarities and differences in ethical perceptions among the sample groups. The survey included an analysis of the students' perceptions of themselves and others in nineteen different situations. The survey and subsequent release of results allowed for on- going engagement of engineering students in discussions regarding professional ethics. 2. LITERATURE REVIEW Research conducted to compare the ethical differences between accounting majors versus business majors found that there were no significant differences (Atlow and Ulrich, 1980). However, one study determined that accountants did score lower than t...
2020
This thesis explores the treatment of ethics within engineering education and practice under a sustainability guise. The approach taken has been to consider influences of rationality, power and ideology in shaping modern society and in framing the treatment of ethics within both engineering education and engineering practice. There is also a consideration of how those influences then shape and Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction Background and Rationale for Study
Learning and Teaching Ethics in Engineering: Preparing Engineering Faculty to Teach Ethics
Through assessment processes recently put into place, many engineering departments at Penn State identified a need to enhance the ethics components of their curricula. To support departments in their enhancement processes, the College of Engineering worked with the College of the Liberal Arts to create a faculty development program to prepare engineering faculty to teach ethics, entitled, "Learning and Teaching Ethics in Engineering." The program was designed to allow engineering faculty to gain some background in ethics and to develop ethics activities for their courses and methods for assessing them. This paper provides a description of the program, a summary of the learning objectives, instructional approaches, assessment methods developed by the participants, and a summary of the assessments of the effectiveness of the program. CEE, 3 required junior level courses, 1 sophomore level course, and 3 first year seminars. These courses enroll approximately 1000 engineering students annually.
A Model For Integrating Ethics Into An Engineering Curriculum
2009
Ethics education is currently of major concern in higher education and in engineering in particular. There are many reasons for this, such as the seeming increase of cheating and plagiarism among students. Simultaneously, the level of trust in public and private institutions, in terms of the honesty and integrity of those in leadership, is dwindling. For engineers, whose occupation allows them potential for positive or negative societal impacts, it is critical that their decisions involve sound ethical judgment. Despite this obvious need, the amount of time given to ethics in an engineering curriculum is minimal. With all the knowledge and skills needed in engineering, it seems as if there is neither time nor space to teach ethics. Consequently, the results are predictable. During a recent meeting of engineering students, the students were asked what kinds of ethical questions they encountered at work or in their studies. The majority indicated they had never encountered any ethical...
Thinking ethics differently (challenges and opportunities for engineers education)
Independent Journal of Management & Production, 2021
Ethics has many definitions, each depending on its domain. In the ancient times, ethics was based on the principles of good action and the search for the common good. Generally, Ethics is understood as a system of moral principles which affect our ways of living. Ethics are related with what is good for society and individuals and is described as moral philosophy. Ethics only makes sense if we put them in the context of human action understood as responsible, creative and communicative. Applied Ethics and Codes of conducts have appeared in the contemporary period. One of the key issues in the engineering education ethics program is the problem of margins/limits of autonomy that will enable future engineers to act ethically in accordance with universal ethical principles and the existing codes of ethics. Computer ethics adds the intellectual property rights, and also the use of personal data. The paper shows a general review of ethics, its history, its evolution, with an emphasis on...
Broadening Ethics Teaching in Engineering: Beyond the Individualistic Approach
Science and Engineering Ethics, 2011
There is a widespread approach to the teaching of ethics to engineering students in which the exclusive focus is on engineers as individual agents and the broader context in which they do their work is ignored. Although this approach has frequently been criticised in the literature, it persists on a wide scale, as can be inferred from accounts in the educational literature and from the contents of widely used textbooks in engineering ethics. In this contribution we intend to: (1) Restate why the individualistic approach to the teaching of ethics to engineering students is inadequate in view of preparing them for ethical, professional and social responsibility; (2) Examine the existing literature regarding the possible contribution of Science, Technology and Society (STS) scholarship in addressing the inadequacies of the individualistic approach; and (3) Assess this possible contribution of STS in order to realise desired learning outcomes regarding the preparation of students for ethical and social responsibility.