The role of school-based teacher incentives to improve student achievement : experiences from selected secondary schools in Manicaland Province, Zimbabwe (original) (raw)
Related papers
Teacher incentives: a death knell for education in Zimbabwe?
2011
Government is failing to pay teachers sustainable salaries. In an attempt to improve the teacher’s incomes and to check strikes and brain drain, The Government through circular minute number 5 of 2009, directed that ten percent (10%) of the levies collected by schools should go towards paying teacher’s incentives. This led to an outcry in the media by both parents and teachers. This study set out to establish the problems that emanated from the payment of the 10% incentives at local level. One hundred and fifty (150) questionnaires were distributed to teachers who were conveniently sampled among 1200 teachers who were marking the ZIMSEC November 2009 O level examinations at Chinhoyi University of Technology. Interviews were conducted with 30 parents who were conveniently sampled from 100 parents whose children attended school in three Gweru district secondary schools. The total sample was one hundred and eighty (180) participants. The findings indicated that the incentive paymen...
Incentives in Zimbabwe's education system: Cure or curse?
International journal of innovation and scientific research, 2014
During the years 2005 to 2008, Zimbabwe plunged into an economic depression. Many social and economic systems were severely shaken, while others crumpled. The education sector was not spared. Many schools closed as teachers left their jobs for the informal sector while others crossed the borders in search of greener pastures. It was against this background that some parents mooted the idea of incentivising teachers as a way of retaining and motivating them. Many teachers were given financial incentives, while in a few cases, incentives were paid in kind. With incentives, some semblance of sanity returned to the education sector. Unfortunately, a few years down the line, the issue of incentives courted so much controversy, poisoning relations amongst stakeholders, especially between parents and teachers. This study assessed how incentives were administered and why they spoiled relations amongst stakeholders. This qualitative study made use of the survey research design where data wer...
2018
One of the challenges facing education systems worldwide is the motivation of qualified teachers to teach at rural schools. Teaching at rural schools is a challenge as rural areas are characterised by adverse living and working conditions, making qualified teachers prefer living and working at urban schools where conditions are more comfortable. Namibia implemented the financial incentive to motivate qualified teachers to teach at rural schools and improve learner performance. The implementation of the financial incentive in Namibia has received little research attention in establishing its effectiveness. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the financial incentive on the performance of learners at rural schools, as this performance relates to teacher motivation. To achieve this, a literature study and an empirical investigation were conducted. An interpretivist research paradigm informed the methodology for the study. A mixed-methods research approach, which relied more on a qualitative research design, included a research sample of 28 teachers, five school principals and two education officials. Data were collected through interviews and document analysis. Individual interviews were conducted with education officials and school principals. Focus group interviews were conducted with teachers. Document analysis entailed accessing applicable documents of each research site in the office of the school principal. Textual data were analysed and presented thematically and numeric data were analysed and presented as frequencies and percentages. Key findings established that financial incentive has contributed little to the performance of learners in rural schools. The fact that rural schools are not properly categorised according to environmental challenges results in teachers not receiving realistic financial incentive. Teachers were therefore not motivated by financial incentive, but by other factors relating to being tuned to nature in rural areas, being exposed to lower living costs and enjoying accommodating school leadership and community care. A revisiting of the implementation of the financial incentive is recommended in order to negate shortcomings and enhance the potential of financial incentive to contribute to improved learner performance as steered by motivated teachers.
Withdrawal of Incentives for Teachers: Wither the Teaching Profession in Zimbabwe
The study explored the effect of the withdrawal of incentives on the motivation of teachers in Zimbabwe. A sample forty-six teachers (15 male and 31 female) were interviewed using a self-administered questionnaire. Data were analysed using descriptive statistics. The study found that both male and female teachers were dissatisfied with the withdrawal of incentives by the government. The findings showed that teachers engaged in side activities in order to supplement wages and salaries after the withdrawal of incentives. The government and stakeholders should consider indirect incentives such as affordable schemes for houses, motor vehicles and waiver for school fees for teachers' children to enhance teachers' motivation and job commitment.
Evidence from around the world shows that teacher effort has an impact on learning outcomes. One of the most basic measures of teacher effort is teacher presence. In Tanzania, teacher absence from classrooms is a non-trivial problem. Recognizing the central role teachers play in the learning achievement of students and the magnitude of the problem of teacher absenteeism in Tanzanian classrooms, Twaweza Tanzania has for the past four years (2013-2016) implemented a teacher motivation intervention based on a cash-on-delivery model, called “KiuFunzza.” Despite skepticism, KiuFunza works. This study sought to understand how and why it works. KiuFunza builds on an underlying self-identity that teachers possess where they think of themselves as purposeful educators. They call the bonus they are paid “Bakshishi”. This word derives from Persian and Arabic, but, often when used in Kiswahili it means a tip or a bribe; something that is sweet like candy. In KiuFunza the Bakshishi has proved to be a quick motivator that is sweeter than a salary rise. This is because it is a public undertaking with the potential for social affirmation and makes explicit the relationship between effort, results, and payment. In the challenging conditions of a resource poor educational setting teachers have lost sight of their significance as educators. Society claims to value and respect good teachers, but our actual behaviours undermine claims that we are committed to educational attainment. KiuFunza’s goal is to improve students’ learning outcomes. It does so by demonstrating a concern with teachers’ interests, by trusting teachers to deliver, and by rewarding unbiased outcomes. It has demonstrated a virtuous cycle of effects 1.Teachers feel more secure and less stressed; and so are able to focus teaching time, attention and reward on individual children. 2.A school environment has emerged that focuses on learning, solutions and performance. 3.Teachers, students and parents become bonded in their joint pursuit of performance. 4.Teachers self-image recovers as they identify as purposeful professionals, irrespective of their motivation to join the teaching profession. These effects are conditioned on the catalyst for motivation being unbiased and reliable, and tangibly demonstrating to teachers that hard work pays, and can generate social affirmation. Advocacy and program design within the education sector could further focus on rewarding (unbiased) performance, rather than blanket measures of resource increases.
Incentives in Elementary Education - do They Make a Difference
This study tried to bring together the experiences of different approaches to incentives followed by six NGOs in the states of Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Orissa, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka. Issues dealing with incentives and the hidden cost of education have been explored with a view to gaining some insights and exploring some possible ways forward in such a diverse and challenging situation.
The Impact of Low Salaries on Teacher Motivation: The Case for Mutasa District-Zimbabwe
This study sort to find out the extent to which teachers were motivated to carry out teaching tasks given the low salaries and incentives they were being paid by the state. A survey design was used so as to widen the reach to teachers' views. Data were collected through self administered questionnaires distributed to 36 teachers. In addition, more data were generated through in-depth interviews with 10 school Heads. The study found out that: teachers were intrinsically motivated by their engagement in teaching and learning as well as seeing the children learn; parents were paying monetary incentives to the teachers; teachers were not motivated by the low monetary incentives they got from parents. The study, therefore, concluded that teachers were functioning more on intrinsic motivation deriving from the joy of engaging in teaching and learning as well as seeing the children learn. It is, therefore recommended that school leaders could maximise opportunity for intrinsic motivation through improving teaching and learning conditions. Also, Parents could add non monetary incentives in their attempt to improve current level of extrinsic satisfaction among teachers.
Monetary Reward and Teachers' Performance in Selected Public Secondary Schools in Kano State
This is a conceptual study that intends to examine the relationship between monetary reward and teachers' performance in Some Selected Kano State public secondary schools. Secondary schools are the bridge between primary education and higher institutions in Nigeria. The need for students to acquire more knowledge and skills beyond primary level in Nigeria has become imperative and hence the need for secondary school education. Therefore, teachers performance is of utmost concern since improvement of teachers' performance can lead to effective performance of students and the education sector at large. The study is going to be quantitative and will adopt survey research design. Cluster sampling technique will be used to obtain responses from the sample of 375 teachers. Regression analysis will be used for Data analysis through SPSS version 17. 1.0 Background to the Study The need for individuals to perform for the organization to function effectively is very important. Job performance is carrying out an activity expected from an employee largely influenced by the reward in place. When an employee does what is prescribed as the content of his job, he performed. Individual job performance is of high relevance for the existence and well being of organizations (Sonnentag, Volmer & Spychala, 2010). Armstrong (2010) argued that one of the most important, if not the most important, of the responsibilities undertaken by managers of organisations is to ensure that members of their entities achieve high levels of performance. These arguments justify the fact that performance of an organization is a reflection of the performance of employees and that the better the employees perform, the better the organization perform and vice versa. Therefore, there is the need for both government and private organizations to employ appropriate reward mechanism for compensating employees' contributions and ginger them towards higher performance. Monetary reward is a measure of influencing individual's drive to act towards desired direction. Monetary rewards comprised all rewards that have a monetary value and add up to total remuneration such as base pay, pay contingent on performance, contribution, competency or skill, pay related to service, financial recognition schemes, and benefits such as pensions, sick pay and health insurance (Armstrong, 2010). The importance of monetary reward cannot be over emphasized. Guajardo (2011) found that monetary rewards are the strongest incentive in Africa, especially salary increase or performance based rewards. Armstrong (2010) argued that monetary rewards are the core element in total reward. Similarly, a study conducted by Narsee (2012) in South Africa found that monetary reward is the most important reward category. These findings cannot be far from the fact that people work so that they can satisfy their various needs and wants from the reward they get. Therefore, a good monetary reward package attracts not only competent workers and retain them, but also determine their commitments and attitudes towards work, and teachers in Kano State are not exception. Teachers' performance is very vital such that poor performance by teachers (lateness, absenteeism, laziness) can seriously compromise teaching quality, learning outcomes, and social development (Bennell & Akyeampong, 2007). Akiri and Ugborugbo (2009) opined that the quality of education depends on teachers as reflected in the performance of their duty. A study by Salman, Mohammed, Ogunlade, and Ayinla (2012) has found that majority of teachers and students have agreed that payment of poor remuneration, in terms of salary and allowances for teachers, affects their performance which as a result contributed greatly to students' mass failure in Ondo State, Nigeria. Thus, what is the effect of salary, allowances, and benefit as monetary reward package on teachers' performance in Public Secondary Schools in Kano State? Furthermore, extant literatures on the relationship between monetary reward and teachers/job performance reported mixed conclusion. For example, a study by Engellandt and Riphahn (2004) in Switzerland found that surprise bonus payments is an effective incentives for employee effort. Ahn and Vigdor (2010) concluded that monetary incentives (bonus) lead teachers to try harder in USA. Similar study by Charity and Timinefere (2011) found that monetary reward has significant positive effect on employees' performance in Nigeria. A study by Gungor (2011) in Turkey revealed that financial rewards have positive effects on employee performance. Similarly, a study by Yamoah (2013) reported a significant relationship between teachers' rewards and job performance in Ghana. Lack of motivational factors such as salary, rent allowances and transport allowances negatively affect teachers' work performance in Ethiopia (Negussie, 2014). On the other hand, a study on teacher performance pay conducted by Adkins (2004) in Florida, USA found that most teachers and other instructional respondents disagree that teacher performance pay provides an
2014
The pride of every school rests in its ability, at the end of the particular academic cycle, to churn out to society students with excellent academic performance, that are all round and super motivated to pursue higher education goals or delve into careers that will contribute to the positive development of the nation. To achieve this, most schools have recognized and underscored the key role that teachers play in the overall performance hence invested heavily in mechanisms geared towards boosting their morale so as to enhance effective teacher delivery. According to Ornstein and Hunkins (1988), teachers are a source of untapped energy and insight and are capable of profoundly changing their schools. The paper therefore focuses on the effectiveness of the school based reward systems towards enhancing teacher performance in Secondary schools in Kitale County, Kenya. The objectives of the study included to identify existing school based reward systems, to assess teacher preferences in...