Jews as Producers and Consumers of History in the Medieval Islamicate World (original) (raw)
The Jews of the medieval Islamicate world were avid consumers and producers of history. In this article, I discuss the major modes of historical writing among the Jews of the period and introduce the question of how that historical writing was used by those Jews. In considering the Sitz im Leben of historical writing, I explore the role of internal communal apologetic, anti-sectarian polemic, inter-religious attack, political support and challenge, entertainment, the contextualizing of philosophy, consolation after adversity, and preparation for eschatological redemption. I pay particular attention to the rewriting of Others' histories-Christian, Islamic, and Jewish sectarian-and the role these often-popular rewritten histories played in medieval Jewish society. This panoply of historical writing challenges an important scholarly view that Jewish consumption of history was minimal and served a limited range of "religious" needs within the medieval Jewish community.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research.
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Related papers
Islamic Historiography as Polemic Literature: Deconstructing Biographies of Medieval Jewish Converts
Journal of Arabic Literature 54.1-2 (2023), pp. 129-157, 2023
This article considers biographical material on Jewish converts authored by Muslim historians, primarily in Mamluk Egypt and Syria from the 13th to 15th centuries, enumerating and analyzing its recurring themes. Among its key findings is that the motifs found in this material are consonant with Islamic theological perceptions of other faith-based groups, especially the Jews. These themes also reflect their writers’ notion of exemplary history. Beyond this, I suggest that the main objective behind the texts under review is the affirmation of basic principles espoused in the Qurʾān, ḥadīth, and the sīrah for the purpose of demonstrating the veracity and superiority of the Muslim faith. https://brill.com/view/journals/jal/54/1-2/article-p129\_5.xml
The Medieval Islamic World and the Jews
The Cambridge Companion to Antisemitism, 2022
This essay appears in a collection that treats antisemitism as it originated and developed in the West – meaning the Greco-Roman world until its mantle passed to Europe. There has never been agreement over the meaning of antisemitism, even among scholars of antisemitism let alone the public at large, and it often serves in the popular press as a vehicle for particular political or religious positions that tend to be reductive and essentializing. While it is true that Jews suffered as a minority community in the Muslim world just as they did elsewhere, it is not clear how that suffering relates to something that could be called “antisemitism.” It is not particularly useful to use the term in relation to the medieval Muslim world, though it is relevant in the modern period when antisemitism enters Muslim discourse with the rise of Western colonial power and influence
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.