• “Monsters, Metamorphosis, and Intra-Community Conflict in the Tales of Rabbi Judah the Pious” in: Karl E. Grözinger (ed), Das kulturelle Profil der SchUM-Gemeinden – Literatur, Musik, Theater, Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2014, pp. 83–98 (original) (raw)
Monsters and the Monstrous: Ancient Expressions of Cultural Anxieties
A Cultural History of Fairy Tales in Antiquity, 2021
Many of the most recognizable monsters in Western culture, such as Medusa, Cerberus, and the Cyclopes, started to appear in literature and art nearly three thousand years ago. Other, more generic types of monstrous or uncanny entities, such as dragons and ghosts, are even older and appear in art and literature across the globe. This chapter covers such creatures in the earliest folk and fairy tales of the ancient Near East and Mediterranean areas, keeping in mind that much of our information comes from tales, or, in most cases, prototypes for tales, embedded within the larger context of Near Eastern and Greek myths. The chapter first considers what the concept of "monster" might have meant for people in those geographical regions thousands of years ago. The chapter then examines what tales from antiquity survive that incorporated monsters, what kinds of monster predominate in these tales, and what the presence and roles of monsters in the tales might have meant.
Monsters and Fabulous Beasts of Ancient and Medieval Times
Myths of gods, legends of battles, and folktales of magic are abound in the heroic narratives of the Middle Ages. Medieval heroes were developed from a variety of source materials: Early pagan gods become euhemerized through a Christian lens, and an older epic heroic sensibility was exchanged for a Christian typological and figural representation of saints. Most startlingly, the faces of Christian martyrs were refracted through a heroic lens in the battles between Christian standard-bearers and their opponents, who were at times explicitly described in demonic terms. General readers and researchers alike on a fantastic adventure on the trail of some of the greatest heroes of medieval literature.
The dominant literate culture of early medieval England – male, European, and Christian – often represented itself through comparison to exotic beings and mon- sters, in traditions developed from native mythologies, and Classical and Biblical sources. So pervasive was this reflexive identification that the language of the mon- strous occurs not only in fictional travel narratives, but at the heart of construc- tions of the native hero as well as the Christian saint. In these constructions we read the central contradiction in this literature: the monster must be ‘other’ and yet cannot be absolutely so; on the contrary, the monster remains recognizable, familiar, seductive, and possible. In this essay, we discuss textual sources for the early medieval monstrous, sources ranging from Pliny to Augustine and Isidore. As we survey early medieval texts dealing with the monstrous in genres including catalog, epic, and hagiography as well as visual depictions in manuscript illustration and the mappaemundi, we consider historically particular cultural and political motivations for the representation of the monstrous in these texts, among them the early Christian conversions and shifting national boundaries.
From mythical monsters to future horrors: towards an understanding of the function of monstrosity:
This BA thesis investigates the function of the Monster from the 5th century onwards, with particular attention to whether, and how, this function has changed over time. To this purpose, three texts are analyzed: 'Beowulf', 'The Island of Doctor Morreau' and 'The Calcutta Chromosome', with a narrow focus on how the monsters in the chosen texts function and are described. Anthropological, philosophical, historical and literary approaches to the monster are outlined and to varying extents applied in the analysis of the individual texts. Subsequently, the texts are analyzed in chronological order, with particular emphasis on the function, description, and location of the monsters, with emphasis on the Monsters of 'The Calcutta Chromosome'. Subsequently, I undertake a comparative analysis of the monsters of 'Beowulf', 'The Island of Doctor Morreau' and 'The Calcutta Chromosome', this time focusing on the geographical location of the monsters, and its meaning. Finally, I attempt a theoretically founded analysis of how the monster functions in literature, with particular emphasis on its symbolic function. Here the theory that was explained in the opening chapter is drawn in, in an argument that the monster basically has different layers of functions. Furthermore, it is argued that the functions of the monster has various facets, symbolic and concrete, and that it refuses any clearcut definition. This is supported by McCormack's argument that the core feature of the monster is that it defies categorization. This is used to support the argument that the monster is fundamentally ambiguous. Throughout the thesis, it is argued that the monster is fundamentally a complex entity, and that any attempt to approach the monster from any one theoretical angle will be incapable of grasping this complexity. It is concluded that my thesis, that the monster has always resided beyond the border of what is known, but that this border has moved over time, is fundamentally correct. However, it is also concluded that this is but one aspect of the ambiguous nature of the monster. Furthermore, it is concluded that the monster is a fundamentally transgressive construct, and that the breaching of borders is one of the key functions of the monster. It is noted that general conclusions can only be drawn to a limited extent on the basis of the examined source material. Furthermore, it is emphasized that the purpose of this thesis is more to point to a general trend in the depiction of monstrosity across literary eras, than to make a definitive statement about the monster as a literary concept.
The Epistemological Functions of Monsters in the Middle Ages
Monsters in the Middle Ages assumed significant epistemological functions, providing an image of the complete 'other' in the human quest for the self. Since late antiquity teratology played a big role in literature, art, philosophy, and religion, but meaning and relevance of monsters changed from author to author (the same applies to their visual representation). This article provides an overview of how the image of the monster changed throughout times and how individual writers evaluated them.
Research Companion to Monsters and the Monstrous
The field of monster studies has grown significantly over the past few years and this companion provides a comprehensive guide to the study of monsters and the monstrous from historical, regional and thematic perspectives. The collection reflects the truly multi-disciplinary nature of monster studies, bringing in scholars from literature, art history, religious studies, history, classics, and cultural and media studies. The companion will offer scholars and graduate students the first comprehensive and authoritative review of this emergent field. Contents: Foreword, John Block Friedman; Introduction: the impact of monsters and monster studies, Asa Simon Mittman; Part I History of Monstrosity: The monstrous Caribbean, Persephone Braham; The unlucky, the bad and the ugly: categories of monstrosity from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment, Surekha Davies; Beauteous beast: the water deity Mami Wata in Africa, Henry John Drewal; Rejecting and embracing the monstrous in Ancient Greece and Rome, D. Felton; Early modern past to postmodern future: changing discourses of Japanese monsters, Michael Dylan Foster; On the monstrous in the Islamic visual tradition, Francesca Leoni; Human of the heart: pitiful oni in medieval Japan, Michelle Osterfield Li; The Maya 'cosmic monster' as a political; and religious symbol, Matthew Looper; Monsters lift the veil: Chinese animal hybrids and processes of transformation, Karin Myhre; From hideous to hedonist: the changing face of the 19th-century monster, Abigail Lee Six and Hannah Thompson; Centaurs, satyrs, and cynocephali: medieval scholarly teratology and the question of the human, Karl Steel; Invisible monsters: vision, horror, and contemporary culture, Jeffrey Andrew Weinstock. Part II Critical Approaches to Monstrosity: Posthuman teratology, Patricia MacCormack; Monstrous sexuality: variations on the vagina dentata, Sarah Alison Miller; Postcolonial monsters: a conversation with Partha Mitter, Partha Mitter with Asa Simon Mittman and Peter Dendle; Monstrous gender: geographies of ambiguity, Dana Oswald; Monstrosity and race in the late Middle Ages, Debra Higgs Strickland; Hic sunt dracones: the geography and cartography of monsters, Chet van Duzer; Conclusion: monsters in the 21st century: the preternatural in an age of scientific consensus, Peter J. Dendle; Postscript: the promise of monsters, Jeffrey Jerome Cohen; Bibliography; Index.
LONDON - W.H. Allen & Co., Waterloo Place. S. W., 1886
This ultra rare book delves into the fascinating realm of ancient mythologies and their roots in pre-historic human civilization. The work explores whether the recorded history of man, spanning a few thousand years, truly encapsulates the entirety of human existence or if ancient mythological eras, chronicled in the traditions of Chaldea and China, hold fragmented memories of civilizations long lost, akin to Plato's Atlantis. Gould questions the brief time span—six to eight thousand years—traditionally assigned to human civilization by Biblical interpreters, suggesting that this period scarcely accommodates the complexity and development of early human societies. The book meticulously examines how myths and legends of divine progenitors, demigods, and monstrous creatures were disseminated globally, shaped by the diverse environmental and cultural contexts of different peoples. **Detailed Overview:** **1. Human Civilization Beyond Recorded History:** Gould begins by challenging the conventional timeline of human history. He proposes that the brief span of written history might only be a fragment of man's intelligent existence. By referencing the extensive mythical eras of Chaldea and China, Gould hints at the possibility of pre-historic civilizations that have perished due to catastrophic events, leaving behind only shadowy mementos preserved through tradition. **2. Questioning the Biblical Timeline:** Gould critically examines the six to eight thousand years commonly accepted by Biblical interpreters for the creation of the world and human civilization. He argues that this limited timeframe barely suffices to account for the documented evidence of ancient civilizations' development, the divergence of human stocks, and the obliteration of connecting branches. **3. Universal Spread of Mythologies:** The author observes that myths of divine progenitors, heroes, and monstrous creatures permeate all corners of the world. These stories, carried with the fidelity akin to the sacred Ark of the Israelites, adapt according to the local genius, superstitions, and environmental conditions. Gould highlights how different settings, from open plains to dense forests, mold these myths, reflecting the inhabitants' lifestyles and fears. **4. Influence of Environment on Mythology:** Gould explores how environmental conditions shape cultural and mythological expressions. For instance, the inhabitants of semi-tropical plains, enjoying a genial sun and open spaces, develop a buoyant and open temperament, influencing their mythologies to be more graceful. In contrast, those living in dense, gloomy forests filled with lurking dangers foster myths filled with dread and vigilance. **5. Divergence of Aryan Descendants:** Focusing on the descendants of Aryan ancestors—the Greeks, Celts, and Vikings—Gould illustrates how environmental and social conditions led to distinct cultural developments. The Greeks, with their favorable climate and geography, cultivated a mythology rich in benign gods and heroic demigods. The Celts, influenced by their forested habitats, developed a more gloomy and sanguinary Druidic religion. The Vikings, shaped by their harsh seaboard environment, created a mythology reflecting their maritime prowess and rugged lifestyle, with deities embodying the tempestuous elements of their world. **6. Climatic Influences on Civilization:** Gould further discusses how climatic conditions influence the advancement of civilizations. He posits that the Chaldeans, living in a pastoral country and descending from nomadic ancestors in Central Asia, advanced in astronomy and climatology due to their prolonged exposure to the vast open steppes and highlands. Their precise understanding of climatic patterns may have surpassed even modern knowledge. **Conclusion:** Charles Gould's "Mythical Monsters" is a comprehensive exploration of the intersections between ancient mythologies, pre-historic civilizations, and the environmental influences shaping human culture. By questioning traditional timelines and examining the global spread and adaptation of myths, Gould provides a scholarly insight into the deep-rooted connections between human history, environment, and mythological beliefs. This overview encapsulates the core themes and arguments of Gould's work, providing a scholarly perspective suitable for an academic profile. The detailed exploration highlights Gould's critical approach to traditional historical timelines, his examination of the universal spread of myths, and his insights into the environmental influences on cultural and mythological development. Tags pre-historic,man,history,mythology,Charles Gould,Mythical Monsters,Chaldea,China,Atlantis,Plato,catastrophe,civilization,tradition,Biblical record,creation,world,human existence,development,stocks,divergence,progenitors,demigods,heroes,monsters,giants,dwarfs,serpents,dragons,beasts,supernatural beings,myths,Ark,Israelites,superstitious belief,genius,countries,plains,semi-tropical,disposition,temperament,forests,gloom,shadows,monsters,nomad,solitude,contemplation,mariners,pirates,traits,religion,polity,customs,mythology,tradition,Greek,Celt,Viking,Aryan ancestors,independence,conquest,polite,skilled,learned,irritable,suspicious,haughty,berserker,maritime adventure,piracy,hand-to-hand combat,Greek mythology,gods,demigods,climate,semi-insular,stormy weather,mountains,Druids,religion,seclusion,haze,dangers,Caesar,Gaul,Britain,Spain,seaboard,storms,waves,winds,forests,climate,harvest,mariner,Thor,tempests,storm-cloud,Chaldeans,pastoral,ancestors,nomadic,steppes,Asia,astronomy,sciences,climatology,environment,culture,Greek nation,pantheon,religious belief,plastic influences,mythological divergence,historical timelines,prehistoric eras,cosmology,mythological eras,prehistoric man,shadowy mementos,chronologies,documental evidence,fabled Atlantis,Biblical interpreters,mythical creatures,divine progenitors,demigods,supernatural beings,mythical stories,global mythologies,mythological spread,environmental conditions,cultural contexts,climatic conditions,mythological expressions,mythological adaptation,cultural development,cultural divergence,Aryan descent,nomadic existence,pastoral society,pastoral culture,Chaldean astronomy,Central Asia,prehistoric traditions,mythological evidence,catastrophic events,ancient civilizations,mythical memory,prehistoric civilizations,mythological records,ancient mythologies,prehistoric chronology,shadowy traditions,pre-civilization eras,prehistoric history,ancient mythos,environmental influences,mythological influences,cultural influences,climatic influences,prehistoric legends,mythical legends,mythological eras,cultural mythologies,prehistoric mythologies,civilization development,prehistoric culture,prehistoric environment,mythological environment,cultural expression,prehistoric mythos,nomadic cultures,prehistoric societies,prehistoric settlements,civilization evidence,mythological evidence,prehistoric evidence,prehistoric astronomy,nomadic traditions,prehistoric science,ancient science,prehistoric astronomy,ancient climatology,prehistoric climatology,prehistoric advancements,ancient advancements,prehistoric myths,ancient myths,prehistoric creatures,ancient creatures,mythical creatures,prehistoric records,ancient records,prehistoric timelines,ancient timelines,prehistoric chronologies,ancient chronologies,prehistoric catastrophes,ancient catastrophes,mythological spread,prehistoric mythology,mythological adaptation,cultural adaptation,environmental adaptation,prehistoric environment,cultural environments,mythological traditions,prehistoric traditions,prehistoric mythology,cultural mythology,prehistoric mythos,ancient mythos,prehistoric legends,ancient legends,prehistoric myths,ancient myths,prehistoric civilization,ancient civilization,cultural development,civilization development,prehistoric development,ancient development,prehistoric society,ancient society,prehistoric cultures,ancient cultures,cultural influences,environmental influences,prehistoric influences,prehistoric religion,ancient religion,prehistoric beliefs,ancient beliefs,mythological beliefs,prehistoric heroes,ancient heroes,mythological heroes,prehistoric deities,ancient deities,mythological deities,prehistoric gods,ancient gods,mythological gods,prehistoric demigods,ancient demigods,mythological demigods,prehistoric progenitors,ancient progenitors,mythological progenitors,prehistoric legends,ancient legends,mythological legends,prehistoric mythology,ancient mythology,mythological mythology,prehistoric folklore,ancient folklore,mythological folklore,prehistoric creatures,ancient creatures,mythological creatures,prehistoric monsters,ancient monsters,mythological monsters,prehistoric serpents,ancient serpents,mythological serpents,prehistoric dragons,ancient dragons,mythological dragons,prehistoric beasts,ancient beasts,mythological beasts,prehistoric myths,ancient myths,mythological myths,prehistoric traditions,ancient traditions,mythological traditions,prehistoric evidence,ancient evidence,mythological evidence,prehistoric legends,ancient legends,mythological legends,prehistoric beliefs,ancient beliefs,mythological beliefs,prehistoric religion,ancient religion,mythological religion,prehistoric deities,ancient deities,mythological deities,prehistoric gods,ancient gods,mythological gods,prehistoric demigods,ancient demigods,mythological demigods,prehistoric progenitors,ancient progenitors,mythological progenitors.