Messianic Pains. The Apocalyptic Temporality in Avant- Garde Art, Politics, and War, Modernism/modernity (original) (raw)
Related papers
World War I as a Cause of Ephemeral Hope in the Artistic Avant-Gardes
World War I as a Cause of Ephemeral Hope in the Artistic Avant‑Gardes, 2023
The article shows, first, how Sociology has approached the concepts of "hope" and "war" and how throughout the history of the discipline these terms have gone from being neglected to arousing considerable interest. Second, the paper analyzes how and why avant-garde artists understood the First World War as a motif of utopian hope to annihilate a civilization in crisis and to transform it through its aesthetic formalization. Third, the essay tries to find out whether that hope was preserved over time or, on the contrary, was soon dissolved as a result of the drama of the events. It is shown here that the savagery of the fighting dissolved all European values of modernity and progress, including artistic ones. In fact, theoretical and stylistic conceptions, aesthetic categories, ethical postulates, and artists' aspirations for conscience to rule the world were blurred. For the artistic avant-garde, utopian promises of a better world broke down. Consequently, this obliges sociologists to pay more attention to both phenomena-that of the war and that of the avant-garde-and to seek a more objective and critical interpretation of modernity, calling for its actualization, and of Sociology itself.
Bagh-e Nazar, 2017
Since the 20th century and following the experience of two world wars and other human catastrophes, the concept of trauma, as an individual and collective phenomenon, has been widely discussed in both scientific and public spheres. Although it is difficult to determine clear boundaries for the categorization of factors causing individual and collective trauma, war can be regarded as a traumatic phenomenon and the concept of trauma resulting from war trauma can be thus advanced. ● Problem Statement and Key Questions The present research focuses on the representation of individual and collective war trauma in works of art with a look at the paintings of two German artists in the years following World War I and World War II. This study aims to trace and study the interactional relationship of these works with individual and collective trauma in the cultural and social context of the postwar society in the defeated country. In fact, this study tries to answer these questions: how does the representation of individual war trauma in these paintings interact with collective trauma in the setting of the postwar society? How can the representation of collective trauma in works of art by different postwar generations be explained by Freudian and post-Freudian psychoanalytical theories? ● Research Methodology To answer the research questions, first psychoanalytical theories about trauma (especially war trauma), with an emphasis on the ideas of Freud, will be discussed. In the course of the content analysis of the works of art, this psychoanalytical approach will serve as a departure point in relation to which the assessment of cultural and social conditions and the biography of the artists will be undertaken. Thus, this study shows that works of art can serve as a means of representation of the memories of individual and collective trauma. For a better understanding of the different individual and collective aspects of war trauma, two German artists from two different generations have been selected for the case study. The fact that one of them belongs to a generation that has experienced war and the other is from a generation that inherited the consequences of war from the generation of their parents, provides us with a better opportunity to study the representation of trauma as an individual or collective experience. ● Research Objective The present study tries to identify the signs and features determined in psychoanalysis to diagnose trauma in the works of two German painters from the era following the two world wars as a representation of individual and collective war trauma and explain the content of these works through a psychoanalytic reading. This study provides for a better understanding of the analyzed works and develops a model for the study of the representation of war trauma in similar works in other societies and historical eras following different wars.
Ethical Representations: Abstracting War and Violence in Modern Art
In analysing the trajectory of Modern art, American critic Clement Greenberg contends that modernist painters found themselves producing a pattern of “flatness”. From Manet and Cézanne to Kandinsky and Mondrian, their works presented a gradual departure from the three-dimensional pictorial illusion of realism and an emerging interest to experiment with new simplified forms and colours. By further eliminating additional elements like a work’s narrative or subject matter, these artists “eventuated in a kind of painting flatter than anything in Western art, [...] so flat indeed that it could hardly contain any recognisable images”. I argue that this tendency towards abstraction, in particular, is figured prominently in paintings of war and violence. Beset by the first two international wars and other civil conflicts rippling through nations like Korea, Spain and Vietnam, the 20th Century was perceived as a tumultuous time of relentless socio-political movements. However, it was also a period defined by its harrowing death toll, as innocent lives were conveniently discarded in their positions as pawns amidst a power struggle. Instead of mimetically replicating the realities of such horrific loss in their art, modernist painters slowly realised that such an approach was unethical and merely (re)traumatises spectators and survivors. As such, abstraction becomes a visual genre most suited to render images of catastrophic events: not only does its non-representational nature mirror the unspeakability of trauma, but it also creates a critical and necessary emotional distance for the audience to witness the painter’s art.
Obrist/Worringer/Marc: Abstraction and Empathy on the Eve of World War One
This essay considers continuities between the impetus towards abstraction within Jugendstil and Expressionism. Both Hermann Obrist and Franz Marc sought through empathy to intuit and image abstract forces at work within the materiality of the organic and inorganic natural worlds. Their creative practice and theoretical writings share much with Wilhelm Worringer's discussion of the "expressive abstraction" found in the Gothic style, which unified the organic with the abstract. This essay explores the trajectories of this visual and textual discourse, paying particular attention to their nexus during 1914 in Obrist's monumental sculptures at the Werkbund Exhibition in Cologne and the development of Marc's paintings over the course of that year.