Does maternity affect women’s careers? Perceptions of working mothers in academia (original) (raw)
Related papers
Educacion Xx1, 2020
Women in academia are underrepresented at the highest levels of the hierarchy. After gaining their PhDs, they seem to make little progress and their career paths appear to be hampered by their family responsibilities. Motherhood can affect scientific productivity and, therefore, promotion. Balancing teaching, research, administration, consultation, and other roles in academia with maternity can be hard. This study comprises an onlinesurvey of mothers with children up to 5 years old, working in academia (n=80) in a Spanish university (University of Murcia), the aim being to ascertain their views regarding maternity and work. Common themes include a greater focus on teaching than on research, handicaps regarding mobility, and working from home. 63% perceived that their CVs are less competitive than those of their co-workers who are not mothers, which 03_2020_24-01_Educ_XX1_Capitulos.indd 405 03_2020_24-01_Educ_XX1_Capitulos.
Academic Motherhood: "Silver Linings and Clouds
2015
Historically speaking, men dominated the university sphere and women were not typically present in academic positions (Ward & Wolf-Wendel, 2012). The dominance of male academics lead to gendered norms and expectations that influence academic life presently (Jakubiec, 2015). Today, more women are entering into higher education as students and as professors; however, sexism and gendered notions about women have not been eradicated (Rhoads & Rhoads, 2012). Further, it is especially difficult for women who are mothers to succeed, get promoted, and achieve tenure. For example, women (more so than men) have reported that parenthood and childbearing are main barriers in their attainment of full professorship (Sanders, Willemson, & Millar, 2009). In fact, Dryfhout and Estes (2010) found that professors who were women were 30% less likely to have attained tenured faculty positions, and were also more likely to have intentions to leave the academic profession. Thus, the impacts of having chil...
Gestión del conflicto trabajo cuidados en el ámbito científico académico
Revista Espanola de Investigaciones Sociologicas, 2024
In this article we analyse the motherhood and care experiences of female researchers in Spain in order to understand the way in which they manage the work-care conflict in the scientific-academic field and to characterise its labour and psychosocial implications. To do this, we conducted 30 semi-structured interviews with researchers at all levels of the academic career affiliated to 23 Spanish research centres and/or universities. The results show that academic mothers experience overload, stress and guilt before the double mandate of being "good mothers" and "good professionals". The results also indicate that they feel forced to sacrifice self-care to more comfortably meet their professional and domestic responsibilities, and to choose between two lesser evils: postponing or giving up motherhood or lowering their professional ambitions. Cómo citar Alcalde-González, Verna; Belli, Simone (2024). «Gestión del conflicto trabajo-cuidados en el ámbito científico-académico: un estudio cualitativo sobre las experiencias de mujeres investigadoras en España».
CohenMiller 2014 Phenomenon of Doctoral Student Motherhood Mothering in Academia (ProQuest)
This study examined the phenomenon of doctoral student motherhood/mothering in academia in a unique way by utilizing (1) an interdisciplinary theoretical framework, (2) examining the experiences of doctoral students who have become mothers for the first time, and (3) by integrating visual data collection into a phenomenological study. Participants included four doctoral student mothers from across colleges at one university. Three interviews were conducted with each participant and included visual data collection during each interview (e.g., drawing created by the participant). Additional data sources included a demographic/background questionnaire and archival data. Through phenomenological analysis of the data sources, three invariant themes (Gendered Experience, Strategic Experience, Sense of Belonging) and seven sub-themes (Realizations, Pregnancy Relationships, Childcare, Multiple Identities, Flexibility, Pushing Through, Informal Policies, and Expectations) were identified. Fo...
Motherhood and Work Experience of Women with Established Careers
Trends in Psychology, 2019
We aimed to investigate the experience of primiparous mothers with established careers in relation to motherhood and their work, from pregnancy to the end of maternity leave. Three public employees participated, answering interviews. Qualitative content analysis showed that the experiences of participants were similar in several aspects. Repercussions of work in the experience of motherhood were identifi ed from pregnancy, considering concerns regarding changes and reconciliation of maternal and professional demands. Feelings of insecurity and ambivalence were also present when babies entered daycare center and women returned to work. Since the pregnancy, changes aiming at managing the demands of work and motherhood were identifi ed. Family, social and organizational support received by the participants contributed to this management. Nevertheless, a sense of overload by the accumulation of activities after the baby’s entrance in daycare center and the mother’s return to work were evidenced, which corroborates literature on the subject.
Career and work-family relationship among academics : An exploratory study
2003
Despite the increase, in recent years, of women’s participation in the labour market, sex discrimination remains a reality in most work organisations. In this matter, academic organisations are no exception. Evidence of sex inequalities is well documented in the literature. At the individual level, inequalities are partly explained by family responsibilities mainly held by women. Having to spend a considerable amount of time in home and children related activities women are left with less time available for scientific work than their male colleagues. With the purpose of understanding how academics experience the relationship between work and family, 32 in-depth interviews were conducted among Portuguese academics of both sexes in one particular university. The findings confirmed that work-family conflict is stronger among female faculty than among their male counterparts. Additionally, the prejudice against maternity and the way it is compatible with a successful career appears to s...
Mothers in U.S. Academia: Insights from Lived Experiences
Despite emerging changes in U.S. colleges and universities, mothers continue to struggle for a voice in an academic landscape that privileges students and scholars who are able to commit long hours to their areas of study under the increasing pressures of the corporatization of education within a global marketplace. In order for women who are parents to have agency and viable career choices in academia, a broad and specific organizational change must occur that emphasizes people's personal and emotional needs as well as their professional obligations and aspirations. Drawing on examples from the Mothers in Academia (2013) anthology, the authors demonstrate both the struggles and strategies of navigating academia as mothers, arguing for a culture of care where professional and personal lives can be integrated in meaningful and gratifying ways. Personal testimonials act as critical interventions in the social, political, and cultural life of academia.
Mothers and researchers in the making: Negotiating ‘new’ motherhood within the ‘new’ academia
Human Relations, 2018
How do early-career academic mothers balance the demands of contemporary motherhood and academia? More generally, how do working mothers develop their embodied selves in today’s highly competitive working life? This article responds to a recent call to voice maternal experiences in the field of organization studies. Inspired by matricentric feminism and building on our intimate autoethnographic diary notes, we provide a fine-grained understanding of the changing demands that constitute the ongoing negotiation of ‘new’ motherhood within the ‘new’ academia. By highlighting the complexity of embodied experience, we show how motherhood is not an entirely negative experience in the workplace. Despite academia’s neoliberal tendencies, the social privilege of whiteness, heterosexuality and the middle class enables – at times – simultaneous satisfaction with both motherhood and an academic career.
Parenthood in the Ivory Tower: Engulfed by Being a Female Parent in Academia
Care and Compassion in Capitalism, 2025
In this chapter, we explore the challenges faced by female parent academics in higher education institutions where capitalist neoliberal policies make it difficult for female academics to balance their work and parenting responsibilities and draw some conclusions about how care and compassion can be used to address the challenges faced by female academics.
How much do children really cost? Maternity benefits and career opportunities of women in academia
2013
Motherhood and professional achievements appear as conflicting goals even for academic women. This project explores this tension by focusing on a set of provisions on parental and maternity leaves across 165 higher education institutions in the UK. Generous maternity provisions generate countervailing incentives for female academics. On the one hand, advantageous policies can foster women’s productivity in terms of research outcomes allowing them to take time out of work without income and career break concerns. On the other hand, women can exploit generous provisions without generating returnable results for the academic institution. We argue that adverse selection problems lead universities to differentiate among academic staff by offering two different types of maternity provisions (more vs less generous maternity leaves) in order to “test” women’s commitment and research ability before offering permanent contracts. Our results support this this line of argumentation. We also fin...