A river catchment modelling approach to urban wet weather discharge control strategies for the Water Framework Directive (original) (raw)
Related papers
Water quality based impact assessment of urban drainage impact in Europe - A Perspective Paper
Ambient water quality impact assessments provide for a procedure to evaluate urban discharges with respect to the state of the aquatic environment. They are used to identify critical discharge points and they give a framework for the re-development of urban drainage infrastructure. This development has become necessary because the EU Water Framework directive promotes achieving good water quality (chemically and biologically) as well as good water quantity. Discontinuous wet-weather discharges are known to have various detrimental impacts on receiv-ing waters. Due to their high variability and their number they are difficult to monitor. Therefore, mathematical models are commonly used to specify the hydraulic impact and pollutant concentration in the recipient. These numerical results are then interpreted with respect to the (probable) abundance of aquatic species. For the last decade guidelines have been available addressing engineers who want to optimize the urban water management system without endangering water quality goals. The urban water and the natural systems vary greatly in size and complexity. Therefore, the models have to be chosen accordingly with the background that more complex models require more basic data and extended skills. In the end choosing and parameterizing the model often becomes decisive whether a wet-weather discharge is considered detrimental or not. In practice, economic constraints and misused models lead to contradicting results, expressing a subjective impact as-sessment. Therefore, currently available ambient water quality assessment guidelines were re-viewed to (i) identify a structure ensuring objectivity, (ii) determine properties supporting the deci-sion making, and (iii) pin-point knowledge gaps that hinder an efficient transition towards water quality based urban water management. To these aims seven European guidelines were structurally analysed and published cases studies were critically reviewed. Furthermore, the algorithms behind the three most comprehensive guidelines were compared against a generic decision support algorithm used in river rehabilitation. Because simplified models are an important part within the assessment, three models were applied to a didactical example. The review of literature and models revealed the following. • An efficient AWA requires a layered approach to include i) screening for problem identifi-cation, ii) quantitative analysis of the various stressors, iii) transparent pre-selection of alternatives and fitting models for the design of protection measures and iv) performance evaluation of measures to be implemented. Each step has to be accompanied by verifying data needs and required model complexity. • Complex ambient water quality assessments demand large investments and expert knowledge from both the regulator and operator. Transparency can only be achieved by clear documentation and a proper uncertainty assessment of the used model. • The information available to engineers about the response of the aquatic environment to wet-weather discharges is insufficient. In science even, many aspects linking chemical water quality or structural integrity to the abundance of species is missing. Effective and efficient planning, however, depends on implementing these links into the urban water management models. The presented results have to be seen in front of the wide spectrum of available guidelines. The more flexible and conceptual it was designed the more responsibility is granted to the planning engineer and decision maker.
Catchment-scale modelling approach for a holistic urban water quality management
2008
In the past three decades, scientific research focused on preservation of water environment and, in particular, on the polluting impact of urban areas on natural water bodies. According to this point, several researches were developed to describe the phenomena that take place on the urban catchment during both wet and dry period. Researches demonstrated the importance of the integrated analysis of all the transformation phases that characterise the delivery and treatment of urban water pollutants from the sources to the final recipient. With this aim, several integrated urban drainage models have been developed for analysing the fate of pollution from the urban catchment to the final receiving waters simulating several physical and chemical processes. Such modelling approaches require calibration and, for this reason, scientific research tried to address two opposite needs: the reliable representation of complex systems and the need of parsimonious approaches in order to cope with insufficient data that are usually available with regard to urban drainage quality aspects. The present paper discusses the application of a home-made model to a complex integrated catchment: the Nocella basin (Italy). The paper describes the monitoring campaign that has been set up for model calibration and it presents some interesting considerations about the monitoring needs for integrated modelling application and some initial results useful for identifying the most relevant polluting sources.
2015
An event-based contaminant load model was developed to identify spatial patterns of stormwater total suspended solids (TSS) and heavy metal loads and assess potential reductions in contaminants loads by implementing various stormwater management options. The GIS-Excel based model estimates contaminant loads from an individual storm event based on different contributing impervious surfaces and key climate characteristics (rainfall intensity, duration, pH and antecedent dry days (ADD)). It then calculates the reduction in contaminant loads that could be achieved through source reduction (e.g. green roofs, repainting) as well as from treatment (e.g. raingardens (bioretention basins), wet ponds) applied to different surfaces within the catchment. The model was run for a case study catchment in Christchurch, New Zealand, to identify where ‘hotspots’ occurred for each contaminant. Model simulations of targeted management options were run, which predicted effective reduction of both TSS an...
Sustainable Urban‐Drainage Systems and Catchment Planning
Water and Environment Journal, 2002
Partnership initiatives to address the problem of diffuse pollution from impermeable surface runoff within urban catchments are reviewed, with particular reference to mutual stakeholder duties and interests which are vested in the regulatory agencies, planning authorities, developers, water companies and highway agencies within the UK. The role of ‘sustainable urban‐drainage systems’within integrated catchment‐based approaches is considered in the context of the requirements of the EU Water Framework Directive and strategic river‐basin management planning.
The impacts of urban discharges on the hydrology and water quality of an urban watercourse
Science of The Total Environment, 1996
This paper presents the findings of a study which has investigated the effects of urban discharges upon the hydrology and water quality of a small urban watercourse located in north London. A variety of hydrological variables and water quality parameters were monitored at a site downstream of two surface water outfalls (SWOs) and two combined sewer overflows (CSOs). Precipitation volume was found to be highly correlated with the total storm discharge (r2 = 0.91) and the duration of storm flow (r2 = 0.93). Precipitation intensity displayed a 0.67 level of correlation with peak discharge voiume. Aqueous loadings of biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), nitrate, chloride, total ammonia, suspended solids and total and dissolved zinc, copper, cadmium and lead, increased during the five monitored storm events. The highest increases in pollutant loadings compared with dry weather values were associated with BOD and suspended solids.
2014
An event-based contaminant load model was developed to identify spatial patterns of stormwater total suspended solids (TSS) and heavy metal loads and assess potential reductions in contaminants loads by implementing various stormwater management options. The GIS-Excel based model estimates contaminant loads from an individual storm event based on different contributing impervious surfaces and key climate characteristics (rainfall intensity, duration, pH and antecedent dry days (ADD)). It then calculates the reduction in contaminant loads that could be achieved through source reduction (e.g. green roofs, repainting) as well as from treatment (e.g. raingardens (bioretention basins), wet ponds) applied to different surfaces within the catchment. The model was run for a case study catchment in Christchurch, New Zealand, to identify where 'hotspots' occurred for each contaminant. Model simulations of targeted management options were run, which predicted effective reduction of both TSS and heavy metals could be achieved with a strategy of combined source reduction and downstream treatment.
Urban diffuse pollution: key data information approaches for the Water Framework Directive
Water and Environment Journal, 2006
Abstract The Water Framework Directive (WFD) provides a coherent structure within which the problems of diffuse urban pollution can be effectively tackled and managed. The context of impermeable surface water quality within the terms of the Directive are outlined, and the pollutant sources and loadings associated with various urban land uses are identified. Stormwater flows and quality are sufficient to prejudice any 'good'ecological potential, particularly in terms of chronic receiving water sediment toxicity. A simple volume– ...
2008
In the past, emission-standard indicators have been addressed by the Environmental Regulation in order to preserve the quality state of the receiving water body (RWB). Such indicators are based on the frequency or the magnitude of a polluted discharge, may it be continuous or intermittent. Recently, in order to properly protect the RWB quality state, the WFD has overtaken the emission-standard concept substituting it with the stream-standard concept, that fixes discharge limits for each polluting substance depending on self-depurative characteristics of the RWB. Stream-standard assessment requires the deployment of measurement campaigns in the RWB that can be very expensive. Therefore, it would be very useful to gain information about the status of the RWB from emission-based indicators. In this context, a survey about a possible connection between the RWB quality state indicators drawn by the Environmental Regulation (i.e. WFD or UPM), and the emission-based indicators has been worked out both considering continuous (i.e. from the WWTP) and intermittent polluting discharges (mainly from combined sewer overflows). A long term analysis considering a holistic approach has been carried out. More specifically, the SS, the WWTP and the RWB have been modelled jointly by means of a parsimonious home-made integrated model. The analysis has been applied to an experimental catchment in Bologna (Italy). It is concluded that correlation between stream-standards and classical emissionstandard variables can be stated even considering the relevant non linear processes that take part between the CSO emission and the RWB water quality condition.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, 2020
The argument for natural flood management in the UK has strengthened in recent years with increasing awareness of the potential benefits gained from upstream interventions (especially improvements in water quality, public amenities and biodiversity). This study aims to develop an understanding of another potential benefit—interventions promoting free discharge at downstream urban drainage outfalls by moderating water levels in receiving watercourses. A novel, coupled model (linking dynamic TOPMODEL, HEC-RAS and Infoworks ICM) is calibrated for the Asker catchment in Dorset, England. This predominantly rural watershed drains to the town of Bridport, frequently submerging a surface drainage outfall in a nearby housing estate. Two forms of upstream, catchment-scale intervention (hillslope tree planting and in-channel large woody debris) are modelled to understand their impacts on the functioning of the drainage network during both the calibration period and a range of design storms. Th...
Modelling pollutant washoff from South East Queensland catchments Australia
The progressive development and urbanisation of catchments alter catchment hydrology and affects stormwater runoff quality. Urban runoff carries pollutants into natural waterways and affects stream water quality. The rapid urban development in coastal areas of South East Queensland has made a significant impact on natural waterways in the region. Efforts to develop predictive models to estimate pollutant washoff, particularly in subtropical Australia, have been limited due to acute shortage of recorded water quality data.