Le Média – A Populist Critique of Journalists and the Media by Journalists (original) (raw)
Related papers
Radical Journalism à la françaiseBetween Differentiation and Stigma
Routledge eBooks, 2023
Focusing on the case of French radical journalists, this chapter has several objec7ves. A:er recalling the specific context of repoli7ciza7on of the journalis7c field in France, under the influence of digital media, it focuses on the condi7ons that allow for certain journalists to break with the professional ideology of neutrality-objec7vity. In a second step, our analysis specifies why this break is par7al. Indeed, our interviewees remain aEached to the journalis7c deontology as the basis of their professional legi7macy. They specify the func7on of journalism against the compe7ng figures of the 'automedia' and the 'editorialist' Finally, they are aware that commiEed and radical journalism is a label or a s7gma that can reinforce the mistrust toward them by the poli7cal and media elites.
Knowledge and Competences for a Counter-hegemonic journalistic practice
2011
In this article we problematize the skills and knowledge needed for the practice of citizen journalism, which we understand as a journalistic practice that deconstructs critiques and points out alternatives to the hegemonic thought. Citizen journalism intends to cater for the needs of citizens -as opposed to consumers-so that they are able to appropriate of and criticize that which is useful for their life experiences and, as a result, intervene in and change the reality in which they live. Such skills and knowledge include ethics, historicity, respect to otherness, critical and political approaches. The background for the analysis are the ideas of public journalism (Rosen, 1994;; alternative and citizen journalism (Carpentier 2009, Atton 2006 and Fuchs 2010, the pedagogy of the oppressed ; the journalistic deontology (Bertrand,1999) and the humanistic perspective (Kapuzinski, 2002). For a macro perspective of the functions of the media in society, we have taken inspiration from and Silverstone (2007). We argue that, despite the commercial interests and the instrumental and spectacular style that permeates the press worldwide, there is within the media conglomerates a professional minority that occupy a locus of resistance and are able to represent, while marginally, popular interests. We do not ignore, however, the knowledge constructed by the research in the fields of sociology of journalism , Schudson 1995, Gitlin 1980) and political economy of media but try to problematize questions concerning the structure of media organizations and devise concrete possibilities of transformation.
Imagined Journalists: New Framework for Studying Media-Audiences Relationship in Populist Times
The International Journal of Press/Politics, 2024
These are challenging times for journalists' relationship with their audiences. Attacks against "the media" and the increasing weaponization of social media to harass journalists have drawn the attention of scholars worldwide. In the current climate, journalists are not only distrusted but also hated, which creates a series of distinct ramifications. In this article, we suggest a new framework to study journalistsaudiences relationship, particularly in times of hostile populism: the imagined journalists approach. A mirror image of the much-studied concept of imagined audiences, imagined journalists refers to the entirety of ideas, feelings, stereotypes, and imaginaries that audiences hold regarding their imagined news producers. It brings together the research on media trust, audiences' perceptions, antimedia populism, and the emotional turn in journalism-to generate a comprehensive understanding of people's criticisms, narratives, and priorities. We demonstrate the potential of this approach by analyzing 1,215 responses to an open-ended question regarding journalists' traits in Israel in 2021. Employing qualitative and quantitative analyses, we find that: (a) right-wing and pro-populist voters hold more negative views of journalists, as expected; (b) voters express three different types of criticism of journalists (professional, personal, and national)-only one of which directly relates to their professional conduct; (c) different types of voters express different types of criticism; and (d) while objectivity and bias remain main concerns, democracy is not
Covering Populist Media Criticism: When Journalists' Professional Norms Turn Against Them
The International Journal of Communication, 2021
Various countries have seen a rise in populist rhetoric used by politicians, parties, and movements to discredit journalists, news outlets, and “The Media.” Research indicates that such rhetoric affects the public’s perceptions of the news media, posing a real challenge to professional journalism. Unlike other targets of populist criticism, journalists find themselves required to mediate that criticism to the public, which puts them in a particularly awkward position. Drawing on thematic analysis of 40 semistructured interviews with Israeli journalists who have been publicly scrutinized by Israel’s prime minister, this article suggests that journalists’ interpretation of traditional journalistic norms, and particularly the ethos of objectivity, leads them to amplify the accusations against them, while refraining from refuting them. As journalists confuse objectivity with passivity, the populist criticism turns into a sophisticated form of “soft” censorship, which uses imagined audiences to manipulate journalists’ professional norms against them.
Populism, Media and Journalism
Brazilian journalism research, 2021
The articles in this special issue on populism, media and journalism build on, but also contribute to the extensive literature on the nature and consequences of populism. Among the questions raised are those about the gap between populism’s radical democratic discourse and actual practice, the destructive effects of populism on the structure and dynamics of various social fields, the importance of context in determining the actual nature of populist discourse and practice, as well as the role of globalization as it interacts with local context. Anti-elitism, anti-pluralism, polarization, charismatic leadership are not new tropes in studies of populism, yet they gain new tones when its effects on media and journalism are assessed. All in all, the study of populism in media and journalism raises important questions about its specificity in the context of new forms of communication and connection, how crises can create opportunities for its emergences, and how difference political syst...
If the manner in which the press is financed constitutes a crucial question in our democracies, it remains, in France, a sociological black box. As Nathalie Sonnac and Jean Gabszewicz point out, “The relationship between journalists and proprietors is neither the best identified nor the most well-known, despite the numerous articles which have, notably, reported on purchases of media groups” (Sonnac, Gabszewicz, 2010, p. 74). In the United States, inversely, the theme gave rise to an important body of scientific literature. Phelippeau et Ragouet, regarding the question of political financing, remarked on the same gap between the abundant scientific literature across the Atlantic, and the scientific desert in the Hexagon. They saw a “specific national affinity in a general tendency for French researchers to abandon ‘the most common practical’ questions when it comes to dealing with politics” (p. 522). In fact, the few studies on the strictly material questions related to the press fall under economic discipline (Toussaint-Desmoulins, 2008 ; Sonnac, 2010) or history. It is indeed, through the prism of the “concentration” of the media that the question had primarily been addressed, which explains the almost the total lack of work adressing public media (with the exception of those by Sircusa, 2001, Endeweld, 2010), backed by political (L’Humanité, Present…), religious (La Croix), activist, (Témoignage Chrétien), associate groups, etc. Sociologists and political scientists are more interested in the relationships between the press and political power. My presentation proposes to explore the category of “independent media” in France. While emblematic newspapers fell into the hands of industrials, bankers and businessmen, a diversity of media replaced independence from economic and political powers as central values.
The Crisis of Journalism Reconsidered
2016
This collection of original essays brings a dramatically different perspective to bear on the contemporary "crisis of journalism." Rather than seeing technological and economic change as the primary causes of current anxieties, The Crisis of Journalism Reconsidered draws attention to the role played by the cultural commitments of journalism itself. Linking these professional ethics to the democratic aspirations of the broader societies in which journalists ply their craft, it examines how the new technologies are being shaped to sustain value commitments rather than undermining them. Recent technological change and the economic upheaval it has produced are coded by social meanings. It is this cultural framework that actually transforms these "objective" changes into a crisis. The book argues that cultural codes not only trigger sharp anxiety about technological and economic changes, but provide pathways to control them, so that the democratic practices of independent journalism can be sustained in new forms. jeffrey c. alexander is a leading social theorist who helped create the contemporary field of cultural sociology. He has written and edited dozens of books, among them The Meanings of Social Life, Trauma: A Social Theory, Performance and Power, The Civil Sphere, The Dark Side of Modernity, and Obama Power (with Bernadette Jaworsky). His books and articles have won various national and international awards. elizabeth butler breese is a sociologist who works with highgrowth technology and education companies. She has published media, public sphere, and celebrity research in several sociology and communications journals and has been called on to comment on social media trends in The New York Times, Wired, and AdAge. She is currently Marketing Director at Panorama Education. maría luengo is Associate Professor of Journalism at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, where she teaches and conducts research in the areas of media theory and journalism. Her work interprets developments at the nexus of social trends and movements, gender, migration, and journalistic culture and practice. She has published widely in the fields of journalism and media studies and co-authored Periodismo social (Social Journalism) with Juana Gallego (Síntesis 2014). Her research has appeared in Journalism Studies, Fudan Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, Communication & Society, and Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociológicas, among others.
Journalism, Representation and the Public Sphere (2015)
The topic “Journalism, Representation and the Public Sphere” is dedicated to the fundamental question: How do journalism, the various representations and public spheres of European cultures and societies change? This volume consists of the intellectual work of the 2014 European Media and Communication Doctoral Summer School, organized in cooperation with the European Communication Research and Education Association (ECREA) at the ZeMKI, the Centre for Media, Communication and Information Research of the University of Bremen, Germany. The chapters cover relevant research topics, structured into four sections: “Journalism and the News Media”, “Representation and Everyday Life”, “Public Sphere, Space and Politics”, “Rethinking Media Studies” and “Academic Practice”. Contributors are (in alphabetical order): Bertrand Cabedoche, Nico Carpentier, Andreas Hepp, François Heinderyckx, Magnus Hoem Iversen, Leif Kramp, Katrin Laas-Mikko, Maria Murumaa-Mengel, Georgina Newton, Hannu Nieminen, Alexandra Polownkikow, Pille Pruulmann-Vengerfeldt, Irena Reifová, Maria Schreiber, Saiona Stoian, Ebba Sundin, Simone Tosoni and Eimante Zolubiene. The book additionally contains abstracts of 41 doctoral projects that were discussed at the 2014 European Media and Communication Doctoral Summer School.