The Deviant Villain: The Construction of Villainy as Deviant Otherness in Mesopotamian Royal Rhetoric (original) (raw)
This article combines theoretical and historical approaches for studying notions of heroism and villainy in ancient Mesopotamia, as reflected in royal propaganda and rhetoric. It focuses on the different manners in which Mesopotamian kings of the second and first millennia BCE constructed the image of their rivals as villains who deviate from the standard characteristics of the heroic ruler. The theoretical framework of the article is based on heroism studies, a recently-established field within the social sciences, which studies the role of heroes and villains in human society. The article utilizes these theoretical considerations for analyzing Mesopotamian royal inscriptions where the ruler's rivals were portrayed as villains. Seven villain-archetypes are identified and discussed, each of which contrasting one or more of the typical heroic traits of the Mesopotamian ruler. By combining sociological, psychological and philological methodologies, this article offers a new perspective on ancient Mesopotamian society and culture.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Related papers
The Redemption of the Monster, or: The 'Evil Hero' in Ancient Epic
N. Coffee, Chr. Forstall, L. Galli Milić, D.P. Nelis (edd.), Intertextuality in Flavian Epic Poetry, Berlin-Boston, De Gruyter, pp. 283-304 , 2019
The goal of this paper is to reconstruct the network of intertextual connections that in ancient epic poetry link the most important evil heroes, from Homer’s Cyclops to Vergil’s Mezentius and Statius’ Capaneus, and to investigate the functions of this typological model in the value system of the epic genre. Through the character of the villain, and his final, if partial, redemption, epic poetry reflects on the (not always clear-cut) boundaries between good and evil, and invites its readers to broaden and deepen the understanding of the complexity of human nature.
" EARLY RULERS " AND THE VANITY THEME IN MESOPOTAMIAN WISDOM LITERATURE AND BEYOND
This article will examine the occurrence of the " Vanity Theme " in Mesopotamian wisdom literature and elsewhere. However, the main interest of this investigation lies in the list of rulers or illustrious men of old which is manifest in a variety of wisdom " Vanity Theme " compositions. We will argue that it will not suffice to speak about the " Vanity Theme " in various literatures of the ancient Near East and the Mediterranean. We should try to identify a particular literary expression that is associated with this type of composition. We contend that this expression is the list or naming of " Early Rulers " that comes to serve as an exemplum to the basic assertion of the " Vanity Theme. " Les neiges d'antan: " Gobernantes antiguos " y el tema de la vanidad en la literatura sapiencial de Mesopotamia y más allá Este artículo examinará la aparición del " tema de la vanidad " en la literatura sapien-cial de Mesopotamia y más allá. Sin embargo, el interés principal de esta investiga-ción radica en la lista de gobernantes u hombres ilustres de antaño que se manifiesta en una variedad de composiciones sapienciales con el " tema de la vanidad ". Argüiremos que no es suficiente con hablar sobre el " tema de la vanidad " en las diversas literaturas del antiguo Cercano Oriente y el Mediterráneo. Deberíamos tratar de identificar una expresión literaria particular que esté asociada con este tipo de composición. Sostenemos que esta expresión es la lista o denominación de los
For Whose Greater Good? The Case of Hero-Making: Girch and Darius
Heroism Science: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 2019
This article reviews an investigation into the case of Stanley Girch (aka Girėnas) and Stephen William Darius as (multi)transfigured and transforming heroes and seeks to examine a twofold assumption that has emerged in heroism science, namely that people create heroes mostly for the better and that learning from the past can help assess which heroes are needed. We argue that it may be beneficial to shift the focus of the analysis and follow the reverse course of a hero's journey, tracing the impact, evolution and origin of the heroic status ascribed to the historical figures, whether individual or collective. Presuming that heroic status follows contextualization of actions, the developmental phases, techniques, and authorship of hero-making can be revealed through a reverse analysis of multi-layered contexts. The findings have led to the unsettling conclusion that the making of historical heroes hardly served the greater good and was quite removed from what was thought necessary. The same contradiction, however, may give an impulse for further development of heroism science as it prompts a broad-based, interdisciplinary assessment of the effectiveness of hero-making in the past, its present influence and projections for the future.
Modern historians of ancient Mesopotamia are chiefly concerned with the deeds of the kings and mainly use sources which reflect conditions at the apex of Mesopotamian society. This paper attempts to investigate possible traces of discontent and opposition as well as the criteria involving the loss of the legitimacy of power in Early Mesopotamia. We will deal with two major types of sources: the early curse formulas in “royal” inscriptions, and the school-based tradition of Sumerian proverbs. Especially the latter allow for a more socially-balanced understanding of history.
The Vanity Theme and Critical Wisdom in Mesopotamian Literature
Altorientalische Forschungen, 2023
The heading "vanity theme" has been attributed to various Sumerian and Akkadian literary compositions that would represent a form of wisdom critical of traditional values. The present article revises those compositions arguing that they do not propound a critical view of traditional wisdom but simply reflect on the finitude of human nature. Critical wisdom only surfaces in a limited number of compositions mostly attested in Middle Babylonian sources. The vanity theme is not only tied to critical views of traditional values but is a flexible literary motif that was adapted to different contexts and compositions.
On violence, error and royal succession in Neo-Assyrian times
Violence seems to have been considered in Mesopotamian texts according to two main perspectives represented in mythology and celebrative historiography: a perspective from which war appears as one of the rational means for the ordering of the world through the king's conquests, which defeat contrary forces, and a perspective from which conflict is the result of a vacuum of divine power and the unleashing of irrational forces. Concentrating our attention on the NA period, we may detect the first view amply exemplified by royal inscriptions, which often dwell on demonstrating the "reasons" of war; the second receives ample elaboration in Erra and Išum. The poem, freely adapting literary motifs, describes scenarios in which violence is not a means of conquest, but rather a process of senseless destruction, as represented in detail especially in the fourth tablet of the tale. Due to the well-known parallelism between heavenly and earthly spheres and in particular the analogy drawn between cosmic and political power, historical events may be interpreted according to literary clichés and the two perspectives combined.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.