Some Reflections on the Constitutional Review in Albania in a Comparison Key (original) (raw)
Related papers
The 2020 International Review of Constitutional Reform Albania
The 2020 International Review of Constitutional Reform, 2021
Abstract This report on the developments of constitutional reforms in Albania during 2020 was published in the edited book "The 2020 International Review of Constitutional Reform" (ISBN: 978-1-7374527-0-6). During 2020, an electoral reform was carried out in Albania, which included not only changes to the Electoral Code, but also constitutional changes.
Academic Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 2021
This study aims to address the functioning and cooperation of constitutional bodies in the Republic of Albania. It aims to highlight the often-rigid relationship between them for the establishment of constitutional bodies, especially when this process needs to pass through a spirit of cooperation. More specifically, the paper will refer to the lack of functioning of the Constitutional Court in the Republic of Albania. This lack, without question, has brought a problem in the functioning and consolidation of the rule of law in the Republic of Albania. Although the great constitutional reform of 2016, seemed to undertake through non-political constitutional bodies to solve the problems that are often created through bodies of a political nature, this so far has not yielded the expected results. The opposite has happened, the non-political constitutional body, which has a role in the appointment of judges of the Constitutional Court seems to have further fueled the conflict between the...
POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL LAW IN ALBANIA (1912-1939) Resume
Institucionet Politike dhe e Drejta Kushtetuese në Shqipëri (1912-1939), 1998
This paper is a summary in English of the book "Political institutions and constitutional law in Albania (1912-1939)". The book was written in Albanian, while this resume is in English as a separate chapter. The summary contains knowledge on the development of constitutional law in Albania during the period 1912-1939, which were intense years for the creation and consolidation of the independent Albanian state.
The independence of the state and the integrity of its territory, dignity of the individual, human rights and freedoms, social justice, constitutional order, pluralism, national identity and inheritance, religious coexistence, as well as coexistence with, and understanding of Albanians for, minorities are the bases of this state, which has the duty of respecting and protecting them.
Conference Proceedings:THE NEXT SEVEN OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Reports from the Seventh International Scientific Conference of the European Studies Department, Faculty of Philosophy at Sofia University “St. Kliment Ohridski” May 2020, 2020
In accordance with the obligations undertaken in the process of the accession to the European Union, the three candidate countries in the Western Balkans have initiated or undergone the process of changing their constitutional acts in order to align them with the requirements stemming from Chapter 23 Judiciary and Fundamental Rights. The paper aims to analyse how Montenegro and Serbia approached this commitment as an integral and essential part of the Action Plans for Chapter 23, while Albania did it as a part of the preparation of the country to receive the candidate status and the opening of accession talks. Subsequently, the paper shows that during the drafting process, the three states were guided by the standards defined by the Venice Commission in its opinions and proposals as well as the EC views received within consultative processes they have undertaken. It also points out the differences in the approach to the content of the changes by the European Union and the Venice Commission in the three cases. While Serbia still has to implement these changes, this paper also presents the diverse experience in Montenegro since 2013 and Albania since 2016 in relation to the implementation of the Constitutional amendments in practice and the effects it has had. Furthermore, the paper discusses the effects of the Constitutional reform in the light of the Enlargement Policy considering the latest developments and the fact that the Rule of Law is an essential part of these processes and the EU requirements. Finally, the paper concludes that the Venice Commission, invited by the European Commission, has provided the three states with its opinion guided both by technical, but also political principles, which, as an effect, has produced a diverse approach to how certain elements of the constitution treat the independence and autonomy of the judiciary within the process of integration in the EU.
ISSUES OF THE ALBANIAN CONSTITUTION IN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE EUROPEAN INTEGRATION
The Albanian Constitution, after the signing of Association Agreements with many Eastern European countries, provides for a number of provisions which serve the integration process of Albania in the European Union. Until it came into force, it was only the Constitution of Poland which contained provisions on the terms of integration and the delegation of powers. In other countries of Central and Eastern Europe, which had signed European Association Agreements, the amendments of the Constitution were realized, especially, in the 2000-es. In the meantime, in old EU-member countries, there were different delegation models, which were mainly defined by the amendments of the Constitutions 1. Different authors mention some factors, which made the amendments in the constitutions of other Central and Eastern European countries to be accomplished with difficulty. Among the main factors it's worth to mention: the suspicions of the people about the delegation of the sovereignty; the spread of euro-skepticism in a number of candidate countries, as well as the referendum-applied experiences, which in some cases have delayed the processes. 2 Thus, a deceleration was kept in the revision of the constitution, with the aim of not transforming the quite advanced formulations on the delegation of the sovereignty into a battle horse for the pretentions of the euro-skeptics. In case of Albania we do notice some differences. It had a climate, which from the formal constitutional point of view, it hadn't suffered from any " European deficit " , that's to say, from any lack of constitutional provisions which authorize the processes of a complete integration in EU. Important terms of integration were provided for in the Constitution of the year 1998, on the eve of the beginning of the Stabilization and Association Process with Albania. These predictions were supported by the European feelings of the Albanian people and were result of the experiences on the amendment of the constitutions from the old EU-member countries, as well as of the constitutional opinion developed in Europe. The public opinion in Albania has created a rather optimist situation about the Euro-Atlantic integration of Albania, which was explicitly expressed since the first movements for democracy, in the 90-ies. The voice of the Euro-skeptics remained
The Effects of Constitutional Changes on the Judiciary System in Albania: The Process of Vetting
Academic Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 2022
The adoption of laws in Albania is often achieved through consensus among legislators, declaring it as the best solution for a certain political or legal situation, which resulted ineffective in many cases. The focus of law improvements was concentrated on control/Vetting, that is, the exclusion from the judicial system of individuals who do not meet one of the three constitutional criteria (wealth, moral integrity, and professionalism). Vetting, control per se, is not a reform of justice, but only one of its constitutive phases. The Albanian Constitution changes aim to restructure the justice institutions to achieve the standards requested for the Albanian EU integration. The paper goes through the different constitutional reforms, focusing on the judicial system changes especially on the recent results of the vetting process in Albania. The questions like: How is the Vetting process affecting judicial standards, how are the new Albanian justice institutions reacting, what is the p...
Jus, International Law & Economics, History & Society, 2017
The reform of the judicial system, which has recently been implemented in Albania, has included many elements about the organization and functioning of the courts and the public prosecutor's office. The main objective was to fight corruption and regain the public confidence in the judiciary. But in the framework of this reform, many important changes have been made, which affacted and changed some parts of the constitutional justice system, thus increasing the individual's access to the Constitutional Court. Regardless of the negative public opinion about the judicial system in general, public opinion is different as regard the Constitutional Court. Although we can not confirm that this opinion is totally positive, in general, the opinion about the Court is more positive from Albanian public. The main activity of this Court is linked to the defense of fundamental rights and freedoms, even though its jurisdiction so far has been limited. So individuals could claim to the Constitutional Court, only when their rights for a fair trial were violated. This restriction, which was also evident in the interpretation of the same Constitutional Court, which applied the fair process solely from the procedural point of view, and not the substantive one, resulted in limiting the access of the individual. However, individual requests to this Court increased year after year. For this reason, the legislator has, in the context of the new constitutional amendments, envisioned an extension of the circle of subjects who may appeal to the Constitutional Court and have as their mission the defense of the fundamental human rights and freedoms. An important change has also been made to the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court, which can now accept and analyze individual claims about the violation of all rights under the Albanian constitution. This way of acting, extending the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court, but also extending the circle of people who can appeal to this court, leads to the creation of two mechanisms, according to which individuals can access the constitutional justice system. The first possibility is the direct one. According to this possibility, the individual can directly access the Constitutional Court, but as a mechanism takes longer and is much longer, because it requires as a prerequisite the exhaustion of all legal means available. The purpose of this presentation is precisely the analysis of the second possibility, given that it is the only direct means with which the individual can personally dialogue with the Constitutional Court. The second is the indirect one. On the basis of this possibility, the individual may submit a complaint to the institutions which, according to the Constitution, may appeal to the Constitutional Court. In this way, these institutions, if they note that violations of the constitutional rights of the individual are due to legal action, have the right to apply to the Constitutional Court. This possibility, even if it leaves the possibility of appeal in the judgment of another body, has the advantage of being a shorter road to addressing the constitutional system for the defense of civil rights.
Interdisciplinary journal of research and development, 2023
This paper discusses how Albania's fundamental human rights are guaranteed by the Constitution and how the Constitutional Court's jurisprudence has contributed to this effort. It includes two aspects of their treatment: the constitutional background and some of the most important decisions made by the Constitutional Court concerning the protection of fundamental human rights. Its goal is to provide the reader with a brief overview of the Constitutional Court's role in this regard while also acting as a jurisprudential guide for the protection of fundamental rights. Although this topic has been covered by some legal experts in previous works, it is particularly relevant now that the Republic of Albania is celebrating the 25th anniversary of the adoption of its Constitution because it highlights the Constitutional Court's contribution even after the Law Reform of the year 2016 and the innovations it brought about. The methodology employed to produce this paper involves processing and analysing secondary data obtained through various means, both qualitatively and quantitatively. The primary focus is on the decisions made by the Constitutional Court between the end of 1998 and the present, viewed through the lens of human rights. The methodological part that is based on interviews or other primary data is not included in the study because of its nature and the time constraints. The article concludes that in order to prevent inconsistencies within the current jurisprudence and to provide more substantive rights for individuals, including those that will be expanded after 2016, it is necessary to add qualitative aspects to its consolidation and to expand it quantitatively.
Interdisciplinary journal of research and development, 2023
The purpose of this article is to analyze the provisions of international law in the Constitution of the Republic of Albania of 1998, from the point of view of the accession to the European Union. The analysis was carried out firstly in the context of the principle of supremacy and the principle of direct application and secondly given the accession of the Republic of Albania to international organizations. This analysis is intended to understand the constitutional framework in light of the accession of the Republic of Albania in the European Union. The analysis of the constitutional provisions important for the accession of the Republic of Albania in the European Union was done through the descriptive method.