Partisan self-interest and electoral reform: The new Italian electoral law of 2005 (original) (raw)
Related papers
THE ROLE OF POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE ITALIAN ELECTORAL REFORMS
Revista Catalana de Dret Públic, (57), 154-165, 2018
The aim of this paper is to understand the role played by political parties in the electoral reforms that have characterised the Italian experience since 1993. In order to do so, the authors: 1) describe the scholarly debate on how parties relate to electoral rules and form of government; 2) shed light on the most significant aspects of the Italian electoral reforms at local, regional and State level; and 3) analyse these reforms from the perspective of the party context. The conclusion is that parties have played only a partial role: while strong pressure to implement change has derived from external factors (referendum and judicial interventions), a widespread tendency towards concentrating power and personalising the political forces has ignored the importance of party dynamics in the way that parliamentary forms of government function.
The new Italian electoral system and its effects on strategic coordination and disproportionality
2018
On 26 October 2017, the Italian Parliament approved a new electoral system nicknamed Rosatellum after Ettore Rosato, head of the Partito Democratico’s (PD, Democratic Party) parliamentary group in the Chamber, who was the first proponent of the law. The new electoral system is the fourth since 1993. It is a mixed system, like the others, and it applies to both the Chamber and the Senate. Roughly two thirds of the seats are assigned with a proportional formula in multi-member districts. The remaining seats are assigned in single-member districts with plurality rule. The impact of the new electoral system in terms of party representation has been more proportional than majoritarian. No party or coalition won an absolute majority of seats. However, if we look at its overall per- formance the picture is mixed. After all, the SMDs are a potent tool and they have made the difference in terms of voting behaviour and pattern of competition. Two pre-electoral coalitions have been formed, the...
This paper aims to rebuild the Italian electoral reform’s age started in 1993, whose beginning marked the end of the “First Republic”, from a rational-choice perspective, while supporting our argument according to which the electoral reforms’ “direction of motion” can be explained through the power holder’s preferences; in other words, changes in electoral systems mirror changes in the power holder’s perception of its position within the party system. In the first section 4 we will provide a theoretical framework and two resulting hypothesis; in the second section, given the power holder’s provisions regarding the forthcoming round of elections and the resulting preferences, we will try to catch each single reform’s ratio in order to test our hypothesis; the third section is dedicated to the new MES’s hypothetical effects on the power holder’s future electoral performances; in the fourth section, conclusions will be drawn and our theoretical framework’s limitation will be highlighted.
The Effects of Electoral Reform in Italy
This article evaluates the impact of the 1993 electoral reform in Italy on four political dependent variables: clear winners and concomitant leftright alternation in government; fragmentation of the party system; governmental stability; and party polarization. The reform, under which 75 percent of parliamentary seats are allocated according to the plurality rule and the remaining 25 percent according to proportional representation, had a declared majoritarian purpose. As a useful benchmark, the attributes associated with a pure majoritarian system are measured against the actual effects that the reform has brought about. Analyzing the outcomes of the general elections of 1994, 1996 and 2001, it is concluded that the changes the new electoral law has engendered on the Italian political system have fallen well short of the stated aspirations of the reformers.