Authenticity in Voltourism: A motive for a decommodified form of tourism (original) (raw)
Related papers
Authenticity as a concept in tourism research
This article discusses the uses of the concept of authenticity in tourism studies. In line with the constructivist perspective which aims to transcend the binary distinction between the authentic and inauthentic as found in the concept of authenticity, it is suggested that this binary dichotomy also has to be overcome in the approaches to the tourist role. If authenticity can be linked to an experience of collective identifications made by the individual, the point can be made that insights from studies of ritual and social performances will be fertile in analysing how such experiences are constituted in social processes. This processual approach may then reveal how authenticity is influenced by subjective and collective views on consensus, creativity and existentialism in the tourist role.
The Paradox of Authenticity and Its Implications for Contemporary and “Bizarre” Tourism Campaigns
Advances in Business Strategy and Competitive Advantage
In this chapter, the paradox of authenticity in the content of the contemporary and "bizarre" tourism campaigns is explored. It is a reflective study that relies on a structure review approach, which aims to give a flavour on how the arguments are presented. The studies examine the structure of the intertwined variables and its implications for tourists' 'lifeworld'. This study suggests that the tourists' lived experience is constructed from their point of view as consumers. In particular, it indicates that (1) pretentious language remains the ultimate power as commodification: and (2) although, tourism campaigns may influence visitors' intentions they may have only a minor effect on the formation of a favourable brand image of the destination. This study extends the discourse on authenticity as the essence of brand differentiation in the destination branding domain and raises issues for further research.
Interpretations of authenticity in tourism
Ever since MacCannell 1 first emphasized the key role authenticity plays in tourism, it has been an important topic in sociologic studies, resulting in various theories attempting to explain the term in the context of the tourism science. It became even more central with the emergence of the experience economy. Companies of various sectors are trying to brand their products as authentic ("Authentic Watches", "Annette -the authentic Moroccan restaurant in Sofia", "Vans Authentic"). The trend is most evident in tourism, with a huge number of destinations being branded as authentic. This paper tries to outline the basic developments, as well as the recent trends in authenticity as manifested in tourism theory and practice.
While volunteer tourism is often popularly portrayed as a more ethical and positive form of tourism, in recent years it has also been subject to much criticism. However, terms such as 'the volunteer tourism industry' or 'voluntourism' do not necessarily account for the diversity of organisations. Similarly volunteer tourists are also placed into categories that do not necessarily distinguish between demographics or motivations. This paper draws on my doctoral research of two small scale organisations in South America which I categorise as decommodified volunteer tourism, appealing to longer term independent backpacker travellers, looking for meaningful encounters with local people. Being attentive to these kinds of decommodified organisations and their volunteers can go some way in understanding and thus promoting a more equitable industry which can be more beneficial for both volunteers and locals involved in the experience.
Authenticity: tourism and the implications of a constructivist approach
The concept of authenticity and its connection to the original, genuine or real has long been debated within a range of fields. One of the largest fields of debate has emerged within tourism literature, due to commentators arguing that tourists are continually on a quest for authenticity. In recent times, this notion has been challenged due to the rising popularity of tourists visiting attractions that may be deemed ‘inauthentic’ by researchers such as Disney World. These notions have also extended to cultural and heritage fields, through the use of ‘inauthentic’ objects such as replicas, reproductions and copies displayed alongside originals objects in destinations such as museums and heritage sites. In discussing the emergence of three different approaches to authenticity within tourism literature, this paper is separated into multiple sections, in order to provide a summary of the debates that continue to plague the sector. This paper is separated into four distinct sessions. The first section provides an overview of the concept of authenticity within tourism and traces its origins to MacCannell, who introduced the subject in the early 1970s. The second section attempts to distinguish the differences between objects that may be deemed inauthentic, such as replicas, copies, forgeries and fakes, and argues that it is the intention of duplicated items that characterizes them as either inherently negative or positive. The third section covers the three main approaches to authenticity, objectivism, postmodern and constructivist, and argues that the third approach allows for copied or replicated items to be deemed as authentic. While the fourth and final section, attempts to illustrate how the popularity of the constructivist approach to authenticity is navigated by museum audiences through recent research undertaken by the Deutsches Museum.
The role of authenticity in tourism planning: Empirical findings from southeast Spain
Tourism. An International Interdisciplinary …, 2007
Tourism is the main economic activity in many towns in the province of Alicante in southeast Spain and has turned this area into a paradigmatic example of mass tourism on the Mediterranean coast. Since the 1960s, the province's coastal towns have opted for a development model centred on what is known as 'residential tourism' or 'second-home tourism', with few exceptions, such as Benidorm. We wish to put forward the argument that the main social agents in the tourism sector have not perceived the 'search for authenticity' as a factor that may attract tourists to this area. To this end, we will start by reviewing critically the theoretical discourse about the role played by authenticity in the motivation of tourists. Then we will discuss some of the results obtained from empirical, qualitative research that included 37 in-depth interviews. As a guide for our empirical research, we use a model based on the stakeholder theory. The epistemological difficulties faced by researchers do not justify certain critical arguments that try to highlight the impossibility of operationalising essential concepts and approaches such as that of authenticity. Therefore, it is necessary that empirical research continues to delve into the sociological keys that determine the 'search for authenticity' in the tourists' experience
International Conference on Tourism Research, 2024
The paper examines the theoretical interconnection between the concepts of voluntourism, community-based tourism, and regenerative tourism. Voluntourism, widely criticized for its implementations unethical towards local environment and community, is re-evaluated in the light of community-based and regenerative tourism principles including unequal power dynamics and questionable long-term benefits to host communities. This paper claims that re-imagining voluntourism within the framework of regenerative tourism offers a new perspective. Regenerative tourism, characterized by its commitment to restoring, revitalizing, and enhancing the wellbeing of both natural environments and local communities, can serve as a guiding principle for voluntourism programs. Community-based tourism is integral to this theoretical exploration, as it emphasizes local participation, cultural and natural preservation, and economic empowerment. When voluntourism aligns with community-based tourism principles, it shifts its focus from shortterm, self-serving actions to responsible community-driven initiatives. By channelling the motivation and resources of volunteers towards community-led regenerative initiatives, voluntourism can contribute to positive, lasting impacts. Ethical reflection is done within the actors only. This paper is theoretical; however, its purpose is in the pragmatism of tourism concept development. It concludes to enhance the understanding of voluntourism's potential to transition from a problematic form of tourism to an ethical and responsible force for change. By reconciling voluntourism with the principles of regenerative tourism and community-based tourism, this paper aims to provide a theoretical foundation for the development of more responsible and sustainable tourism practices. In doing so, it strives to contribute to the theoretical knowledge surrounding alternative and socially sustainable tourism concepts.