Climate Change and Human Rights (original) (raw)
2008, Development
https://doi.org/10.1057/DEV.2008.35
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
Wolfgang Sachs asks who are the winners, and who the losers in climate change? He makes the case that cuts in fossil fuel use are imperative not only to protect the atmosphere but also to protect human rights.
Related papers
Climate Change : A Threat To Human Rights
Glaciers are melting, sea levels are rising, cloud forests are dying, and wildlife is scrambling to keep pace because of Global Climate change. Climate change is one of the biggest crises that humanity is facing. As a result of climate change there are more intense storms, more rain followed by longer and drier droughts (a challenge for growing crops), changes in the ranges in which plants and animals can live, and loss of water supplies that have historically come from glaciers. Climate change has already had observable effects on the environment. It is already affecting society in far reaching ways. In fact most human activities have an effect on and are influenced by environmental and climate change factors. Evidence for climate change abounds, from the top of the atmosphere to the depths of the oceans. Certain type of extreme weather events like Rising Sea levels, Floods, Heat Waves, Droughts, Desertification, water shortages, the spread of tropical and vector borne diseases have become more frequent and/or intense. These and other aspects of climate change affect the enjoyment of Human Rights by people throughout the world including – right to life, right to health, right to housing, right to an adequate standard of living, right to food, right to water, right to property, right to self-determination and also damaging some sectors of our economy. The present paper focuses on the Climate change and its impact on Human Rights. Climate change has emerged as one of the major threat to Human Rights of our generation. Climate change poses an enormous threat to the lives and well-being of individuals and communities across the world. The negative impacts caused by climate change are global, simultaneous and increasing exponentially according to the degree of climate change that ultimately takes place. Climate change, therefore, requires a global rights-based response. One reason for the attention to the relationship between climate change and human rights is the recognition that climate change is having an uneven impact across the world.
CLIMATE JUSTICE: CLIMATE CHANGE AND HUMAN RIGHTS
Denialism and Human Rights, 2019
Book chapter: Author of Chapter: ‘Climate Justice: Climate Change and Human Rights, in book: “Denialism and Human Rights”, by Roland Moerland, Hans Nelen (Eds), Cambridge University Press, 2017. ABSTRACT: The inadequate commitment of academia to Climate Change research, and the neglected, under-developed state of Climate Justice, must be addressed and counter-acted. The following paper aspires to pay a small contribution to that specific cause. This essay is based on the fact that Climate Change is undermining the fulfillment of internationally protected Human Rights, like the rights to health and life; the right to food, water, shelter, property; rights associated with livelihood and culture; with migration and resettlement; and with personal security in the event of conflict. The worst effects of Climate Change are principally felt by those whose rights protections are already insufficient. In this essay, I highlight these risks and advocate their consideration. Additionally I ask questions such as: What are the Human Rights repercussions of Climate Change, and how does the extensive organisation of international Human Rights law and knowledge, convey that phenomenon? Where does international Human Rights law overlap with or provoke duties under the embryonic Climate Justice regime? Where should Climate Change strategies challenge Human Rights essentials? My ambition is to clarify the confusion covering this area of study, and by examining the relationship between Climate Change and Human Rights, an attempt is made to discover, examine, and analyse their most essential links.
Forging the Nexus of Climate Change and Human Rights
European Journal of Law and Political Science
The impact of climate change on human rights is a serious worry for the global community and is receiving more attention from both policymakers and researchers. However, information in this sector is sparse and fragmented. In an effort to highlight the difficulties facing humanity due to climatic factors, this article examines the rising emphasis given to human rights principles. It examines the linkages between human rights and legal responses to climate change and argued that certain connections exist between the two. The extent to which the international system sufficiently safeguards the human rights of those who are negatively impacted by climate change is examined. In conclusion, it makes suggestions for enhancing the protection of human rights in the context of climate change.
Climate Change and Human Rights: notes for a talk at the Inaugural Terry Hampson Dinner
International human rights instruments emerged after the Second World War and the UDHR was adopted on 10 December 1948. Since then binding human rights instruments have been developed and adapted to different areas of the human condition. International concern about degradation of the environment commenced with the Stockholm Conference in 1972. There is much crossover between concerns with a healthy environment and other human rights principles. The receipt by the HRC of framework principles on human rights and the environment brings us closer to a binding human rights instrument that directly addresses the right to a healthy and sustainable environment.
Climate Change and Human Rights: Unpacking the Issues
Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law, 2010
Global warming is expected to contribute to many human wrongs: disease, malnutrition, flooding of coastal communities. But does every human wrong violate a human right? Should we conceptualize climate change not only as an environmental problem – the preeminent one of our time – but also as a human rights violation? Proposals to treat climate change as a human rights problem raise many fundamental questions. Theoretically, what does it mean to conceptualize climate change in human rights terms? How would a human rights approach differ from treating climate change as an environmental or economic or scientific problem? Descriptively, what does human rights law say about climate change and, conversely, what does climate change law say about human rights? Normatively, does it make sense to approach climate change as a human rights issue? What are the pros and cons? This brief introduction to a symposium issue of the Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law on climate change and human rights seeks to map out the overarching distinctions and questions.
Climate Change and Human Rights: Themes for a New Government
Climate Change and Human Rights: Themes for a New Government, 2013
The environmentalism spawned by Ms Carson's Silent Spring must always be tempered to ensure that the poor and the powerless who suffer most also receive protection and relief. Human rights principles can assist in ensuring that this also occurs in the fight to mitigate climate change.
A Human Rights Based Approach to Climate Change
This thesis researches if human rights law can be the foundation of a legal framework to stop climate change. First, it is proved that climate change meets the definition of Hardin’s ‘tragedy of the commons’: a common resource is exploited without a regulatory framework that prevents overexploitation. The atmosphere is a common resource that suffers from overexploitation due to the emissions of greenhouse gases by human activities. This causes climate change. Only a regulatory framework that entails all the subjects that are responsible for this overexploitation can avoid a tragedy commons such as climate change. The attempts made in the past to create an effective global regulatory framework have failed. There are clear linkages between climate change and human rights. Climate change interferes with the enjoyment of several human rights. Both civil and political rights and economic, social and cultural rights are under pressure due to climate change. For that reason, it is justified to research if international human rights law can be the foundation of a global regulatory framework to stop climate change. Human rights law could be a basis to force states and non-state actors to lower their greenhouse gas emissions and avoid the tragedy of the commons of climate change. Environmental human rights jurisprudence has developed procedural and substantive standards and requires states to regulate private actors. This is derived from economic, social and cultural rights and from civil and political rights. However, this jurisprudence is in the context of environmental problems within one state. If these principles were to be applied to a global problem such as climate change, the duties arising out of human rights must be extended extraterritorially. The duties arising from civil and political rights are not easily translated in extraterritorial obligations. However, the duties arising out of economic, social and cultural rights can be extended extraterritorially using the ‘duty to cooperate’. The duty to cooperate makes it possible to apply the standards developed in environmental human rights jurisprudence to the global problem of climate change. It requires states to work together to solve climate change. This can found the regulatory framework to avoid the tragedy of the commons of climate change in international human rights law. Using the duty to cooperate proves to be a legitimate option to come to a human rights based approach to climate change.
The Nexus of Climate Action and Human Rights, with a Focus on Sustainable Energy Transitions
2019
The scale of the potential human rights impacts of climate change are astounding. Up to an additional 600 million people could face hunger by 2080 due to climate change. 7 Even if the global temperature rises no more than 2°C, one in seven people in the world will face a severe reduction in water resources. 8 Between 2008 and 2015, 157.8 million people were forced from their homes in the past seven years as a result of extreme weather. 9 It is also estimated that between 2030 and 2050, climate change is expected to cause approximately 250,000 additional deaths per year, from malnutrition, malaria, diarrhoea and heat stress. 10 As a threat to global security and prosperity, climate change has a multitude of effects on the protection and fulfilment of human rights. Some are direct effects such as in the case of damage caused by rising sea levels, extreme weather events and natural disasters brought about by climate change. 11 Others are more indirect ripple effects or slow onset effects such as in terms of the right to health caused by deteriorating underlying social and environmental determinants of health and increases in food, water and vector-borne diseases, 12 or violations of the rights of indigenous peoples through state responses to climate change that would affect indigenous lands, livelihoods and way of life. 13 Former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson has called climate change the "greatest threat to human rights in twenty-first century". 14 As a result, the consequences of unmitigated climate change cannot be underestimated and states must act quickly to both minimize the potential catastrophic effects of climate change while also preparing societies to become more resilient in the face of a harsh new climate reality. A joint statement by human rights NGO Amnesty International and environmental NGO Greenpeace in the lead-up to the 21 st Conference of Parties (COP) to the UN Framework Convention 7 Greenpeace and Amnesty International. "Joint Statement: Protection of human rights from climate change requires urgent shift to 100% renewable energy for all." (2015). 8 Ibid 9 Ibid 10 "Climate Change and Health" (2018).
Human rights and the impacts of climate change: Revisiting the assumptions
Oñati Socio-Legal Series, 2020
The Paris Agreement acknowledges the need to tackle the permanent and irreversible impacts of climate change. It does not, however, provide means to hold state and non-state actors accountable for the harm to persons, property and the environment associated with climate change. In 2009, the Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights (OHCHR) noted that qualifying the effects of climate change as human rights violations posed a series of technical obstacles. More than a decade later, applicants around the world increasingly rely on human rights law and institutions to complain about harms associated with the impacts of climate change. National, regional and international human rights bodies stand on the frontline to bridge the accountability gap left by the Paris Agreement. This article therefore revisits the OHCHR’s assumptions, suggesting that we use human rights as an interim “gap-filler”, while we seek better tools to tackle the impacts of climate change.
Related topics
Cited by
Cause and response: vulnerability and climate in the Anthropocene
Journal of Peasant Studies, 2014
Causal analysis of vulnerability aims to identify root causes of crises so that transformative solutions might be found. Yet root-cause analysis is absent from most climate response assessments. Framings for climate-change risk analysis often locate causality in hazards while attributing some causal weight to proximate social variables such as poverty or lack of capacity. They rarely ask why capacity is lacking, assets are inadequate or social protections are absent or fail. This contribution frames vulnerability and security as matters of access to assets and social protections. Assets and social protections each have their own context-contingent causal chains. A key recursive element in those causal chains is the abilitymeans and powersof vulnerable people to influence the political economy that shapes their assets and social protections. Vulnerability is, as Sen rightly observed, linked to the lack of freedomthe freedom to influence the political economy that shapes these entitlements. In the Anthropocene, human causes of climate hazard must also now be accounted for in etiologies of disaster. However, attention to anthropogenic climate change should not occlude social causes of (and responsibility for) vulnerabilityvulnerability is still produced in and by society.
Globalizations, 2014
The term 'new materialism' has recently gained saliency as a descriptor for an eclectic range of positions that question the human centred and human exclusive focus of scholarship across the humanities and social sciences. In turn these emerging perspectives have been subject to critique by those writing in the established materialist tradition who argue that new materialism ignores the unique specificity of human agency and the transformatory capabilities of our species. Our previous interventions have endorsed a particular account of posthumanism that draws together complexity influenced systems theory with elements of political ecologism that have incorporated aspects of established materialist and humanist thinking. This article rejects the old materialist critique that denies the emancipatory potential of posthumanist thinking, and explores the potential for an emancipatory posthumanism.
Ambiente & Sociedade, 2014
Rainfall is a natural event having significant impact in the state of Espírito Santo (Brazil), resulting in floods and mass movements, damaging communities in a historical situation of socio-environmental vulnerability. The State Civil Defense is mobilized towards risk mitigation through the State Civil Defense Department (CEDEC) and through the development of the State Protection and Civil Defense Plan, coordinating multiple social actors. This paper aims to analyze the acts and role of the State in response to extreme events, focusing on how vulnerability, risk and disaster in the urban environment are tackled by government policy. Furthermore, it aims to discuss the contemporaneous actions after Hyogo 2005-2015, focusing on the concept of resilient cities, given the relevance of prevention work and actions by local actors, governmental or not, in the process of risk and disaster reduction and of mitigating vulnerabilities, demonstrating the application of the global discussion in...
Human Rights Education Review
What if the way we (teach and learn to) speak about human rights crises is part of these crises? This conceptual paper sets out to explore the role of a human rights-informed pedagogy of hope in helping learners cultivate languages of hope and advocacy in the context of language education for sustainable development. Recognising that a focus on agency connects critical pedagogies of hope, human rights education, and language education, this contribution argues that the language classroom may become a space of hope by offering stories of hope, change, and transformation to help learners envision a better future and take communicative action towards these futures. Cultivating languages of hope and advocacy highlights the learners’ role as active change agents who assume responsibility in the face of their human rights duties and act accordingly. Thus, human rights-informed language education may empower learners to contribute to living together in a more sustainable and just world.
Related papers
Human Rights and Climate Change: Building Synergies for a Common Future
Human rights exist only on the margins of the existing international climate change regime. Undoubtedly, bringing a human rights framework to international efforts can help to solidify the ethical moorings needed to compel meaningful action to address climate change. However, while advocates of a rights-based approach to climate change agree that human rights principles should underpin global climate change policies, there are many variations in how human rights may be defined, justified, and brought to bear in the climate change arena. This chapter reviews several leading approaches and proposals for strengthening the connection between climate change and human rights. Each approach presents innovative options for marshaling human rights as both a rhetorical tool to help promote the achievement of a global climate change agreement, and also to influence the negotiation and content of a strong, effective, and equitable framework. Nevertheless, it remains a research challenge how to integrate human rights norms into an international climate change regime.
Climate Change and Human Rights: Amicable or Arrested Development?
Suggested citation: 1(2) Journal of Human Rights and the Environment (2010) 236 This article considers the attention which is increasingly afforded to human rights norms in the attempt to highlight the challenges facing humankind as a result of climate change. It analyses the links between legal responses to climate change and human rights and argues that certain connections exist between the two. This is particularly the case in domestic settings. At the same time, a number of significant limitations exist which are likely to hamper the use of human rights law in climate change settings.
Climate change and human rights: Roles, responsibilities and actions
The world's climate is changing, with insidious effects that steadily erode the quality of life of those who depend on the environment. The dramatic effects of this change are evident in the form of an exceptional accumulation of natural disasters. In the two decades since the U.N. recognized climate change as a potential threat, climate change has emerged as a real and worsening danger to health, human rights, and human well-being. Accordingly, climate change has become an integral part of the discussion surrounding human rights advocacy and action, in particular it is suggested that a rights based approach to climate change offers potential for engagement and mitigation of the effects of climate change on vulnerable populations.
Climate Justice and Human Rights, in a World in Climate Emergency
Global Campus Policy Briefs, 2021
Dr. Zoi Aliozi, Global Campus of Human Rights, 2021. Abstract Climate justice is the blueprint for a fair and sustainable future of life on this planet. Climate justice can be understood as a lens for looking at climate change as a social, ethical and legal issue, rather than solely an environmental one. This frame of justice has in its core the protection of human rights and of the most vulnerable in a climate changed world. Climate justice should be seen as a flexible umbrella that is about ensuring that the process of implementing policies to tackle the anthropogenic harms of climate change is mirroring the rule of law and is developed on a rights-based approach. It is a matter of global justice with duties spreading from the international to the regional and national stakeholders. If the United Nations (UN) fails to promote climate justice, then we collectively fail to protect human rights and negligently violate the rights of future generations. This policy brief outlines the linkages of human rights and climate change, by advocating for climate justice. Climate change is undermining the fulfilment of internationally protected human rights, like the rights to health and life; the rights to food, water, shelter and property; rights associated with livelihood and culture; and with migration and resettlement. The worst effects of climate change are principally felt by those whose rights protections are already insufficient. The main message of this brief is intended to raise awareness about the climate emergency that our world is under, and to extend an urgent call for immediate climate action addressed to all stakeholders in the European Union (EU) and UN levels, including politicians, law and policy makers as well as to civil society. After three decades of negotiating about the reach and power of climate laws and policies, we have reached a point that the negative effects of climate change are directly harming human rights on a large scale. We need a global response with strong laws mirroring and integrating the human rights project in this process. This brief aims to expose the political negligence of power holders in mitigating the negative effects of climate change on our planet, human rights and humankind’s existence. Climate change is not only linked with the obvious human rights, like the right to a healthy environment or right to life; but climate change has become synonymous for climate emergency, and if this emergency is not mitigated by climate justice it will turn into the end of human rights. It is not rocket science to understand that in a world without a healthy environment, drinkable water and clean oxygen, no right to life or any human right can be truly enjoyed. Keywords climatic changes, human rights, justice, environmental law Citation Aliozi, Z. (2021). Climate Justice and Human Rights, in a World in Climate Emergency, Global Campus of Human Rights. https://doi.org/10.25330/1232 URI http://dx.doi.org/10.25330/1232 https://repository.gchumanrights.org/handle/20.500.11825/2340
Exploring the Legal Basis of a Human Rights Approach to Climate Change
Chinese Journal of International Law, 2011
In this contribution, we consider the relevance of international human rights law to climate change. We review the widely agreed understanding that climate change interferes with human rights. We then examine how a particular State or States may be held responsible for internationally wrongful acts that are caused by contributions to climate change emanating from activities that are under that State's or those States’ jurisdiction. We focus on human beings' actions that the best available science indicates with a high degree of certainty are responsible for climate change and the consequential interference with the human rights of individuals that are caused by the adverse impacts of climate change. We also explore the consequences of international human rights law for States’ responsibility to cooperate to achieve adequate international action on climate change.
Staying human-centric at the intersection of climate change and human rights
2016
The concept of climate justice links human rights with efforts to address climate change to achieve a human-centric approach, safeguarding the rights of the most vulnerable in the process. In their ongoing efforts to implement the recommendations from the newly published IBA report, Achieving Justice and Human Rights in an Era of Climate Disruption, the IBA working groups should safeguard the human-centric approach that inspired the report in the first place, and be mindful that the human dimensions are always well integrated into efforts to address the environment and climate. Recommendations regarding environmental impact assessments, the environment and international trade, and institutional measures and processes to address the environment or climate change should generally integrate the social and human aspects in their work, in order to ensure that any effort to benefit the environment and climate should not come at the expense of people.
Climate Change, Social Justice, and Human Rights
Anthropogenic climate change, and the environmental harms it entails, has become one of the most complex challenges of our time. Climate change is capable of severely undermining a person‟s ability to lead a dignified and good life. Thus, climate change creates conditions of social injustice, which require our urgent attention. This thesis argues for the introduction of a new environmental human right in response to these social injustices. In doing so, I strongly build on Martha Nussbaum‟s capabilities approach, with Breena Holland‟s addition of the „environmental meta-capability.‟ I utilize the environmental meta-capability to derive a human right to a safe and healthy environment, and show why human rights should be part of protecting human capabilities. I argue that the human right to a safe and healthy environment can be justified as it is a crucial element of „capability protection‟ for a person‟s environmental meta-capability, which, in turn, is necessary for establishing minimum conditions of social justice.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
References (13)
- Arnell, Nigel W. (2004) 'Climate Change and Global Water Resources: SRES emissions and socio-economic scenarios', Global Environmental Change 14(1): 31^52.
- Donnelly, Jack (2003) Universal Human Rights inTheory and Practice, Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Exeter Conference (2005) ' Avoiding Dangerous Climate Change', A Scientific Symposium on Stabilisation of Green- house Gases, Exeter, 1^3 February (www.stabilisation2005.com).
- Halweil, Brian (2005) 'The Irony of Climate',WorldWatch Magazine, March/April, 18^23.
- Hare, William (2003) Assessment of Knowledge on Impacts of Climate Change ^Contribution to the specification of Art. 2 of the UNFCCC. Expert study for the German Advisory Council on Global Environmental Change for the Special Report 'Climate Protection Strategies for the 21st Century: Kyoto and Beyond', Berlin: WBGU.
- IPCC (2001) Climate Change 2001. Synthesis report, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- IPCC (2007) Climate Change 2007: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- McMichael, A.J., Campbell-Lendrom, D.H., Corvala Ł n, C.F., Ebi, K.L., Githeko, A.K., Scheraga, J.D.,Woodward, A. (2003) Climate Change and Human Health ^Risks and responses, Geneva: WHO/UNEP/WMO. Development 51(3): Thematic Section Parry, Martin L., Cynthia Rosenzweig, Ana Iglesias, Matthew Livermore and Gunther Fischer (2004) 'Effects of Climate Change on Global Food Production Under SRES Emissions and Socio-Economic Scenarios', Global Environmental Change 14(1): 53^67.
- Patz, Jonathan A., Diarmid Campbell-Lendrum, Tracey Holloway and Jonathan A. Foley (2005) 'Impact of Regional Climate Change on Human Health', Nature 438: 310^7.
- Sachs,Wolfgang,Tilman Santarius (eds.) (2007) 'Fair Future: Resource Conflicts, Security, and Global Justice', London: Zed Books.
- Shah, Mahendra M., Gu º nther Fischer and Harrij van Velthuizen (2006) 'Food,Water, Health, and Infectious Disease. Focus on Global Change', in Interactions Between Global Change and Human Health pp 230^51, Scripta Varia 106, Vatican City: The Pontificial Academy of Sciences.
- Steiner, Henry J. and Philip Alston (eds.) (1996) International Human Rights in Context: Law, politics, morals, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- UNCHR (United Nations Commission on Human Rights) (2005) 'Rapport of the Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food, Jean Ziegler', 24 January. E/CN.4/2005/47.
- Watt-Cloutier, Sheila (2004) 'Climate Change and Human Rights', www.carnegiecouncil.org/viewMedia.php/ prmID/444. Sachs: Climate Change and Human Rights