Urban renewal projects and dynamics of contention in Istanbul:The cases of Fener-Balat-Ayvansaray and Suleymaniye (original) (raw)
Related papers
Resisting urban renewal in Istanbul
Urban Geography, 2014
In this article I examine grassroots responses to state-directed urban renewal in two poor neighborhoods in Istanbul. Through detailed analysis of resident perspectives and urban association tactics, I explore various factors that shape the trajectories of resistance to urban renewal, including solidarity networks, levels of participation and trust in local neighborhood associations, strength of neighborhood identity, extra-local support, and the traditions and channels of negotiation with state actors. I argue that these factors are articulated by a distinct “politics of compensation”—a term that I borrow from Ananya Roy—that is particular to the contemporary neoliberal condition. I find that grassroots mobilizations in Istanbul do not necessarily operate in opposition to neoliberalism; in fact, many struggles remain within the conceptual space of neoliberalism and its cost-benefit calculations. These findings contribute to the emerging literature on struggles against urban renewal in the global south. Keywords: Istanbul; urban renewal; grassroots resistance; neoliberalism; displacement
Urban Regeneration and Social Segregation -The Case of Istanbul - H. Gul-C.Ergun
Despite some of its negative consequences, urbanization is seen as an indicator for development and, thus, has been widely supported in Turkey. In recent years, as the migration to urban areas has slowed down, some more comprehensive steps have been taken to solve urban problems, particularly inadequate housing supply and squatter housing areas. In this respect, urban regeneration is presented as a panacea for the solution of many urban problems and the renewal of cities. Yet, social, cultural and historical aspects of city life are often ignored. Since 2005, many urban regeneration projects have been carried out one after another in many cities in Turkey. This process seems to have exclusive and disintegrative consequences as the displacement of the poor and marginal groups in large cities has shown. After a conceptual and theoretical introduction, this paper critically reviews recent urban regeneration projects and the experience and struggle of some urban residents in Turkey, particularly in the studied neighborhoods in İstanbul. Besides, the dynamics of segregation and exclusion involved in the process of urban regeneration project implementation in the studied communities are analyzed.
An urban social movement challenging urban regeneration: The case of Sulukule, Istanbul
Urban regeneration projects have become a focus of attention in Istanbul due to tourism promotion, particularly great expectations from the European Capital of Culture 2010 Event. Sulukule, a Romani neighborhood on the historical peninsula of Istanbul, was designated as an urban redevelopment zone. The Sulukule Urban Regeneration Project is one of the recent efforts to present “a better urban environment” to foreign visitors and investors. The project has accelerated the struggle for land, causing dispossessions, evictions and demolitions. Locals’ needs and rights are denied. Consequently, the citizens in Sulukule started to oppose regeneration and formed an urban social movement. This paper attempts to analyze the urban social movement in Sulukule, the Sulukule Platform, which emerged as an urban coalition challenging tourism-led regeneration.► Urban regeneration in Sulukule, Istanbul caused demolitions and evictions. ► Citizens formed an urban coalition, the Sulukule Platform, to defend their rights. ► The Sulukule Platform failed in physical preservation of the neighborhood. ► Ambiguous property rights, lack of wide support, strong opposition and fragmentation among locals contributed to this failure. ► The Sulukule Platform continues to struggle for return of Romani dwellers to Sulukule.
Shaping the City: Three Urban Events in Istanbul
2018
Baska hadiselerin ya da kazalarin kacinilmaz ya da belirlenmis sonucu olmayan, tumuyle olumsal ya da beklenmedik bir sekilde ortaya cikan ancak guncel kenti donusturen ve gelecegini sekillendirmede guc ve etki uygulayabilen kentsel olaylar hakkinda ne dusunmeliyiz? Kentin morfolojisi ve yapili cevresi yani sira kent sakinlerinin mekan algisinda kirilmaya ve yeni bir konfigurasyona sebep olan muhim eylemleri ve olaylari nasil tespit edebilir ve aciklayabiliriz? Bu makale kentin modern doneminde belirleyici olan, kentin morfolojisini, kentte yasayanlarin deneyimlerini ve kentin etnik-dini kompozisyonunu karsilikli olarak kuran uc olayi tariflemekte ve incelemektedir. Makalenin temel argumani, her ne kadar yaratici dinamikleri zorunlu olarak tutarli bir kentsel sistem uretmek uzere islemiyor olsa da, kentsel olaylarin bir araya gelerek ya da ic ice gecerek cagdas/guncel kenti parcalayarak-yeniden birlestirerek yapilandirdiklaridir.
Current Urban Discourse, Urban Transformation and Gentrification in Istanbul
"In the mid-2000s, unprecedented economic growth provided a catalyst for Istanbul's transformation. Tolga İslam outlines the background to large-scale urban development and renewal projects that have been undertaken by local authorities throughout the city. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Keywords: Zaha Hadid Architects, Masterplan for Kartal, Istanbul, 2006;Tabanlıoğlu Architects, Galataport project, Istanbul, 2001;continuous economic growth;investments in the transportation infrastructure;undersea tunnel;new shopping malls;gated housing communities;new housing on state-owned land;Mass Housing Administration (TOKİ);recreational centre in Küçükçekmece;Massimilliano Fuksas, Kisho Kurakawa;Ken Yeang;Kengo Kuma;MVRDV;strategy to promote Istanbul;Haydarpaflaport;mixed-use areas;add value to the city;Başibüyük;Justice and Development Party (Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi -AKP);‘Law on the Protection of Deteriorated Historic and Cultural Heritage through Renewal and Re-use’;Tarlabaşı and Sulukule;high crime rates;public-private ownership"
Colliding Urban Transformation Process: The Case of Historical Peninsula, Istanbul
International Journal of Architectural Research: ArchNet-IJAR
Over the last three decades, the disruptive quality of urban and social restructuring processes in Turkey has been intensified by the government’s decision to embrace the concept of urban transformation as a tool to boost the Turkish economy and development. In this respect, many cities have experienced a rapid urban transformation, practicing more of a top to down approach in implementing an urban planning and design, and at the same time undervaluing the potential of a participatory process for a common future and for the improvement of the quality of social and urban life. The article examines the process of “social and spatial restructuring” for the old-city housings of the city of Istanbul, as part of a larger urban transformation phenomenon. The research comparatively analyses three different urban transformation projects from the city of Istanbul's historically valued Golden Horn area and focuses on missions, actors and roles of the projects in terms of the social and spa...
Heritage and Development, 2023
Dark streets descend into a floodplain as poor houses line both sides… It is possible to find shrimp sellers, bakers, vinegar makers, carpenter's apprentices, waiters, barbers, accordionists, kitara makers, bar singers, revue dancers, and tailor's apprentices all along on both sides of the street from all religions and sects, Turkish, Russian, Armenian,
Urban Pulse(RE) Making Space for Globalization in Istanbul
Urban Geography, 2008
This paper provides critical reflections on the urban transformation campaign launched by the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality (IMM) as part and parcel of its ambitions to upgrade Istanbul to “world city” status. I focus on two main aspects of “urban transformation” in Istanbul: prestige mega-projects and (re)development of informal housing areas, with particular emphasis on the latter. I examine how poor residents’ livelihoods are put at stake in spite of the IMM’s claim that “urban transformation” is ultimately beneficial for all citizens. I conclude with the unique policy challenges that the local governments face in developing participatory models for urban renewal and regeneration in Istanbul. [Key words: urban transformation, urban renewal, squatter redevelopment, gecekondus, Istanbul.]