Engagement and Performance in Physics: The Role of Class Instructional Strategies, and Student’s Personal and Situational Interest // Implicación y rendimiento en Física: el papel de las estrategias docentes en el aula, y el interés personal y situacio (original) (raw)
Related papers
Students' engagement in learning physics: A subject-specific approach
2017
Most of the existing conceptualizations of students’ engagement explore the role of general engagement. However, if we are interested in understanding the process of learning specific school subjects, this approach is not suitable. The aim of the study was to explore the components of students’ engagement in learning physics and to examine the differences in engagement in physics in respect of several variables: gender, grade, the expected grade in the subject at the end of the school year and the intention to choose physics as an elective subject in the national secondary general education final examination (The Croatian State Matura). The participants were 803 students from the second, third and fourth grade in five general program grammar schools in Croatia. Confirmatory factor analyses confirmed the existence of three distinct, but related components of students' engagement in physics: cognitive, behavioral and emotional engagement, which all show satisfying to high reliabil...
Research in Science Education, 2023
Research indicates that students' interest in science decreases during their school years. To counteract this, a quasi-experimental instructional intervention was designed in which we addressed students' leisure interests to foster their (situational) interest in physics. Students in the intervention group got the opportunity to choose topics matching their leisure interests (e.g. sports, music) and were encouraged to reflect on and discuss the application of principles of semiconductor physics to those topics throughout the intervention with a duration over 11 lessons. The intervention group consisted of 60 students from German high-track schools; another 55 students comprised the control group. The results of a MANCOVA analysis indicate that the instructional intervention succeeded in triggering students' catch and hold component of situational interest during all four phases of the lesson series. Furthermore, behavioural disengagement developed more positively for students in the intervention group, while no significant effects were found for their behavioural engagement, their interest in physics-related activities in leisure or their general interest in physics classes in school. The results suggest that addressing students' leisure interests in physics classes can promote their situational interest and reduce their behavioural disengagement in physics.
In Search of Student Engagement in High School Physics Through Contextual Teaching M.Ed. Thesis 2012
This action research study compared student intellectual engagement between two different instructional delivery methods. The first instructional method was a non-contextual teaching approach using a textbook to teach the work outcomes for the S4 physics mechanics unit. The second instructional method was a contextual teaching approach where students built an electric guitar pickup and a simple electric guitar in order to provide a context for the teaching of the electromagnetism outcomes for the S4 physics electricity unit. To measure the intellectual engagement of students, data was collected from personal student journals and from questions generated by students following different instructional activities. The student generated questions were categorized and ranked to judge the degree of student intellectual engagement and depth of thought using a framework where numerical values were assigned to the questions. Each question was categorized as peripheral, factual, conceptual, or philosophical where the peripheral questions had the lowest intellectual ranking and the philosophical questions had the highest intellectual ranking. Data was also collected from cumulative unit tests, short exit slips and a personal teacher journal. The research revealed that students were more intellectually engaged and exhibited much more positive attitudes during the contextual lessons. The questions generated by students during the contextual lessons were of the higher order factual and conceptual types while the questions generated during the non-contextual lessons were predominantly of the lowest order peripheral type. By using the electric guitar and electric guitar pickup as a context, this action research study demonstrated that these contextual activities intellectually engaged students and helped to facilitate their deeper understanding of electromagnetism.
In Search of Student Engagement in High School Physics Through Contextual Teaching
IHPST Conference Procedings, 2013
This action research study compared student intellectual engagement between two different instructional delivery methods. The first instructional method was a non-contextual teaching approach using a textbook approach to teach the work-energy concepts. The second instructional method was a contextual teaching approach where students built an electric guitar pickup and a simple electric guitar in order to provide a context for the teaching of the electromagnetism. To measure the intellectual engagement of students, data was collected from personal student journals and from questions generated by students following different instructional activities. The student generated questions were categorized and ranked to judge the degree of student intellectual engagement and depth of thought using a framework where numerical values were assigned to the questions. Each question was categorized as peripheral, factual, conceptual, or philosophical where the peripheral questions had the lowest intellectual ranking and the philosophical questions had the highest intellectual ranking. Data was also collected from student journals. The research revealed that students were more intellectually engaged and exhibited much more positive attitudes during the contextual lessons. The questions generated by students during the contextual lessons were of the higher order types while the questions generated during the non-contextual lessons were predominantly of the lowest order peripheral type.
The Influence of Students' Expectations on Their Interests in Physics Lessons
Online Submission, 2006
The purpose of this paper is to present results of the study conducted to explore students' expectations related to development of student interest in physics and physics lesson. The concept of interest is the affective description of this connection between person and objects. Even though interest is assumed to be important for its role in learning concepts, studies are not sufficient to explore students' expectations that play important role for sustaining interest. Person-Object Approach to Interest, as a theoretical approach underlying Self Determination Theory, explains interest as a relatively enduring relationship between a person and objects in his or her daily-life experiences. For the purpose of the study tenth grade students were interviewed. The interview questions were semi structured and aimed to elucidate the categories that explain the relationship between students and interest objects from daily life related to physics lesson. Results support that students' basic needs need to be fulfilled, and feeling and value related expectations should be met to stimulate students' interest. Findings of this study suggest reconsidering students' expectations from a physics lesson for their interest in physics lesson.
Personality and engagement in learning physics: the mediating effect of achievement goals
2017
To achieve expected learning outcomes, students must be actively engaged in the learning process. Studies have shown that engagement consists of three components: behavioral, cognitive, and emotional (Fredrics, Blumenfeld, & Paris, 2004). Students' engagement in learning depends on their relation to the subject of teaching and the quality of the educational process, but in this study, we have focused on personal determinants of engagement. In particular, we were interested in the extent to which individual differences in the personal characteristics of students and their motivational orientations reflect the level of their engagement in learning physics. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to explore the relationship of perfectionism and reinforcement sensitivity to different components of students' engagement in learning physics, and to examine whether achievement goals have a mediational role in this relationship. The participants were 224 students in Grades 7–8 (50.5...
International Journal of Science Education, 2018
Modeling Instruction (MI), an active-learning introductory physics curriculum, has been shown to improve student academic success. Peer-to-peer interactions play a salient role in the MI classroom. Their impact on student interest and self-efficacy-preeminent constructs of various career theories-has not been thoroughly explored. Our examination of three undergraduate MI courses (N = 221) revealed a decrease in students' physics self-efficacy, physics interest, and general science interest. We found a positive link from physics interest to self-efficacy, and a negative relationship between science interest and self-efficacy. We tested structural equation models confirming that student interactions make positive contributions to selfefficacy. This study frames students' classroom interactions within broader career theory frameworks and suggests nuanced considerations regarding interest and self-efficacy constructs in the context of undergraduate active-learning science courses.
Sabiedrība, integrācija, izglītība, 2022
The article deals with the eighth-grade school students' motivation for learning physics. The spectrum of factors influencing the school students' motivation for learning physics is very wide. This study addresses the phenomenon of school students' motivation for learning physics in the light of an educational factor. We analyze the role of instructional clarity in physics lessons on school students' motivation for learning physics based on TIMSS 2019 data set of Lithuania and Finland. To disclose the influence of instructional clarity in physics lessons on school students' motivation for learning physics confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and structural equation modelling (SEM) was used. The results of our research reveal that instructional clarity in physics lessons is directly and positively associated with school students' motivation for learning physics. SEM results disclosed not only significance but magnitudes of associations between instructional clarity in physics lessons and school students' motivation for learning physics as well.