The New Challenges vs. Old Formulas: What Would Make the European Union a Greater Global Player? (original) (raw)
Related papers
The European Union’s global strategy: Complementarity and specialization
Portuguese Journal of Social Science
As a grand strategy, European Union Global Strategy (EUGS) is a roadmap to convert the European Union (EU) in a key strategic actor. The evidence of some conceptual vulnerabilities, particularly the EU lack of classical means and strategic autonomy, limits its implementation. Thus, this article aims to find some relevant actions that the EU needs to put in place to enhance her global image as a credible and specialized actor where the power of her strategic partners, as NATO and United Sates, need to be complemented. To that effect, first, the EU must demonstrate leadership and mobilize the support of member states to carry out its strategy. Second, it must leverage its strategic autonomy by intervening in crises and conflicts where the military means are not the most important. Third, it must focus on preventing or solving the problems in the EU’s neighbourhood as it will suffer direct repercussions if it fails to do so. Implementing the EUGS will require a generic but encompassing...
Moldavian Journal of International Law and International Relations, 2017
Let’s imagine the international security environment as a chess table with various pieces making different moves and the way they move on the board, gives them different values in the game. The main question is whether the European Union is the most valuable piece, the queen or the weakest one, the pawn, namely we wish to disclose whether the EU is „going global” being able to spread its norms and extend its power in various parts of the world, detaining strategic autonomy in security affairs. This „unidentified political object” (EU), as named by Jacques Delors in its close neighbourhood has an enormous political and economic influence, however, in the global arena, where actors play by different rules the Union has limited power. The dilemma is if in this competitive international milieu the Union is able to expand its regional polity being more than just a regional security provider, becoming a global security maker. As stated by Javier Solana, the period of peace and stability in Europe at the end of the twentieth and the beginning of this century, is largely due to the existence of the European Union. This Union has not only generated a high level of economic development on the old continent, but also a new approach to security, based on the concept of peacemaking, through peaceful settlement of disputes and via international multilateral cooperation.
The EU´s Future Role on the Global Stage
What role will the EU play on the global stage? The struggle of some of its members in the current economic crisis, its apparent inability to punch its political weight in international negotiations (e.g. the climate summit in Warsaw in 2013) or play a dominant part in international crisis management (the Arab Spring, Syria) cast doubt on the capabilities of the EU as a global player. In order to regain its strength, the EU has to deal with pressing economic and political questions. It has to provide a credible and feasible road map for economic recovery and social cohesion. At the same time, it has to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of European governance without risking its legitimacy. To pre- serve its actor capacity, the EU must make sure that the (presently unequally distributed) growth potential stemming from research and development serves the economic recovery of the union as a whole. At the same time, successful efforts to make European governance more efficient must be accompanied by additional safeguard measure to ensure its legitimacy.
The (Small) State of the Union: Assessing the EU’s Ability to Implement Its Global Strategy
New Perspectives Interdisciplinary Journal of Central & East European Politics and International Relations, 2019
The European Global Strategy (EUGS) is a significant document that came out at a critical time. Decision makers and scholars need to identify and assess the challenges the EU is facing in its effort to pursue its new Strategy. This paper addresses the lack of a tool for identifying those challenges and assessing the EU’s ability to respond to them by introducing a new analytical framework based on the conceptualization of the EU as a small power in the international system, and the literature about the international relations of small states. The framework combines the factors that impact upon a small state’s behaviour and performance in the international system and consists of the following elements: a) the EU’s relations with the great powers in the system, b) developments in the EU’s neighbourhood, c) the EU’s politics, and d) the EU’s reputation. After discussing each one of them, the paper contributes a comprehensive assessment of the EU’s ability to implement its Strategy. It concludes that in order to implement its Strategy, the EU should respond to specific challenges. Therefore, the framework this paper introduces can improve our understand- ing of both the EUGS and the Union’s strengths and weaknesses, shed some light on what measures should be taken for the Union to respond to challenges that lie ahead and be used as a yardstick to assess the Union’s progress. Moreover, the framework can be applied to other areas of the EU’s external action and contribute to both drafting better informed strategic documents and supporting their implementation.
European Union as a global actor
2014
There has been considerable debate surrounding the nature of the European Union's international capacity. Early conceptions of the Union as a civilian or non-military actordominated early thinking, characterising the Union as a new kind of international actor. 1. Others 2 , meanwhile argued that this simply sought to make a virtue of weakness and that if the Union were ever to be taken seriously, then it would have to develop a full-spectrum military capacity. That debate, in a somewhat different form, continues today. The 'civilian power' thesis 3 has evolved to one in which the Union continues to be posited as a new kind of international actor, but now as one which is somehow uniquely capable or uniquely configured as effective exporter of norms and values in the international system 4. Others insist that only as the Union develops its nascent military capacity can it begin to shoulder real international responsibilities. 5 Within this second debate exist more polemical positions on the adverse, or other, consequences of the 'militarization' of the Union's international profile and transatlantic arguments surrounding a division of labour between the US and EU in delivering 'hard' and 'soft' security capacity. This paper will outline and critically engage these debates. It will conclude that while the Union remains a distinctive international actor, the trajectory of its development may suggest the pursuit of an 'enlightened power' model.
Defining the Role of the EU as a Global Actor: Challenges and Perspectives
Political Thought, 2021
The aim of this paper is to study the perspectives for the development of the EU’s global role in the current environment, taking into account the aspirations for strategically increased influence on international trends. The main argument of the research is that the EU should use the available instruments to strengthen its role, while working to strengthen its position as a strategic autonomous actor, i.e. to combine the instruments of soft and hard power. Finally, in order to achieve such a “mission”, the EU should recognize the Western Balkans as its strategic ally, i.e. a region in which it can, with its actions, make the most significant change.
2019
This study seeks to analyse the European Union’s diplomatic goals in its relations with other international organisations, it also seeks to analyse the major obstacles the European Union faces in international organisations. The European Union is involved in various aspects of international relations and manages to influence international relations. However, the European Union faces a lot of challenges in international relations, mostly as a result of it being an international organisation, it is unable to join or have full member rights in certain international organisations. The other major challenge the European Union face are due to European member states not speaking with one voice. In order for the EU to be an effective international actor, it needs to cooperate and speak with one voice. If each EU member continues to put its national needs first and EU collective needs second, the EU will continue to face challenges in achieving its goal of becoming a global actor.