Balancing Potential and Risk: The Living Lab Approach in Mobile Participation Research (original) (raw)
Related papers
Potentials and challenges of a living lab approach in research on mobile participation
This paper discusses potentials and challenges of living lab approach in studying pervasive mobile participation, including reporting experiences of a living lab experiment currently conducted in Turku, Finland. It shows that the living lab approach offers both new opportunities and challenges when implemented in the urban governance context. In general, living labs hold great potential for researching participatory processes enabled by state-of-the-art technology in real world contexts. However, conducting experiments in those real life contexts presents a number of inherent difficulties that makes the potential essentially vulnerable, such as usability issues and political ambivalence on change.
Advances in Electronic Government, Digital Divide, and Regional Development
Smartphones and tablet computers are becoming essential in everyday life, connecting us in a powerful network through mobile web services. They open new channels of communication between citizens, institutions and administrations, offer greater access to public information, and facilitate increased participation. These new forms of collaborative social interaction revolutionize our information and knowledge society. The chapter examines the new opportunities opened up by mobile phones for mParticipation in the context of urban planning processes. After beginning with a theoretical overview about technical developments, eParticipation and the changes in communication in a networked society, it defines the concept of mParticipation. This is followed by an examination of six real-world projects. These examples are then used for the identification of best practices and for the analysis of the usefulness and effectiveness of these new participatory tools. In addition, the chapter discuss...
Motivations to use a mobile participation application
This paper reports results on presumably the first city-wide mobile participation trial (Living Lab) examining citizen participation in urban planning, conducted in Turku, Finland, in 2015. The questions examined are the socioeconomic characteristics of the application users, as well as their motivations to participate. The inclusion of online participation has been discussed widely in literature on e-participation and the digital divide, arguing for a great influence of socioeconomic factors, interest in the topic, and users' online skills. The results reveal that this application, too, was used predominantly by young adults and middle-aged, highly educated, and technology savvy citizens, who were already interested in urban planning. Their use of the application was motivated primarily by the opportunity to bring their own ideas and issues to the city authorities' attention, rather than participating in missions given by the municipality or discussing planning issues with fellow citizens, indicating a rather individualistic usage interest. The location-based features and ease of use of a mobile application were valued highly. Those who idled reported predominantly technical challenges with the app.
Created by everybody': Engaging participation with mobile interfaces
Cities define themselves through the regions that surround them. Thus, the specific characteristics of "the city" can change dramatically even within one nation. Nevertheless, we can identify key criteria for thriving cities. Healthy cities have governments that fulfill at least citizens' physical needs; great cities fulfill their emotional and psychological needs as well. With responsiveness to citizens' needs as a gauge, we can focus on improving struggling cities, and perhaps even make them great. With a study of Chicago 'edge cities' as a starting point, we argue for the integration of camera phones and more conventional web-based interfaces. By linking citizens with each other and with municipal planners, such a strategy has the potential to reach across the 'digital divide,' mediate between conflicting interests and priorities, and introduce higher standards for accountability in government.
Virtual Environments as Enablers of Civic Awareness and Engagement
International Journal of Urban Planning and Smart Cities, 2020
The wide availability of accurate sensors currently hosted by smartphones are enabling new participative urban management opportunities. Mobile crowdsensing (MCS) allows people to actively participate in any aspect of urban planning, by collecting and sharing data, reporting issues to public administrations, proposing solutions to urban planners, and delivering information of potential social interest to their community. Although collected data can be very helpful to enhance the quality of life of citizens, mobile users are still reluctant to use their devices to take advantages of the opportunities offered by the digitized society, mainly due to privacy issues. From August to December 2018, the city of Florianópolis, capital of Santa Catarina, in southern Brazil, was used as a living lab environment for an MCS application called ParticipACT Brazil, a socio/technical-aware crowdsensing platform. While the current literature focuses on MCS from a purely technical point of view, this ...