Becoming Radically Undone: Discourses of Identity and Diversity in the Introductory Gender and Women’s Studies Classroom (original) (raw)
Related papers
Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal 31.2, 2012
Purpose -The paper aims to examine the potential feminist politics of teaching: is there a clear connection between feminism and teaching, and is there a particular feminist way of teaching? Through notions of engaged political pedagogy (as developed by bell hooks Jacques Rancière), it proposes an intersectional and dissensual approach to teaching, as a primary way of practising feminist politics within academia. Design/methodology/approach -The paper sets out to explore the possibility of a feminist pedagogy of teaching. Drawing on works by social and feminists theorists as well as by radical pedagogues, it negotiates these various standpoints, finding similarities and differences, in order to formulate ways in which we can more fruitfully conceive of teaching as politics. Findings -The paper proposes that the classroom proves one of the most radical spaces for possibility within academia. Through an engaged, dissensual pedagogy, in which both students and teachers work together in mutual recognition of each other's knowledge, the feminist teacher can enthuse political change both within and outside of the classroom. Originality/value -Teaching is often viewed as a less important part of academic work. This paper, in contrast, proposes the classroom as one of the spaces where we as feminist academics can have the most impact. Providing a theoretical methodology of a potential feminist teaching pedagogy, this paper adds a well-needed exploration of the relation between teaching and feminism, and a defence of teaching as politics.
Teaching Feminism: Between Marginalisation and Feminist Persistence
Šolsko polje, 2020
The aim of this article is to gain insights into how feminist principles, content and practices persist in higher education in times of neoliberal ideology, post-feminism and the intensification of extreme-right wing politics. The main issue the article seeks to address is the state of gender-related and feminist topics in higher education. Their state should be addressed at the intersections of: 1) social context; 2) institutional settings (formalised and officialised gender-related curricula); and 3) intra-institutional practices, such as backlashes to and sanctions against feminist practices. In order to achieve this, we start by briefly sketching the beginnings of women’s studies worldwide, and the ambivalences of institutionalising feminist knowledge. We proceed by focusing our discussion on the contemporary social situation, significantly marked by right-wing politics and neoliberal ideology, aiming to constitute feminism as irrelevant on the grounds of an individualised ‘brav...
Changing perceptions about feminists and (still not) claiming a feminist identity
Gender and Education, 2016
We examine student perceptions about feminists and feminism, and the willingness to claim a feminist identity and engage in collective activism, as stated at the beginning and end of a Women's Studies course. Course participation simultaneously fostered more positive views towards feminists and feminism and entrenched the unwillingness to claim a feminist identity and engage in activism. These contradictory outcomes stemmed from the critical capacity to recognise that structural inequality is reproduced through disciplinary relationships. Thus, unwillingness was entangled with feelings of fear and vulnerability in relation to the national context whereby neoliberalism guides the governance of the self, and where gender equality has presumed to be achieved. The article highlights that developing the willingness to identity and act is intimately shaped and constrained by the socio-political context and personal relationships. We consider the implications of this insight in relation to pedagogical assumptions about developing feminist knowledge in the classroom.
As it currently stands, little academic attention has been paid to the systematic devaluation of femininity or femmephobia. By adopting “femme” as a critical analytic, this paper dislocates femininity from its ascribed Otherness and demonstrates how empowered femininities have been overlooked within gender studies. Femme, as the failure or refusal to approximate the patriarchal norms of femininity, serves as the conceptual anchor of this study and is used to examine how femmephobic sentiments are perpetuated within Contemporary Western Feminist (CWF) theory. This perpetuation is propped up by the thematic marginaliza- tion of empowered femininities from the texts chosen for gender studies courses, revealing a normative feminist body constructed through the privileging of identities that maintains femininity as white, middle-class, normatively bodied, and without agency. The excavation of an empowered feminine subject from the margins reveals the foothold of normative whiteness embedded within feminist pedagogies. Using a thematic analysis of how femininity is taken-up within textbooks used in gender studies courses, the current paper demonstrates how intersections of femininity have yet to be addressed within dominant Feminist theories. The femme—as a queer potentiality—o ers a way of (re)thinking through the limitations of CWF theory and the paradoxical preoccupations with the absented femme.
Teaching in Higher Education, 2017
At present there is a small, albeit growing, body of literature on pedagogical strategies and reflections which addresses the ways educators attempt to challenge the effects of neoliberalism on higher education. In this article, we reflect upon our pedagogical practices in higher education in this moment of neoliberal transformation wherein, as Sirma Bilge notes, intersectionality is being 'undone' in academic feminism. As graduate students teaching in Toronto, Canada, we describe how our commitment to social justice pedagogy works against this 'undoing' of intersectionality by embracing vulnerability, discomfort and the possibility of conflict in classrooms that do not simply accommodate, celebrate or include difference. Given that neoliberal renderings of diversity obscure and reinforce unequal relations of power, we demonstrate how we attend to these power relations, particularly racism which is salient to our teaching context, by employing intersectionality as a pedagogical practice and a political intervention to advance social justice.
Bridging the Divide: Connecting Feminist Histories and Activism in the Classroom
Radical History Review, 2008
Learning about the historical traditions of social change movements is critical for today's students. Students need social justice role models to understand what has changed as a result of people's organized and individual efforts over time. Students need to learn from the successes and challenges of past movements in order to know that change is not only possible but that they, too, can be change agents. When exposed to the depth and breadth of activist histories -histories of which they usually have little to no knowledge of -students start to think more critically about their own education. They begin to consider what narratives they have been taught and what/who have been left out.
From Critical Feminist Theory to Critical Feminist Revolutionary Pedagogy
Advances in applied sociology, 2024
Since 1996, Stuart Hall has written that no intellectual who truly wants to fulfill this role and no university that wants to face the 21st century with pride in its adequacy can afford to ignore the racial and ethnic problems that plague our world (Hall, 1996: p. 343). Indeed, we may claim that gender issues are just as critical to the adequacy of educational institutions and educators. The present work is based on the recognition of the difficulties that educators face in translating social justice-based policy into an emancipatory pedagogy in the classroom when the gender perspective is absent. Indeed, many of the difficulties that educators face today are due to the absence of a critical feminist reading of the world, a point that has been recently highlighted in the relevant literature (Gale de Saxe, 2016). In this work, I propose a Critical Feminist Revolutionary Pedagogy based on the discussions about critical revolutionary pedagogy and resistance practices thus offering educators the opportunity to reflect on how education is a form of cultural politics and how practices such as participation in reflective and critical discussions as well as reflection can offer new ways of challenging the "traditional" nature of school education as well as different sources of empowerment.