Picking One's Battles: NNES Doctoral Students' Imagined Communities and Selections of Investment (original) (raw)
Related papers
Adopting a qualitative case study methodology, the present study illuminates how two multilingual students enrolled in a U.S. community college ESL class negotiated the sociocultural norms valued in their multiple communities to make investment in learning English in college. Drawing on Gee's theory of Discourse and identity (1996) and Norton's theory of investment (2000), the study found that each student's investment in learning the language practices of the classroom was shaped by the diverse Discourses in which they participated across time and space. Despite confronting structural constraints, the focal students were able to mobilize their multiple Discourses to negotiate the existing sociocultural norms and invest in identities that have the potential to transform their lives. These findings suggest that multilingual students' learning at the college is shaped by their socio-cultural milieu and future aspirations. Thus, language educators should recognize their multiple identities as well as their agency, and broaden the curriculum goals to accommodate their diverse linguistic and educational needs.
2016
The social identity construction of international students studying in the United States is important to the field of second language learning and the study of identity. A Social Identity and Communities of Practice (CoP) framework were used to understand how participation in a CoP informed the identity of non-native speaking university international students studying in the U.S. The focus of this study was to investigate how participation in a CoP informed the identity of non-native speaking international university students studying in the U.S. I proposed that these frameworks provided a foundation for understanding how participation in a CoP for non-native English-speaking university students informed their international student identity. Furthermore, this study showed how participation in a CoP contributed to the participants’ sense of belonging. Data collected for this study included audio recordings of the group and individual interviews, notes from the observation of the CoP,...
Investment and imagined communities: A narrative analysis of the identity construction by student-teachers of English Investimento e comunidades imaginadas: uma análise narrativa da construção da identidade de alunos-professores de inglês AB STRACT – The objective of this article is to discuss an exploratory study about the identity construction of eight student-teachers of English as learners of English as an additional language in the region of Vale do Açu, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil using some of the concepts developed by Bonny Norton, that is, investigating the types of investments made and the imagined communities aspired to by those student-teachers. For the exploratory study, a narrative perspective was adopted as identities are socio-cultural narratives constructed in time. The analyses showed that construction of the identities of the student-teachers investigated revolves around two types of investment: those which lead to learn and use the language, and those which lead to learn the English language to teach it. The results have shown that in the analyzed group of student-teachers, the learner-as-user and learner-as-teacher identities seem to confl ate and, in most cases, the learner-as-teacher identity seems to override the learner-as-user identity. Also, since many of the studies carried out on learner identity using Bonny Norton's theoretical approach had immigrants in contexts where English is used by the community they are living in, this work is expected to contribute to Norton's approach as the participants of this study are learning English as an additional language in contexts where the community members do not use English and English is mainly learnt in formal environments. RESUMO – O objetivo deste artigo é discutir um estudo exploratório sobre a construção identitária de oito alunos-professores como aprendizes de Inglês como língua adicional da região do Vale do Açu, Rio Grande do Norte, utilizando os conceitos desenvolvidos por Bonny Norton, isto é, os tipos de investimentos realizados e as comunidades imaginadas pelos participantes do estudo. Também, uma abordagem narrativa de pesquisa foi adotada, já que as identidades são narrativas socioculturais progressivamente construídas. A análise mostrou que a construção da identidade dos alunos-professores investigados gira em torno a dois tipos de investimentos: aqueles que os levam a aprender a língua para usá-la e aqueles que os levam a aprender a língua para ensiná-la. Os resultados mostram que no grupo de alunos analisados, a identidade do aprendiz como usuário da língua e a identidade do aprendiz de professor parecem se misturar, e em muitos casos, a segunda se sobrepõe a primeira. Também, como a grande maioria dos estudos realizados acerca da identidade de aprendizes na perspectiva desenvolvida por Norton foram realizadas com imigrantes em contexto de segunda língua, este trabalho pode contribuir com a área, já que seus participantes são alunos, aprendendo inglês como língua adicional no Brasil. Palavras-chave: aprendizes de inglês, identidade, investimentos, co-munidades imaginadas.
Learning Investment as a Means of Shaping Learner Identity in Higher Education
KOTESOL Journal, 2021
Despite the growing number of research studies on identity and investment in EFL countries, there seems to be insufficient research on the investment and identity in Asian contexts, and research is extremely sparse in the Indonesian context. To fill this void, this study aims to investigate how an Indonesian learner's investment in English shaped her identity as an English language learner. This study was carried out through an in-depth interview both offline and online. Additionally, a narrative analysis was used to examine the Indonesian learner's investment and identity in learning English with regard to her complex real-life experiences. The data were analyzed by referring to learner identity and learner investment as frameworks for the case study. The outcomes of the study found that the learner's professional and well-educated parents supported her investment in terms of time, support, and money for learning English, and as a consequence, the learner was motivated and felt a connection to the language, which gradually shaped her identity across diverse communities as an English language learner. These findings have the pedagogical implication that educational practitioners need to consider not only curricular activities but also extra-curricular activities to facilitate effective learning while fostering investment. Since in many Asia contexts there is a financial component to English language education instruction beyond regular schooling, the parents' view of English language education plays a critical role. This directly impacts a learner's perception of English, their English instruction, and their investment in the language. This study suggests implications for the Southeast Asian and Asian classrooms, considering factors outside the classroom.