Sinai: Egypt’s Linchpin, Gaza’s Lifeline, Israel’s Nightmare (original) (raw)

The Journal of North African Studies, 2016

Abstract

lence. The example of ‘Abd al-Qādir allows Cherif to argue for the validity of a unique blend of Islamic thought and universal humanism. It is difficult not to share Cherif’s hopes for a future of dialogue and mutual respect and his book certainly presents an inspiring example in the life of ‘Abd al-Qādir. That said, the book suffers from repetition, including the retelling of the same story or quotation in multiple chapters. In addition, Cherif presents ‘Abd al-Qādir as entirely infallible. The narrative of the Emir’s life would benefit from some critical analysis of his actions, without risk of diminishing his exemplary life story. Finally, it must be said that the book contains some very grand claims, including designating ‘Abd al-Qādir as the founder of both the modern concept of human rights and the Algerian state. The validity of these claims is assumed rather than demonstrated. Of course, the book is not a work of history and the author does not pretend to be anything less than overtly political in making these claims. Despite these issues, the book offers an inspiring narrative of respect and humanity. Through the story of the life of the Emir ‘Abd al-Qādir, Cherif makes a powerful case for the need for interfaith and intercultural dialogue in the present.

Georgios Rigas hasn't uploaded this paper.

Let Georgios know you want this paper to be uploaded.

Ask for this paper to be uploaded.