Robert A. Kenedy, Uzi Rebhun, and Carl S. Ehrlich (eds.), Israel and the Diaspora: Jewish Connectivity in a Changing World (Springer Nature, 2022) proofs front matter (original) (raw)
Related papers
Reconsidering Israel-Diaspora Relations
2014
This paper intends to follow the state of mind of Jewish intellectuals in the USA regarding Israel in the last 20 years, among three groups of intellectuals, who were connected to two Journals and a newspaper since 1990: Encounter, Tikkun, and Forward. Their discourse was concentrated in the Jewish-Arab national struggle. Each group represented a unique political and spiritual ethnic approach towards Israel's policy vital for its existence as a Jewish State. The Encounter recommended power policy; Tikkun preached messianic liberalism; and Forward advised a realistic political approach. All three approaches express the involvement of the intellectuals in the political issue without being professional politicians. Jonathan D. Sarna: From Worldwide People to First-World People: Consolidating Jewry Jews imagine that we are an "am olam," a global people spread "from one end of the world even unto the other." Since World War II, however, the Jewish world has been consolidating at an unprecedented rate. More than 80 percent of world Jewry lives in just two countries: the United States and Israel. Half of all Jews live in just five metropolitan areas: Tel Aviv, New York, Los Angeles, Haifa and Jerusalem. More than 93 percent of Jews live in countries of the First World, meaning countries with the most advanced economies, the highest standards of living, the most advanced technologies and the greatest influence on world affairs. Most of the countries outside of the First World, by contrast, are totally barren of Jews or house remnant communities that are far too small to be viable. In short, where once Judaism was a "world religion," today, increasingly, it is a "First-World religion". This paper will examine the consolidation of world Jewry and its implications. Dina Porat: The impact of anti-Semitism and the Holocaust on Israeli and Jewish identity This is a vast issue, long debated and researched. Therefore, given the time and framework limit, let us present four viewpoints, and try to illustrate them by using a number of examples: First, the impact of anti-Semitism on Jewish identity: a letter from Albert Einstein to Haim Weizmann, deploring the undermining impact of anti-Semitism on the inner most feeling of the modern Jew, vis-à-vis the Orthodox attitude that denounces such an impact all in all: anti-Semitism, and the Holocaust, are part of Jewish history, that the believer can afford to ignore on account of a solid well-built identity. Second, the impact of the Holocaust on the tension between Jewish and Israeli identities: Recently, author Aharon Apelfeld advocated the understanding of the Holocaust as characterized by love, especially within the Jewish family, that made it possible to overcome the disaster, while author A. B. Yehoshua's perception of the Holocaust is one of terrible failure. Hence, Apelfeld fosters Jewish identity, while Yehoshua would like Israelis to distance themselves from exilic identity, and foster a purely Israeli one.
Antisemitism and the Relationship Between Zionism and Jewish Diasporic Identity
2015
I’m sitting cross-legged inside the small refugee tent, decorated with posters from the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades. Across from me is Mohammed, a new Canadian and for-mer Palestinian resident of East Jerusalem. We make eye contact, I give a little smile. Diagonally to my left, sitting down, smiling and hugging his knees is Ori. He’s an Israeli who’s recently shown me a film he made while serving his mandatory military service in Southern Lebanon. The video, shot from an opening in his jacket with a hidden camera (the IDF doesn’t take kindly to soldiers filming while on duty) depicts the hardships of army life as the soldiers of his unit lip-sync the lyrics to Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody”. “Mamma mia let me go ” is not exactly the lyrical basis of a pro-military kind of film. To my left is Racheli. Also an Israeli, Racheli fits the stereotype of someone from Northern Tel Aviv; worldly, stylish, and VERY lefty. Racheli was condemning the occupation long before Ariel Sharon decided the “O...
The State of Israel and the Jewish Diaspora
2004
This Report examines in depth the complex relationship that exists between the State of Israel and the Jewish Diaspora. The Report comprises five main parts and several appendices which present some important documents of interest for the Israel-Diaspora relationship. The first part on The State of Israel and the Jewish Diaspora after a review of some general unique and shared patterns of Diasporas, presents an overview of the Jewish People and Israel in historical perspective, followed by a discussion of the peculiar double role of the State of Israel as the State of the Jewish people and the State of its citizens. An overview is also provided of the main legal provisions in the State of Israel concerning the relationship with the Diaspora, namely in the area of citizenship. The second part presents a detailed overview of the Demography of World Jewish Population. Attention is given to the determinants of Jewish population change as is the case of other sub-populations in a broader context, and to the ensuing peculiar conceptual and technical Issues. After a discussion of Jews in the global system, detailed data are given on World Jewish population size and geographical distribution in 2004, and an overall picture and prospects for the future are provided. The third part provides a detailed examination of the Institutional and Organizational SetUp of Jewish communities in Israel and in the Diaspora. It briefly raises some general principles of governance now observable among the Jewish people, and follows describing the main global and international Jewish organizations, the major organizations based in the United States, Jewish organizations in other countries. Some overall analysis and conclusions are presented in the end. The fourth part discusses Strategic Challenges that stand in front of the Jewish people, beginning with an overall balance and followed by a detailed analysis of the impact of external environment on the Jewish people and Judaism, and major internal trends within the Jewish people with special attention to the interactions between Israel and Diaspora. The fifth part deals with Future Prospects with special attention to future common decision-making mechanisms such as the Presidential suggestion to create a Second House devoted to the discussion of common issues between the State of Israel and the Diaspora. The final remarks reconsider the challenges of peoplehood survival and interaction in the current era of globalization.
The Jewish Diaspora and the State of Israel
Since the biblical times, the Land of Israel has been the centre of focus, both spiritually and theologically. The historical roots, culture and the religious identity of the Jewish people – within Israel – can be traced back many centuries, even before Judaism was formally unified and centralised (Safran, 2005). Moreover, the existence of Judaism and its adherents within Israel can be seen perpetually throughout history. This further implies the spiritual and theological importance and role of the Holy Land from a Jewish perspective. However, over time, the perception and interpretation of Judaism and its teachings have changed dramatically: from Orthodox, to Conservation and then Reform. Therefore, this essay will briefly assess the relationship between the Jewish Diaspora and the state of Israel throughout history. In addition, the findings will be supplemented with an examination and overview of the Orthodox and Reform perspectives on the modern state of Israel.
Toe establishment of the State of Israel in I 948 was at once the Zionist move ment's greatest triumph and the beginning of an ongoing crisis of self-doubt. Its principal goal achieved, Zionism could have ceased to exis� as did the movement for women's suffrage in the United States with the passage of the Nineteenth Amendment. Indeed, some Jewish leaders quickly argued that its historical mission was complete; its continued existence served no useful purpose. For Amer ican Jewry as a whole, which had emerged after the Holocaust as the largest Jewish community and chief representative of the Jewish Diaspora, the transformation of Palestinian Jewry into an independent political entity immediately made their relationship highly problematic.
It is now more than fifty years since the State of Israel was established. It has passed the initial stages of nation building and is today, in many respects, a Western, technological society. It was never, however, a "new nation," created ex nihilo. It was built, in large measure, on the experience of ideologically driven Jewish settlement in Eretz Israel (Palestine), which began in the nineteenth cen tury. It also had as its background the Holocaust and its tragic results for the Jewish people; war and an ongoing military struggle with neighboring coun tries; and the necessity of absorbing unprecedented numbers of new immigrants from very different backgrounds. It has a multiethnic population, comprising groups that vary widely in their degree of Jewish cultural traditionalism as well as their level of modernization. While the challenges of immigration, absorp tion, and the external threat of war served as unifying factors for Jewish society in Israel for much of Israel's history, the situation has shifted in recent years. Partly as a result of the establishment of formal relations with a number of major Arab neighboring states and the ongoing search for reconciliation with the Palestinian Arabs-a relationship which again flared up and doused aspira tions for a speedy accord-the strengthened self-assurance of Israel's long-term existence shifted the focus of Israeli public discourse to domestic matters. In addition, Israel has experienced significant socioeconomic development and, along with it, the emergence of a pattern of individualism characteristic of other advanced Western societies. Additional Western, mainly American, cultural influ ences, particularly in the area of consumerism, have also, through rapid growth in electronic communication, increasingly penetrated, inter alia, into Israel's so cial structure. Israel of today is thus a society in transition where different sets of values occasionally increase intergroup tensions and challenge social cohe sion. The rhythm of events, trends, and innovation in various areas is intense. Israel continues to be a living laboratory for social research. This book consists primarily of new articles, as well as a few that are expan sions and elaborations of previous work, by foremost specialists on the central issues of contemporary Israeli Jewish society. Our approach to understanding Jewish life in Israel is largely interdisciplinary but with an overriding sociologi cal perspective. We focus on the behaviors of people, rather than institutions or organizations, within the many social, cultural, and political realms. We begin with a social history of Jews in Israel over the last century (Rebhun), to provide background for the rest of the volume. This is followed by a detailed analysis by
Journal of International Political Theory, 2017
This article explores a question that is often assumed but rarely addressed: What does Israel provide ideationally for Diaspora Jews that serves as the basis for Diaspora/Israel relations and justifies the importance of Israel for Jewish identity? Whereas past literature on this topic has either assumed an answer to this question or debated survey results and demographics, this article takes a different approach by not assuming an answer to this question. The article argues that Diaspora Jews’ relationship with Israel is best understood phenomenologically. The significance of Israel for Diaspora Jews is found in a type of obligation that is political but is not based in sovereignty or law but instead in meaning that serves as a form of authority and functions as part of the phenomenological structure characterizing Jewish being-in-the-world in the age of Israel. Using a combination of personal reflection, empirical research, and theoretical investigation, the article concludes by su...
2012
he concept of Jewish identity in Israel would seem to be as self-evident as European identity in Belgium. Modern Israel was conceived as a beacon for the world' s Jews, inspired by Jewish philosophy and informed by a desire to chart the next stage in Jewish consciousness. One would expect Jewishness to be its lifeblood. Things turned out differently. In fact, it was partly the desire to forge a "New Jew" that left Jewish identity in a sort of limbo in the nascent state. The negation of the Diaspora, central to classical Zionist thought, allowed little room for an identity perceived as antiquated and destined for disappearance. In the religious sphere, the ceding of authority to an ultra-Orthodox rabbinate fostered negative attitudes towards the religion among Israel' s non-Orthodox majority, as well as an assumption that one cannot express Jewish religious identity outside of Orthodox strictures. To be sure, a new Jewish cultural archetype has emerged in Israel. But it is Israeli first and foremost. For most Israelis, it has not embodied uniquely Jewish forms of expressions and religious possibility. Many Israelis feel ambivalent to this day about the Jewish aspects of their national identity-their relationship to Jewish wisdom, history, tradition and philosophy. Recently, there have been promising signs of change. New generations have begun to explore expressions of Jewish identity that reject the longstanding religious-secular divide. They are discovering different ways of being Jewish-in some cases inspired by global Jewish communal trends, and in others informed by uniquely Israeli sensibilities. The articles in this issue of CONTACT explore these new vistas of Jewish identity in Israel. Taken together, they paint a picture of an evolving spiritual, intellectual and cultural landscape that is giving new energy to Jewish life in Israel and beyond.