Training Policy for the 21st Century: Decentralization and Workforce Development Programs for Unemployed Working-Age Adults in Canada (original) (raw)
Related papers
Environment and Planning A, 2001
This paper critiques the learning-region literature on two related points. The first is that the learning-region analysis of labour markets is theoretically underdeveloped, because it underestimates the difficulty of overcoming systematic skill mismatches, underinvestment, and free-rider practices which characterize unregulated labour markets. Second and relatedly, because it does not link the problematic nature of labour-market governance to the conflicts and contradictions of state policy, the learning-region literature effectively ‘depoliticizes’ policymaking. The paper draws on a case study of the development of local boards for training and adjustment in Ontario, Canada, and develops an alternative framework utilizing a critical governance perspective which stresses how knowledge and learning must be seen as part of state accumulation and hegemonic strategies. Such strategies are contingent on the representation of stakeholders, in particular business, and current attempts to d...
Training as the Principal Focus of Adjustment Policy: A Critical View from Northern Ontario
Canadian Public Policy / Analyse de Politiques, 1997
Cette étude de cas régional porte sur les effets de la formation sur l'ajustement de marché du travail suite à des licenciements de grande ampleur dans la communauté minière d'Elliot Lake dans le nord de l'Ontario. A l'aide de données d'enquête longitudinales, nous montrons que les programmes de formation ont eu, pris dans l'ensemble, des bénéfices limités pour les travailleurs qui ont perdu leur emploi, même si les programmes de plus longue durée au niveau collégial semblent être plus efficaces. Ceci n'implique pas toutefois qu'il faille réduire les dépenses de formation car elles peuvent avoir des bénéfices sociaux et psychologiques importants pour les travailleurs qui ont perdu leur emploi ainsi que leurs familles. Cet article est une critique de l'approche contemporaine qui fait de la formation le principal outil d'ajustement, du moins de la façon dont elle a été utilisée dans les communautés qui dépendent d'une seule industrie comme Elliot Lake. This is a regional case study of the effects of training on labour market adjustment following mass layoffs in a single-industry mining community, Elliot Lake in Northern Ontario. Based on longitudinal survey data we find that training programs as a whole had limited benefits to the laid-off workers, particularly in terms of reemployment, although longer-duration programs at the college level appeared more effective. This is not a call to cut funding for training, which can have important social and psychological benefits for laid-off workers and their families; but it is a criticism of the current approach that makes training the principal focus of adjustment policy, at least as it plays out in single-industry communities like Elliot Lake.
The labour market impacts of adult education and training in Canada
2003
Abstract In this report, we use the data from the 1998 Adult Education and Training Survey (AETS) to estimate the impact of participating in adult education and training on the employment and earnings of Canadians. We apply methods that assume ���selection on observables���, including both standard regression-based methods and propensity score matching methods.
Reforming labour-market policy governance: the Quebec experience
Canadian Public Administration/Administration publique du Canada, 1998
Research on labour-market programs suggests that their effectiveness is enhanced when the private sector is involved in designing and directing them. One way of bringing this influence to bear involves the creation of concerted deliberative assemblies, dominated by organized business and labour, that are granted an important decision-making authority regarding these measures. This article examines the effort to launch such a deliberative assembly in Quebec, the only Canadian province that has, to this point, succeeded in putting such an assembly into place durably. The model has encountered significant obstaclesabove all, the resistance of officials and politicians who are anxious to protect their traditional policy-making prerogatives, as well as to protect labour-market programs from uninformed and self-interested private-sector input. Nevertheless, the governance reform has acquired a clear record of accomplishments since it was launched in 1991. Moreover, while the Quebec political economy is clearly more auspicious for the concertation model than is the case elsewhere in Canada, it nevertheless offers some useful insights to those who might attempt to apply the model elsewhere in Canada.
Low-Paid Workers and On-the-Job Training in Canada
Relations industrielles, 2000
This paper provides evidence of on-the-job training for low-paid workers in Canada and examines workplace and individual factors associated with their on-the-job training. The study uses Statistics Canada’s Workplace and Employee Survey (WES) 2001 data. Results show that less than a quarter of low-paid workers received on-the-job training in 2001 as compared to one third of higher-paid workers. A decomposition of regression models indicated that this substantive gap is statistically significant. With the shrinking labour force, ongoing skills development is needed to enable workers to earn a decent living, fulfill their work-related goals, and contribute to the current and future productivity of their workplaces and the economy. We recommend governments provide support for low-paid workers’ on-the-job training.
Devolution of Employment and Training Policy
Journal of Aging & Social Policy, 2003
The case for the devolution of employment and training programs has traditionally been based on the supply side argument that state and local governments are in the best position to assess the training needs of their disadvantaged workers. We provide a different perspective by focusing on the demand side of the labor market and the link between aiding older workers and fostering economic growth. We illustrate the importance of this focus by examining the labor market in Massachusetts, where the full employment economy of the late 1990s resulted in serious labor supply bottlenecks. Older workers, whose ranks are growing rapidly, provide the largest known labor reserve for meeting these labor supply deficits in the next decade. Tapping this reserve, however, means improving skills, deferring retirement, bringing older persons back into the labor market, and increasing full-time employment.