Karen Ferreira-Meyers, Book Review: Dong Guaqiang and Andrew G. Walder, A Decade of Upheaval: The Cultural Revolution in Rural China, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2022. NETSOL, 7/1, SRING 2022, pp.48-51. https://www.netsoljournal.net (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Review of Politics, 2011
Wretched Rebels is an abridged translation of Lucien Bianco's Jacqueries et révolution dans la Chine du XXe siècle (Editions de la Martinière, 2005). Jaqueries systemized the analysis of Peasants without the Party (Sharpe, 2001), a volume that anthologized articles and papers Bianco published between 1970 and 1999 and that won the Association for Asian Studies Joseph R. Levenson award in 2003. Despite this complicated bibliographic context, Wretched Rebels stands alone as an incisive and valuable overview of rural unrest in twentieth-century China, representing the distillation of a lifetime of scholarship on the Chinese revolution by one of the giants in the field. The work's central focus is the nature of unorganized-by revolutionary parties, secret societies, or popular sects-peasant resistance and its implications for Chinese revolutionary history. Though Bianco writes from a perspective sympathetic to the plight of oppressed farmers, he is no apologist for the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). A vocal critic of Maoist excess in the 1970s, Bianco here soundly refutes Maoist historiography by establishing with exquisite historical detail the comparative lack of peasant class consciousness in prerevolutionary China. In short, he finds that peasants resisted taxes far more often than rents, and that most collective action represented a broad-based coalition of landowners, tenants, and laborers. Only rarely did the poorest peasants take action against the landholding class, since it was the state, not rural class structure, that was the main target of peasant disturbances. Tax resistance was omnipresent, while the imposition of modernizing policies by the late Qing and Nationalist (GMD) states, and the brutal wartime conscription practices of the latter, also incited considerable violence. Ultimately, "antitax revolts were the best and most consistent expression of the discontent of the great majority of Chinese villagers" (90). The first two chapters establish the typology of rural movements governing the book's analytical frame, drawing from a data set of 3,648 disturbances assembled mainly from local gazetteers, accounts compiled for the Wenshi ziliao (Cultural and Historical Materials) series, and materials from the First and Second National Archives of China and US State Department archives. Though cognizant of the mixed nature of many of these incidents and forthright in addressing the problems that this poses for his analysis, Bianco establishes a taxonomy that is instructive and largely convincing. At the broadest level he differentiates movements that opposed the state and those that did not. The former, the subject of chapter 1, are subdivided into antitax disturbances, opposition to state policies, and resistance to conscription. The latter, the focus of chapter 2, comprise "social movements" driven by vertical
The Cultural Revolution in the Countryside: Scope, Timing and Human Impact
The China Quarterly, 2003
Information extracted from 1,520 county annals published after 1987 is used to estimate the timing and impact of the Cultural Revolution in rural China. Outside observers initially concluded that the movement had little impact on remote rural regions, while early post-Mao revelations suggested that the opposite was the case. Adjusting for the tendency of shorter accounts to report fewer casualties, and with additional assumptions about under-reporting in the longer and more detailed accounts, the authors derive an estimated death toll of between 750,000 and 1.5 million, a similar number of people permanently injured, and 36 million who suffered some form of political persecution. The vast majority of these casualties occurred from 1968 to 1971, after the end of the period of popular rebellion and factional conflict and the establishment of provisional organs of local state power.
The Journal of Asian Studies, 2002
The War of Resistance to Japan of 1937-1945 was a defining moment in the development of Eást Asia not simply because of its conflict but also because its progress led directly to the victory of the Chinese Communist Party in 1949, the establishment of the People's Republic of China, the retreat of the Chinese Nationalist Party to Taiwan, and indirectly to the economic and po litical consequences of those events. Necessarily, the history of the War of Resistance to Japan has been and remains highly ideologized: seen through the filters of the civil war between Nationalists and Communists, the wider Cold War of which the Chinese conflict rapidly became part, and the politics within the Chinese Communist Party. Important as those perspectives may be, they can also obscure the dynamics of social change. In the 1990s the climate for scholarship began to change dramatically, both because there was greater access to a wider range of sources and also because there was greater and closer interaction among scholars globally, betw een those inside and those outside the People's Republic of China researching the War of Resistance to Japan. This volume resulted from precisely that kind of cooperative project building on the latest re search into the dynamics of social change at the local level during the War of Resistance to Japan. Participants were invited to a workshop at the
The China Quarterly, 2016
the practice of discrimination according to class background by 1937, under Mao, it persisted until the Cultural Revolution. The last third of the book is devoted to Walder's masterful analysis of the Cultural Revolution. After the debacle of the Great Leap Forward, Mao never felt confident of the loyalty of comrades like Liu Shaoqi, Peng Zhen and Lu Dingyi. The Cultural Revolution was both a massive purge of "people in authority taking the capitalist road," and the destruction of the party-state bureaucracy by mobilizing student Red Guards against it. Walder's detailed account highlights significant facts: that the Red Guards were directed by the small group of Mao's loyalists (originally headed by Chen Boda, Mao's Yan'an tutor); that Red Guard factionalism was produced by this top-down manipulation rather than more deeply rooted conflicts among social groups; and that half of the Cultural Revolution's violent deaths (total of 1.2-1.6 million) occurred during 1968 when military-led organs of local power anxious to prove their own loyalty carried out a massive witch hunt including confessions forced by torture. The tragic consequences of Mao's rule for Chinese society come through vividly on every page of Walder's dispassionate and authoritative account. I hope that current and future generations of Chinese youth, who have been deprived of knowledge about Mao's China by parental reticence and politicized schooling, will have the chance to read it.