“Working from home is one major disaster”: An analysis of student feedback at a South African university during the Covid-19 lockdown (original) (raw)
Related papers
Education as Change
After the announcement of a national lockdown by the South African state in March 2020, university students and lecturers had to conduct learning activities online. In countries where reliable information and communications technologies exist, this transition was relatively smooth. Students were able to learn using internet-based online learning systems. This is not the case in South Africa. Based on in-depth interviews with some students and lecturers and the use of internet resources, this article demonstrates that the participation of students from poor and working-class households evinced many deficiencies. This is because South Africa’s information and communications technology infrastructure disadvantages poor and working-class households. The poor access to online learning that students from working-class and poor households experienced demonstrates that in South Africa the argument about the promise of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, which must supposedly be embraced by ev...
African Perspectives of Research in Teaching & Learning, 2021
The spread of the 2019 novel coronavirus in South Africa, like in many parts of the world, has led to a sustained national lockdown meant to prevent the continued spread, as well as a potential resurgence of the virus. This meant all institutions of learning (higher and basic education institutions) were closed. Higher education institutions in South Africa were forced to adopt Emergency Remote Online Teaching and Learning (EROTL) Modalities to salvage what was left of the 2020 academic year. This was partly to avoid a systematic and institutional collapse of the education sector. Therefore, in this paper I reflect on the pedagogical difficulties and successes that I have encountered as a teacher-educator (lecturer) at a rural university in Limpopo Province, South Africa relating to the sudden, unprecedented, shift from face-to-face teaching and learning to EROTL. This I do by employing a decolonial framework underpinned by decolonial love as decoloniality, and a living theory methodology with action-reflection cycles as a method. I concluded, for instance, that for EROTL to be meaningful and impactful; university departments need to have a reliable institutional memory that would enable new academic staff members to know what was taught previously in a specific module or course allocated to them. Beyond this, as lecturers, we need to build solid relationships with our students that centre their interests, and these relationships need to be informed by decolonial love. This will enable us to meaningfully collaborate with them in our pursuit of a successful academic project that is transformative. We also need, in our pedagogical choices, to consider other online platforms such as WhatsApp, especially in managing larger classes. Higher Education; Pedagogical Content Knowledge; Rural University.
International Journal of Information and Education Technology
The Covid-19 pandemic has caused many universities to move instruction online. For the most part, this move has not been based on sound principles and best practices of online teaching, but can instead be characterised as emergency remote teaching (ERT) that aims to continue instruction despite the substantial drawbacks of insufficient planning or training. Research has looked at challenges inherent in ERT, as well as considered the benefits of online instruction for flexible learning environments. However, little research has looked at the experiences of students from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds during ERT. This paper explores student feedback on two courses taught in 2020 at a South African university, collected during routine course evaluations. The two courses employed universal design for learning (UDL) principles in order to attempt to make the courses as accessible and equitable as possible for all students. Data were analysed using thematic content analysis. The themes...
Perspectives in Education
The outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic brought about an abrupt transition from face-to-face to online learning, which caught higher education institutions off guard. Universities had to scramble for solutions to ensure that learning was not disrupted and there was adequate technological infrastructure to conduct classes online; that academics were capacitated to conduct virtual teaching and that students had access to the necessary technology and internet connectivity. To understand this move, this study explored student teachers' experiences of the emergency transition to online learning during the COVID-19 lockdown at a South African university. The study was underpinned by the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and adopted a qualitative research design, generating data from ten fourth-year student teachers using a Zoom focus group discussion and analysing the data using an inductive thematic framework. The discussion focused on the students' views on digital equity and access to technology; the teaching and learning modalities they were exposed to; their proficiency with the technology and training received; assessment as well as views on the learning management system (LMS, which is Moodle in this case). The study found that among the issues that universities had to deal with were the digital divide; constrained pedagogical approaches; inadequate proficiency in the use of the learning management system; the fact that the quality and integrity of assessment were somewhat compromised as well as students' unfavourable living conditions which make learning from home difficult.
Online learning at the Durban University of Technology during the COVID-19 pandemic
Open Learning as a Means of Advancing Social Justice: Cases in Post-School Education and Training in South Africa
Online learning can be seen as a way to broaden educational provision. The South African Department of Higher Education and Training is turning to open learning approaches (such as online learning) to provide cost-effective mass enrolment in post-school education. This study adopts a qualitative approach to explore how online learning may be opening up education at the Durban University of Technology (DUT). The chapter shares the experiences of three staff members and one student, gathered via online interviews and WhatsApp chat discussions undertaken during emergency remote teaching (ERT). Although online learning is a strategic objective at DUT, it was not yet at full-scale implementation before the COVID-19 pandemic struck. The national lockdown thus accelerated the institution’s plans to take teaching and learning online. This research uses Nancy Fraser’s (2005) conception of social justice as parity of participation to examine the extent to which online learning creates ‘partic...
African Journal of Inter/Multidisciplinary Studies
The pandemic has compelled Higher Education Institutions around the world to resort to Emergency Remote Learning (ERL). This abrupt ‘pivot to online’ learning has exacerbated existing challenges in Higher Education, particularly in South Africa. This paper interrogates whether the sudden move to ERL has compounded or ameliorated existing academic challenges for students in Higher Education Institutions. The study summarised herein draws on ‘critical humanising pedagogy’, an approach that centres student needs in the teaching and learning process. In employing student experiences and perceptions of ERL, the study adopted a qualitative approach, with specific focus on students from one of SA’s top five universities. A perturbing finding is that teaching and learning under ERL has regressed into impersonal methodologies, devoid of any notion of pedagogy as the science and art of teaching. More unsettling is that ERL has alienated and disengaged students from learning as a collaborative...
International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research
The aim of article is to analyse the remote teaching and learning experiences of students, as expressed in online discussions among first-year students at a South African university, to enhance understanding of how learning remotely during Covid-19 lockdown affected students’ lives and their academic commitment. The article draws on data collected from 45 students, mainly aged between 18 and 22, registered for an academic literacy course. These students came from diverse racial, socioeconomic and schooling backgrounds, although most were black students. These participants’ Covid-19 and remote learning experiences are used in this case study as qualitative datasets. To generate rich narratives, a set of open-ended questions were designed and posted on the course’s Blackboard page. The questions focused on the socioeconomic, psychological and academic effects of Covid-19 during the lockdown. At the end of the course, a thematic analytical approach was used to identify and categorise p...
, 2022
Access to higher education has been one of the critical areas of concern in South Africa, particularly for students from disadvantaged backgrounds. The Corona-virus (Covid-19) pandemic has brought the systemic cleavages into sharp relief, with 'access' and subsequent 'success' emerging as an important variable. Availability of digital facilities and internet connectivity have been important factors in enabling participation in higher education during the Covid-19 pandemic. The advent of the pandemic has, however, brought a new context to the challenges of higher education access, deepening the precarious position of students from disadvantaged backgrounds. Thus, online teaching and learning intensified the digital divide between the 'haves' and the 'have-nots', exacerbating the already existing inequalities in the South African higher education system. The paper reflects on the question of how digital divide and access to learning infrastructure exacerbated inequality among students during the Covid-19 pandemic in South African higher education. This question is particularly important, given the rapid digitalisation of the curriculum that many South African institutions are still struggling to align with. This paper aims to interrogate the implications of the Covid-19 pandemic on South African higher education, highlighting the challenges of the digital divide and access to learning infrastructure using a social justice approach. The article draws on the work of Fraser (1999), which refers to the idea of social justice as distributional justice, re-allocating resources accessed solely by the privileged to the historically disadvantaged. It also aims to understand how the typology of inequality across the differentiated institutions affected the delivery of education during Covid-19. This is a qualitative research based on both secondary and primary data exploring official documents, statistics and published materials. The article argues towards a comprehensive and inclusive digital learning strategies with substantial coordination both from government and non-government stakeholders. It recommends that digital pedagogy and online platforms of learning should become an integral element of South African higher education services to ensure the continuity of education; this is necessary to avoid similar difficulties if crises that restrict physical movement occur in the future.
International journal of social sciences & educational studies, 2022
The purpose of this paper is to conceptually explore and examine teaching in higher education during and post COVID-19 era. This paper uses literature-based approach which considers a narrative review of literature as its main approach in exploring and examining data related to online teaching and learning in higher education. There has been various challenges and criticisms about online teaching ever since lockdown regulations instigated by COVID-19 in South Africa. Online teaching and learning has been criticized for their lack of quality assurance in higher education. Although there are claims, hiccups and criticisms of the quality assurance and credibility of online teaching and learning, accessing education is inevitable irrespective of the challenges encountered. Accessing education is important and goes beyond or post COVID-19 pandemic whereby distance learning should be endorsed in higher institutions. The paper argues that the usage of online platforms during COVID-19 pandemic became a panacea for the students who were remote from physical institutions of higher learning to access higher education. Therefore, the paper submits that while COVID-19 would have its aftermath in higher education institutions, there are lessons and prospects that could be drawn from the challenges. The paper recommends the rethinking strategies that could possibly be employed to enhance students' learning and engagement thereof. Among those strategies, is a Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) that encapsulate the blended method of pedagogy and Open Distance Learning (ODL) that may be effective in teaching and learning in the current circumstances.