Russian FDI in Central and Eastern European countries. Opportunities and threats (original) (raw)
2006, IWE Working Papers, No. 168
Abstract
Russian outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) has been showing a very promising performance in recent years. The Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries have become a key destination, but this is often viewed with suspicion by host countries. The paper begins with the quantity and geographical distribution of Russian capital investment, pointing to differences between estimates and official OFDI data reported on a balance-of-payments basis by the Central Bank of Russia, which are frequently revised. In some years, OFDI has exceeded the FDI inflows into Russia, which is very unusual for an ex-communist transformation country. It is also paradoxical that FDI from relatively poor and less developed Russia should be supporting the economies of relatively more developed countries. When the destinations are examined, it emerges that some of the FDI is round-tripping and trans-shipping, as a significant proportion of the investment is conducted indirectly, through third economies. The paper investigates the companies behind the transactions and their various motivesfor expanding abroad. The bulk of the OFDI has been coming from natural resource-based companies, Russia’s largest exporters, earning well from high world market prices for energy sources and raw materials. Having presented the Russian FDI position in the CEE region through the statistics of the host countries, the paper sets out to describe the main Russian-origin investments and trends in selected CEE countries. Special attention is paid to the strategic investments in the gas and oil industries and the alarming dependence on Russian natural gas and crude oil. It is stressed that Russian FDI is managed by mature strategies. The paper also looks at the usually negative attitude taken in ex-socialist CEE countries to companies with Russian capital. The reasons for resistance include memories of earlier Soviet policies, fear of losing control over the commanding heights of the economy, and so-called oil and gas diplomacy, as well as cultural, productivity and efficiency issues. Five case studies are cited to shed light on the probable acquisition methods. Finally, attention is turned to the prospects for Russian FDI in the CEE countries and to some actual privatization opportunities.
Figures (16)
End-period stock of Russian FDI, UsD, % Notes. UNCTAD uses CBR data. The CEE countries were defined up to 2004 as the following 19: Albania, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Macedonia, Moldova, Poland, Romania, Russia, Serbia and Montenegro, Slovakia, Slovenia, and Ukraine. For 2005, UNCTAD uses a fresh categorization. The new EU member countries (Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia) were reclassified as EU (hence developed economies), and the rest as South-East Europe (Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Ma- cedonia, Romania, and Serbia and Montenegro) and the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS): Ar- menia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan — formerly in a Cen- tral Asia group under developing countries. WIR 2005, p. 6) Despite this reclassification, the CEE-related proportions in this paper have been recalculated so as not to break the time series. ; UNCTAD FDI database.
Source: Kalotay 2003, 11-13, and own calcula~ tions. Main destinations of the Russian FDI out-~ flows, 1995-9 The top 10 destinations for OFDI projects from Russia, 2002-3, %
Stock of inward foreign direct investment (IFDI) from Russia in the CEE countries, Malta and Cyprus
Source. Ernst&Young 2004. Cross-border M&A deals by Russian firms announced by top five CEE destination countries, 2002 and 2003
Top 10 non-financial TNCs based in Russia, ranked by foreign assets, excluding shipping companies
Notes. The transnationality index (TNI) is calculated as an average of three ratios: foreign assets/total assets, foreign sales/total sales and foreign employment/total employment. Foreign assets (USD millions) appear in brackets. Lognn1 Anta Russian firms among the top 25 non-financial TNCs based in CEE countries, ranked by foreign assets Source. WIR 2004, 317, WIR 2003, 191, WIR 2002, 112, WIR 2001, 115.
Source. Gagilas 2002.
Top 10 non-financial TNCs from SE Europe and the CIS, ranked by foreign assets in 2003
Major gas-related investments in CEE countries yy Russians and dependence on the Russian natural ga Source. PAIIZ (Polish Information and Foreign Investment Agency), Gazprom 2005a, b; AK&M Online News 2005, Energiainfo.hu (various articles); The Moscow Times 2005g; company websites.
Major CEE oil-related investments by Russians and national dependence on Russian crude oil
Source. Portfolio.hu (2005d). Refining capacity of oil companies in the region, million t per year
Sources. External and intra-European Union trade. Monthly statistics. Eurostat, European Commission 2000/12, 76; 2001/12, 76; 2002/12, 76; 2003/12, 79; 2004/7, 79.
Notes. According to UNCTAD definitions, this is recorded at the time of deal closure, but M & A values are not necessarily paid out in a single year. The data cover deals involving acquisition of an equity stake of more than 10 per cent. They include purchases via domestic and international capital markets, which should not be considered as FDI flows. Moreover, M & A data are expressed as the total trans~ action amount of particular deals and not as differences between gross acquisitions and divestment abroad by firms from a particular country (here Russia). FDI flows are recorded on a net basis in a particular year. (See WIR 2005, pp. 301-2.)
Other major investments by Russians in CEE countries
On September 12, 2005, the Czech Anti-Monopoly Office approved the sale of the Czech Republic’s stake in Vitkovice Steel. The Moscow Times 2005k. — * On September 12, 2005, the Czech Anti-Monopoly Office approved the sale of the Czech Republic’s stake in Vitkovice Steel. The Moscow Times 2005k. During 2001-2, OMZ acquired a 66 per cent interest in S.C. UPET SA, a Targoviste-based facility specializing in manufacturing of mobile rings, components for offshore rigs and metal valves. In May 2004, the company (as part of the oil and gas equipment and shipbuilding business segments) was sold to certain members of the OMZ’s management. OMZ 2005, 22 and 48. | Through Germany-based Sinara Handel GmbH, a trading company of TMK. 4 Through Swiss-based Mechel Trading AG. ARIS (web).
Key takeaways
AI
- Russian outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) in CEE countries raises significant geopolitical concerns.
- OFDI from Russia exceeded $100 billion in 2004, highlighting its growing global economic influence.
- Natural resource companies dominate Russian OFDI, driven by high energy prices and market-seeking motives.
- Host countries exhibit resistance to Russian investment due to historical and economic fears.
- Privatization opportunities in Romania and Bulgaria present strategic entry points for Russian firms.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
References (107)
- AK&M Online News 2005. Oborot ev- ropeyskoy kholdingovoy kompanii Gaz- proma -ZGG -v I polugodii uvelichil- sya na 23 per cent do 1.6 mlrd. evro. In: ZGG website, August 25. http://www.zgg.de/russian/press/press\_d etails.php?newsid=54
- Albert, Ferenc 2002. Leállt a Cemtrade, 770 embert elbocsátottak (Cemtrade shuts down, 770 dismissed). Bihari Napló. January. http://www.hhrf.org/biharinaplo/02jan/ bn20124.htm Alexander's Gas and Oil Connections 2003a. Country Analysis: Baltic Sea Region. Alexander's Gas and Oil Con- nections. Vol. 8, No. 2, January 24. http://www.gasandoil.com/goc/news/nte 30400.htm Alexander's Gas and Oil Connections 2003b. Gazprom consortium acquires Lithuanian utility. Alexander's Gas and Oil Connections. Vol. 8, No. 8, April 17. http://www.gasandoil.com/goc/company /cnr31693.htm Äripäev 2004. Estonia: Trendgate to in- vest in oil terminal. In: Website of Lo- gistics Turku Region. May 6. http://www.logisticsturku.fi/logistics/BUL LETIN.NSF/0/0eba8eaa535f7276c2256e8 c002af287?OpenDocument Äripäev 2005. Press digest: Estonia - Äripäev. Baltic Business News, August 1. http://www.balticbusinessnews.com/mod /onl_news.pl?disp=2&uud_id=456306
- Äripäev Online 2002. Port of Muuga beats other ports for large coal supply order from Russia. Äripäev Online, October 2. http://www.aripaev.ee/2244/free/summa ry.html ARIS (web). Top foreign companies in Romania 2004. Romanian Agency for Foreign Investment. http://www.arisinvest.ro/level1.asp?ID=1 99&LID=2 Baltic Rim Economies 2005. Baltic Rim Economies. (Bimonthly review of Turku School of Economics and Business Ad- ministration) No. 2, April 28.) http://www.tukkk.fi/pei/bre/BRE\_2\_200 5.pdf Bank of Lithuania 2005. Annual Report of the Bank of Lithuania 2004. Bank of Lithuania, Vilnius. http://www.lb.lt/eng/publications/annual s/annual_2004.pdf Bank of Moscow (web). About Bank of Moscow. In: Website of Bank of Mos- cow. http://www.mmbank.ru/eng/about/
- Barát, Szabolcs 2005. Új olajnagyhatalom a régióban? -Interjú a Lukoil elnökhe- lyettesével (New oil superpower in the region? Interview with the deputy pre- sident of Lukoil). Portfolio.hu. July 19. http://www.portfolio.hu/cikkek.tdp?cChe ck=1&k=2&i=56568
- Barát, Szabolcs, and Balázs Sándorfi 2005. Interjú az OMV vezérével: versenyről, INA privatizációról, orosz olajról, 10 per cent-os MOL pakettről (Interview with the head of OMV, on competition, INA privatization, Russian oil, the 10 per cent MOL tranche). Portfolio.hu. April 4. http://www.portfolio.hu/cikkek.tdp?k=2 &i=52540&p=5
- Bloomberg 2005. Yukos defaults on long- term contracts to supply oil. Bloomberg. January 20. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news? pid=10000085&sid=ac1hwTmum5ws&ref er=europe BP 2004. BP Statistical Review of World Energy 2004. June. BP 2005. BP Statistical Review of World Energy 2005. June.
- Budapest Stock Exchange 2005. A MOL értékesíti lengyelországi töltőállomás hálózatát (MOL sells Polish filling- station chain). Budapest Stock Ex- change. September 28. http://www.bet.hu/onlinesz/10000638.ht ml?newsid=13502&uio=
- Bulandra, Iulian, 2005. Artrom Slatina exports 80 per cent of its output. Romanian Daily. September 28. http://romaniandaily.ro/cat44603/art1609 673711/ Bulatov, Alexander S., 1998. Russian di- rect investment abroad: main motiva- tions in the post-Soviet period. Trans- national Corporations. Vol. 7, No. 1, April. pp. 69-82.
- CBR 2004. International investment posi- tion of Russia for 2000-2003. In: Website of Central Bank of Russia. September 30. http://www.cbr.ru/eng/statistics/credit\_s tatistics/print.asp?file=iip_rf_e.htm CBR 2005a. International investment posi- tion of Russia for 2000-2004. In: Website of Central Bank of Russia. July 12. http://www.cbr.ru/eng/statistics/credit\_s tatistics/print.asp?file=iip_rf_e.htm CBR 2005b. Balance of payments of the Russian Federation. In: Website of Cen- tral Bank of Russia. September 30. http://www.cbr.ru/eng/statistics/credit\_s tatis- tics/print.asp?file=bal_of_payments_05_e .htm CBR 2005c. Net outflow of private sector capital. In: Website of Central Bank of Russia. October 5. http://www.cbr.ru/eng/statistics/credit\_s tatistics/print.asp?file=capital_e.htm České noviny 2004. Russia's OMZ takes over shares in three Skoda Holding units. eské noviny. July 14. http://www.ceskenoviny.cz/news/index\_ view.php?id=78022 CIA World Factbook 2005. http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/fact book/ Cienski, Jan 2004. New bribery allega- tions threat to Polish party. The Finan- cial Times. November 1. CNB 2005. Foreign Direct Investment 2003. Czech National Bank. March. http://www.cnb.cz/www.cnb.cz/en/statis tics/bop_stat/bop_publications/pzi_books /PZI_2003_EN.pdf CNB (web) Foreign direct investment. In: Czech National Bank website. http://www.cnb.cz/en/statistics/bop\_stat /fdi/ CompLex Céghírek 2004. CompLex CD Céghírek (company news). KJK-Kerszöv Jogi és Üzleti Kiadó, Budapest. October
- DKG-East Annual Report 2004. Dunning, John H., 1981. Explaining the international direct investment position of countries: towards a dynamic or developmental approach. Weltwirt- schaftliches Archiv 119/1, 30-64.
- Dunning, John H., 1986. The investment development cycle revisited. Weltwirt- schaftliches Archiv. 122/4, 667-7.
- Durka, Barbara, and Janusz Chojna, eds, 2004. Foreign investments in Poland. Annual Report. Warsaw: Foreign Trade Research Institute.
- E.ON 2004 MOL Gas acquisition update. E.ON. November www.eon.com/download/dwn/602/ 20041111_MOL_Gas_Transaction_Hando ut.pdf eBroker.hu 2005a. A Gazprom nem vásá- rol részesedést a szlovák SPP gázszol- gáltatóban (Gazprom not buying stake in Slovak SPP gas provider). eBro- ker.hu. June 13. http://www.ebroker.hu/pls/ebrk/new\_cik kek_html_p.startup?p_cikk_id=85837580 eBroker.hu 2005b. Fitch: mérföldkő az OMV-Aral ügylet a cseh üzemanyag- piacon (OMV-Aral deal on Czech fuel market a milestone). eBroker.hu. Octo- ber 11. http://www.ebroker.hu/pls/ebrk/new\_cik kek_html_p.startup?p_cikk_id=91254376
- East Express 2005. Confirmation of new owner of Mobtel Serbia 063 expected. East Express. August 22. http://www.wirtschaftsblatt.at/express/e astexpress022005.pdf
- Eesti Gaas 2005. AS Eesti Gaas Annual Report 2004.
- Eesti Gaas (web). In: AS Eesti Gaas' web- site http://www.gaas.ee/index.php?lang=eng& main_id=24 EIA 2005. Baltic Sea Region. Country analysis briefs. Energy Information Administration. March. http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/balti cs.html Embassy of Denmark in Sarajevo 2005. Overview of the energy and environ- ment sectors in B&H. July 25. In: Website of the Embassy of Denmark in Sarajevo. http://www.ambsarajevo.um.dk/da/men u/Eksportraadgivning/Markedsmulighed er/Sektoranalyser/MiljoeOgEnergi/ Energiainfo.hu 2004. A PKN-Mol-fúziót az oroszok politikai befolyásszerzésre akarják felhasználni (Russian aim to use PKN-MOL merger to gain political influence. Energiainfo.hu. April 19. http://www.energiainfo.hu/?i=8086&s=9 2&m=10
- Energiainfo.hu 2005a. Belarusz orosz gázt vesz (Belarus buys Russian gas). Ener- giainfo.hu. January 4. http://gazpiac.hu/?t=1&i=9820&m=10&s =158 Energiainfo.hu 2005b. Drágábban adná a gázt a Gazprom a balti államoknak (Gazprom wants to sell gas dearer to Baltic States) Energiainfo.hu. June 8. http://gazpiac.hu/?t=1&i=10978&m=10& s=158
- Energiainfo.hu 2005c. A Gazprom mégsem száll be a szlovák SPP-be (Gazprom not going into Slovak SPP after all). Energiainfo.hu. June 14. http://gazpiac.hu/?t=1&i=11043&m=10&s =158 Energiainfo.hu 2005d. Kivonul a Shell Romániából (Shell leaves Romania). En- ergiainfo.hu. June 16. http://olajpiac.hu/?t=2&i=11089&m=10& s=165
- Energiainfo.hu 2005e. Szeptemberben dön- tenek a szlovák gáztársaság, az SPP átszervezéséről (September decision on reorganizing Slovak gas company SPP). Energiainfo.hu. August 12. http://gazpiac.hu/?i=11625&m=10&t=1& s=159
- Energiainfo.hu 2005. Esso-kutakat vesz a Grupa Lotos (Grupa Lotos buys Esso pumps). Energiainfo.hu. August 26. http://olajpiac.hu/index.xp?i=11776&m= 10&t=1&s=165
- Energyforum.net 2001. Russian Gazprom to control Lithuanian gas supplier. Energyforum.net. December 7. http://www.energyforum.net/news/week 50/news91.shtml Ernst&Young 2004 Sliyaniya i pogloshc- heniya v Rossii. Obzor sdelok 2003 goda. Moscow: Ernst&Young. March.
- Estonian Investment Agency 2004a. Rus- sian industrial giant to build a new oil terminal near Muuga port. Estonian Investment Agency. May 7. http://www.investinestonia.com/popups/ newswindow.php?id=160
- Estonian Investment Agency 2004b. Sever- staltrans to become dominant player in Estonian oil trade. Estonian Investment Agency. November 8. http://www.investinestonia.com/index.ph p?option=news&Itemid=2&topid=0# Estonian Investment Agency (web). Com- panies with major shareholdings 2004. Estonian Investment Agency. http://www.investinestonia.com/pdf/Com panies_major_shareholdings_2004.pdf Estonian Ministry of Foreign Affairs 2005. Economic development in the Baltic Countries. Background paper prepared by External Economics and Develop- ment Cooperation Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Re- public of Estonia. http://web- static.vm.ee/static/failid/320/Economic_d evelopment_Baltic_Countries.pdf Estonian Railways (web). Severstaltrans acquires a controlling stake in EOS. Estonian Railways. http://www.evr.ee/?id=1724&langchange=1
- Estonian Trade Council 2005. Estonia: Spacecom transships 449,249 tons of oil in February. Estonian Trade Coun- cil. March 15. http://www.etc.ee/index.php?page=42&a ction=article&article_id=1623
- Evrazholding 2005. Evraz Group SA to acquire Vitkovice Steel in Czech Re- public. July 13. In: Evrazholding's web- site. http://www.evrazholding.ru/en/press\_ce ntre/news/index.php?id48=716 External and intra-European Union trade. Monthly statistics. Eurostat, European Commission. 2000/12; 2001/12; 2002/12; 2003/12; 2004/7. http://www.fn.hu/cikk.php?id=3&cid=63 362 FigyelőNet 2003b. Az ÁÉB megvette a Binimex Kft.-t (ÁÉB bought Binimex). FigyelőNet. December 10. http://www.fn.hu/cikk.php?id=3&cid=71 726 FigyelőNet 2004a. A Gazprom végleges ajánlatot tesz a román gázszolgál- tatókra (Gazprom makes last offer for Romanian gas provider). FigyelőNet. July 13. http://www.fn.hu/cikk.php?id=3&cid=83 445 FigyelőNet 2004b. 300 millió eurót fizet a Ruhrgas a román gázszolgáltatóért (Ruhrgas to pay 300 million for Ro- manian gas provider). FigyelőNet. Oc- tober 21. http://www.fn.hu/cikk.php?cid=88678&i d=4 FigyelőNet 2004c. A Lukoil megvenné a bolgár Petrolt (Lukoil to buy Bulgarian Petrol). FigyelőNet. December 8. http://www.fn.hu/cikk.php?id=3&cid=90 956 FigyelőNet 2005. Többséget szerzett az állam a Gazpromban (State gains ma- jority in Gazprom). FigyelőNet. June 26. http://www.fn.hu/index.php?id=5&cid=1 00783
- Finance.cz 2005. Rumuni odloží termín nabídek na Electrica Mutenia Sud. Fi- nance.cz. November 11. http://www.finance.cz/toCP1250/zpravy /finance/56562/
- Floreno 2004. A magyarországi petrolké- miai ipar lehetséges fejlődési irányai, különös tekintettel a nemzetközi össze- függésekre (Possible lines of develop- ment in Hungary's petrochemical in- dustry, with special attention to inter- national connections). Floreno Kft., Bu- dapest. Prepared for the Ministry of Economy and Transport -Hungary. June.
- Forbes Russia's 100 Richest 2004.
- Forum Invest 2003. The development of business partnerships with the Russian Federation. Conference paper. Moscow. October 21-2. In: Forum Invest web- site. http://www.foruminvest.ro/services.php? sec=forum&sub=desk&cont=documentati on&id=53 FSEE 2005. Karic's big deal. Forum for South-Eastern Europe. May 31. http://balkansecurity.com/news/index.ph p?l=en&q=ekonomija&enddate=2005-05- 31&login=&passwd=
- Gagilas, Vladas, 2002. Lithuanian gas sector. Workshop paper. http://europa.eu.int/comm/energy/gas/ work- shop_2002/doc/candidate_countries/lith uania_internal_gas_market.pdf Gazprom 2005a. Gazprom annual report 2004. Moscow: Gazprom. http://www.gazprom.com/documents/A nnual_Report_Eng_2004.pdf Gazprom 2005b. Gazprom in figures 2000-2004. Moscow: Gazprom. http://www.gazprom.ru/documents/Stati stika per cent20En.pdf
- Gorshenin, Vladimir, 1995. Zarubezhnoye dostoyaniye Rossii. Ekonomika i Zhizn 19, 38. Gostamkom 2003, 2004 and 2005. Tamozhennaya Statistika Vneshney Torgovli Rossiyskoy Federatsii 2002, 2003, 2004. Sbornik. Moscow: Gostamkom. Government of the Republic of Croatia 2002. Strong interest in INA privatisat- ion as 10 companies submit detailed expressions of interest. Website of Government of the Republic of Croatia. Press release. June 14. www.vlada.hr/ina- privatizacija/english/press-3.html GVH 2005 Hungary's Competition Office, Vj-14/2005/4. March 2. http://www.gvh.hu/index.php?id=3748&l HFSEA (web) Hungarian Financial and Stock Exchange Almanac. http://www.tas.hu/uj.cgi?p=sitemap&l=m agyar&t=t&s=&r=&v=7837097656
- Híradó 2005. Rahimkulov a MOLra és a BorsodChemre tesz (Rakhimulov goes for MOL and BorsodChem). Híradó. September 30. http://www.hirado.hu/cikk.php?id=64091 HSH Nordbank 2005 HSH Nordbank Baltic Report. Corporate Communicat- ions, HSH Nordbank. No. 2/05, May. HVG 2004a. Nyomáspróba (Pressure test). HVG. No. 6, February 7.
- HVG.hu 2004b. Oroszország: elzárt gáz- csapok Európa felé. HVG. February 18. http://hvg.hu/frisshirek\_cikk.asp?oID=A 331294D-6038-40FD-9556- 07509A473A7E
- HVG.hu 2005. Terjeszkedés délen. Egymil- liárd dollárt visz Bulgáriába a Lukoil (Spreading south. Lukoil puts a billion dollars into Bulgaria). HVG.hu. Novem- ber 17. http://hvg.hu/gazdasag/20051117Lukoil bulg.aspx IBSP (web). Website of the International Bank of St. Petersburg. http://www.ibsp.ru/tallinn.htm INA (web). INA's website. http://www.ina.hr/eng/page.asp?p=1
- Index 2004. Késve fizet a Gazprom a szlovák SPP-ért (Gazprom pays late for Slovak SPP). Index. July 26. http://index.hu/gazdasag/ghirek/?main: 2004.07.26.&187524
- Index 2005. Folytatódik a horvát INA pri- vatizációja (Privatization of Croatian INA continues). Index. September 23. http://index.hu/gazdasag/vilag/ina5753/ INGfn Romania 2004. Lukoil takes over Romanian company for USD 121 mil- lion. INGfn Romania. January 23. http://www.ingfn.ro/?m0=0&m1=0&page n=126&printView=1&id=254352&lang=en
- Interfax 2004. Pipe Metallurgic Company creates a mini-holding in Romania. In- terfax. May 21. http://www.tmk- group.com/eng/?id=428743&doc_id=903
- Interfin Capital 2005. Bulgaria relies on RAO UES' investments. Interfin Capital. May 27. http://ifcapital.com/main/news/digest?ye ar=2005&month=5&day=27&id=2654&P HPSES- SID=dc0b175f0d9b52b8d5b7da52fa551f ec
- Ion, Sergiu, 2004. Lukoil a preluat o firma romaneasca pentru 121 mil. $. Ziarul Financiar. January 23, 3. http://www.mediaimage.ro/WKY-PUR- TML/monitorizare/newsletter/23_01_04/ buc_zia_230104_87_3.html Itera Press Service 2005. ITERA and the Government of Macedonia signed co- operation agreement. Itera Press Ser- vice. August 25. http://www.iteragroup.com/isp/eng/inde x/articles/185/6/
- Ïurianová, Marta, 2005. Slovakia wants to discuss Transpetrol with Russia. The Slovak Spectator 11:40, October 17-23. http://www.slovakspectator.sk/clanok.as p?cl=21049
- Jankauskas, Vidmantas, 2005. Develop- ment of energy regulation in Lithuania. Paper presented at workshop 'Reform- ing Infrastructure: privatization, regu- lation and competition', Riga, May 3. http://www.sprk.gov.lv/index.php?id=40 11&sadala=135
- Kalotay, Kálmán 2003. Outward foreign direct investment from economies in transition in a global context. Journal for European Management Studies 8:1, 6-24.
- Kalotay, Kálmán 2004. The late riser TNC: Outward FDI from Central and Eastern Europe. Conference paper 'New Europe 2020. Visions and Strategies for Wider Europe'. Turku School of Economics and Business Administration, Turku (Finland). August 27-8. http://www.tukkk.fi/pei/NewEurope/par allelsessions.htm Kamakin, Andrei 2005. Dzhentlmeni u dachi. Itogi. No. 10.
- Khaldin, Mikhail A, and Vladimir D. An- drianov 1996. Kapital Rossii: potyeryat ili preumnozhit? Ekonomika. Centr Kompleksnikh Sotsialnikh Issledovaniy i Marketinga, Moskva. No. 1.
- Kommersant 2004. 100 Largest Financiers of Russia, Kommersant. August 1. http://kommersant.com/page.asp?id=-1465
- Kornienko, Sophia, 2004. Short-lived rows hamper Russian-Estonian business. The St. Petersburg Times. August 24. KPMG 2005. Investment in the Baltic States. A comparative guide. KPMG. http://www.investinestonia.com/pdf/inve stment_in_the_baltics_2005.pdf
- Králik, Lóránd, 2004. Fellendülőben a román alumíniumipar. Könnyű szárn- yak (Romanian aluminium industry ex- panding. Easy wings). HVG. June 16. http://hvg.hu/hvg\_friss\_cikk.asp?oID=fe a72e9d-b37f-43a3-ab97-bc93917612fa
- Laurynas, Byla, 2003. Investors last week retreated from Mazeikiu Nafta. Finan- cial Brokerage Company "J s tarpin- inkas". November 4. http://www.jt.lt/English/Naujienos/P\_Na u_Ben2_Tur.asp?ID=28364
- LBB 2004. Website of Latvijas Biznesa Banka. http://www.lbb.lv/page25.juse?menu\_\_id =10 Lisitsyn, Nikita E., Sergei F. Sutyrin, Olga Y. Trofimenko and Irina Vorobieva 2005. Outward internationalisation of Russian leading telecom companies. Turun Kauppakorkeakoulu Turku School of Economics and Business Ad- ministration. Electronic Publications of Pan-European Institute. No. 1. Lithuanian Development Agency (web). Top foreign investors in Lithuania 2002. Lithuanian Development Agency. http://www.lda.lt/invest.bic.topforeigninv estors.html
- Liuhto, Kari, and Jari Jumpponen 2003. The Russian eagle has landed abroad. Evidence concerning the foreign opera- tions of Russia's 100 biggest exporters and banks. Lappeenranta University of Technology, Department of Industrial Engineering and Management, Research Group for Russian and East European Business, Finland. No. 141.
- Liuhto, Kari, 2002. Russian oil and gas: a source of integration. Research Re- port, Lappeenranta University of Tech- nology, Lappeenranta. No. 131.
- Lukoil 2005. Lukoil annual report 2004. Lukoil, Moscow.
- Lukoil Baltija (web). Lukoil Baltija website. http://www.Lukoil.lt/ru/stations
- Lukoil Baltija Group (web). Website of Lukoil Baltija Group. http://www.Lukoil.lt/en/about/group
- Lukoil Baltija R (web1). Website of Lukoil Baltija R. http://www.Lukoil.lv/index.php?&378
- Lukoil Baltija R (web2). Website of Lukoil Baltija R. http://www.Lukoil.lv/index.php?&374
- Lukoil Bulgaria (web). Lukoil Bulgaria website. http://www.Lukoil.bg/e/1\_facts.asp Lukoil Eesti (web). Lukoil Eesti website. http://www.Lukoil.ee/rus/index.php?id= 111 Lukoil Press Release 1999. Lukoil plans to bid for the Bulgarian state company Petrol AD. Lukoil Press Release. Febru- ary 18. http://www.Lukoil.com/press.asp?div\_id =1&id=419
- Lukoil Press Release 2004a. Lukoil in- creases its interest in the share capital of Bourgas Refinery. Lukoil Press Re- lease. February 13. http://www.Lukoil.com/press.asp?div\_id =1&id=2309
- Lukoil Press Release 2004b. Lukoil puts its modernized Romanian oil refinery into operation. Lukoil Press Release. October 28. http://www.Lukoil.com/press.asp?div\_id =1&id=2283
- Lukoil Press Release 2005a. Lukoil rasshiryayet set AZS v Vengrii. Lukoil Press Release. March 21. http://www.Lukoil.ru/press.asp?div\_id=1 &id=709&year=2005
- Lukoil Press Release 2005b. Lukoil and oil industry of Serbia intend to create a joint venture. Lukoil Press Release. June 30. http://www.Lukoil.com/press.asp?div\_id =1&id=2366&year=2005
- Lukoil Romania (web). Lukoil Romania's website. http://www.Lukoil.ro/despre/LUKOILRo mania.php Lukoil (web). Lukoil website. http://www.Lukoil.com/static.asp?id=58
- Máté, T. Gyula, 2005. Vörös benzin- veszély (Red petrol danger). Magyar Hírlap. March 20. http://www.magyarhirlap.hu/cikk.php?ci kk=92063
- Mechel 2004. Mechel Prospectus. October 29. http://www.mechel.ru/media/for\_investo rs/47827ACL.pdf Mechel (web). Mechel's website. http://www.mechel.ru/about/production _capacity/index.wbp Menedzsment Fórum 2005. Kiárusítja en- ergiaipari vállalatait Bulgária (Bulgaria sells off its energy firms). Menedzs- ment Fórum. October 27. http://www.mfor.hu/cikk.php?article=23 065&pat=3
- Mihailescu, Andrea R. 2005. UPI Energy Watch. The Washington Times. April 25. http://washingtontimes.com/upi- breaking/20050425-013421-3857r.htm Napi Online 2002a. A MOL is ott van az INA kérői között (MOL among INA suit- ors). Napi Online. June 14. http://www.napi.hu/default.asp?cCenter =article.asp&place=morecompanynews&n ID=123881
- Napi Online 2002b. Gdanskban nyomul a PKN Orlen-Rotch páros (PKN Orlen- Rotch pair press on in Gdansk). Napi Online. November 11. http://www.napi.hu/default.asp?cCenter =article.asp&nID=140592
- Napi Online 2005. A Shell után a Romgaz is kell a MOL-nak (After Shell, MOL wants Romgaz too). Napi Online. August 2. http://www.napi.hu/default.asp?cCenter =article.asp&placein=hirkereso&nID=256 933 Népszabadság 2004. A MOL bekebelezte a romániai Shellt (MOL absorbs Romanian Shell). Népszabadság. November 24.
- Népszabadság Online 2005. A MOL szer- biai esélyei (MOL's chances in Serbia). Népszabadság Online. August 23. http://www.nol.hu/cikk/374625/ News2biz Lithuania 2005. Snoras tries to throw M&A net on Europe for Rus- sians. News2biz Lithuania No. 194, August 17. http://www.news2biz.com/pdf\_files/Lithu ania_no_194_august_17_2005_english.pdf OMZ 2005. OMZ International Financial Reporting Standards Consolidated Fi- nancial Statements 2004. http://www.omz.ru/media/financial/pres entations/OMZ per cent20GAAP per cent20FS per cent206m per cent202003.pdf Origo 2002a. A PKN tiltakozhat a gdan- ski finomító magánosítása ellen (PKN may protest Gdansk refinery privatiza- tion). Origo. August 23. http://www.origo.hu/uzletinegyed/hirek/ vilaggazdasag/20020823apkn.html Origo 2002b. A Rotch már a PKN Or- lennel akarja a gdanski fimonító rész- vényeit (Rotch wants Gdansk refinery shares with PKN Orlen). Origo. Sep- tember 25. http://www.fototar.origo.hu/uzletinegyed/ hirek/vilaggazdasag/20020925arotch.html Origo 2003. Júniusban döntenek a gdan- ski finomítóról (June decision on Gdansk refinery). Origo. June 12. http://195.228.240.145/uzletinegyed/hire k/vallalatihirek/20030612juniusban.html Origo 2004a. Eredményes volt az orosz gázcsap elzárása (Russian gas tap clo- sure succeeds). Origo. February 19. http://www.origo.hu/uzletinegyed/hirek/ vilaggaz- dasag/20040219eredmenyes.html Origo 2004b. Orosz világcégé lehet a diósgyőri vasmű (Diósgyőr Ironworks may go to Russian world firm). Origo. April 19. http://www.origo.hu/uzletinegyed/hirek/ vallalatihirek/20040419orosz.html
- Origo (2004c) Az oroszoknak sem kell a diósgyőri vasmű (Russian don't want Diósgyőr Ironworks either). Origo. May 6. http://www.origo.hu/uzletinegyed/hirek/ vallalatihi- rek/20040506azoroszoknak.html Overgas (web). Overgas website. http://www.overgas.bg/Page.jsp?languag e=En&unid=6E4AF28A08694765C2256E5 B004F97F4
- Pelto, Elina, Peeter Vahtra and Kari Liuhto 2003. Cyp-Rus investment flows to Central and Eastern Europe -Rus- sia's direct and indirect investments via Cyprus to CEE. Electronic Publications of Pan-European Institute. Turun Kauppakorkeakoulu Turku School of Economics and Business Administration. No. 2. Petrol (web). Petrol AD website. http://www.petrol.bg/index.php?p=comp any&language=en
- Petrom 2005. Petrom -Facts and Figures 2005. In: Petrom's website. http://www.petrom.ro/engleza/noutatiinvesti tori/Facts_and_Figures per cent20en.pdf Petrom (web). Petrom SA website. http://www.petrom.ro/engleza/en\_despr e_noi.htm
- Plunkert, Patricia A., 2005. Aluminium - 2002. In: U.S. Geological Survey Min- erals Yearbook--2002. U.S. Depart- ment of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, Virginia. http://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/c ommodity/aluminum/alumimyb02r.pdf Politikafórum 2004. Szlovákia: privati- zációs viták (Slovakia: privatization debates). Politikafórum. October 2. http://www.politikaforum.hu/index.phtm l?oldaltyp=hir&ccid=10042995 Portfolio.hu 2005a. Több száz millió dolláros olajprivatizáció a régióban (Several hundred million dollar oil pri- vatization in region). Portfolio.hu. Janu- ary 27. http://www.portfolio.hu/cikkek.tdp?k=2 &i=50304
- Portfolio.hu 2005b. Tovább terjeszkedik a Lukoil Kelet-Európában (Lukoil expands further in Eastern Europe). Portfolio.hu. June 14. http://www.portfolio.hu/cikkek.tdp?k=2 &i=55246
- Portfolio.hu 2005c. BorsodChemet és MOL- t venne Rahimkulov (Rakhimkulov wants to buy BorsodChem and MOL). Portfolio.hu. September 30. http://www.portfolio.hu/cikkek.tdp?h=3 &k=2&i=59432
- Portfolio.hu 2005d. Tovább erősítene a Lukoil a régióban (Lukoil wants to strengthen further in region). Portfo- lio.hu. October 5. http://www.portfolio.hu/cikkek.tdp?cChe ck=1&k=2&i=59630
- PR Newswire News Release 2001. Roma- nian alumina refinery to suspend op- erations. PR Newswire's News Release. November 22. http://www.prnewswire.co.uk/cgi/news/ release?id=77121
- Presidential Decision 2004. Decision No. 338 of 31.12.2004 concerning the State aid granted to S.C. CSR SA Resita. http://www.competition.ro/pdf/en/decizi i/2004/338.pdf PrimOnline 2005. Megütközés Belgrádban: Orosz cégé a szerb Mobtel többségi tulajdona (Clash in Belgrade. Serbian Mobtel majority ownership for Russian firm). PrimOnline. March 7. http://hirek.prim.hu/cikk/44880/?sr=ag hirkereso PwC 2004. Central & Eastern European Mergers & Acquisitions Survey 2003. PricewaterhouseCoopers. http://www.pwc.com/hu/eng/ins- sol/survey- rep/mandace2000/M&A_2003.pdf PwC 2005. Central & Eastern European Mergers & Acquisitions Survey 2004. PricewaterhouseCoopers.
- Ramusovic, Aida, 2004. Montenegro: My Beautiful Launderette? Transitions Online. November 1. http://www.ciaonet.org/pbei/tol/tol\_200
- /oct26-nov1/oct26-nov1h.html. Randburg.com (web). Lukoil Baltija. In: Randburg.com. http://www.randburg.com/li/Lukoil.html Reuters 2004. Romanian gas firms draw five international bidders Reuters. March 15. http://biz.yahoo.com/rm/040315/energy _romania_gas_1.html RIA Novosti 2005. Basic Element buys 65 per cent of Montenegrin aluminum plant. RIA Novosti. July 28. http://en.rian.ru/business/20050728/40 992773.html
- Rubanov, Ivan, 2003. Victims of world competition. Gateway to Russia. May 23. http://www.gateway2russia.com/st/art\_ 79117.php RusAl (web). RusAl's website http://www.rusal.com/press/presentation/ RusTrubProm 2004. TMK kupila za odin evro zavod v Ruminii. Rustrubprom. February 13. http://rustrubprom.ru/view.php/D493\_0 _3_0_C/ Rybkin, Ivan 1995. Tri dokhodniye chasti byudzheta. Ekonomika i Zhizn. No. 14. p. 1. RZD Partner Business Magazine 2004. Primorsk oil terminal to hurt all Baltic ports. RZD Partner Business Magazine. October 12. http://eng.rzd-partner.ru/news/index.php ?action=view&st=1097569982&id=15
- SARIO (web). Website of Slovak Investment and Trade Development Agency. http://www.sario.sk/index.php?idd=174 &typ=2&now=FOREIGN_DIRECT_INVEST MENTS_ACC SIEPA (web1). FDI inflow in 2001 in Serbia and Montenegro. In: Website of Ser- bian Investment and Export Promotion Agency. http://www.emb-serbia-montenegro. org.cn/business/foreign_investment_issue s/fdi_inflow_in_2001_in_serbia_and_mon tenegro.htm SIEPA (web2). Foreign Investment Statistics 2002-2004. In: Website of Serbian In- vestment and Export Promotion Agency. http://www.siepa.sr.gov.yu/investment/in vestor_guide/fdi.htm Snoras Bank (web). Snoras Bank's web- site. http://wwwen.snoras.com/about/history/
- Socor, Vladimir, 2003. Have oil, won't let it travel via Latvia. Wall Street Journal Europe. February 2.
- Sofia Municipality 2004. Reduction of Greenhouse Gases by Gasification of Sofia Municipality. JI Project Design Document. Sofia. April. www.senter.nl/sites/erupt/con- tents/i001556/pdd_overgas-final.pdf SofiaEcho.com 2003. Privatisation -The current state of play. SofiaEcho.com. February 6. http://www.sofiaecho.com/article/privati sation---the-current-state-of- play/id_6468/catid_29
- SofiaEcho.com 2004. Bulgaria's champion taxpayers. SofiaEcho.com. February 26. http://www.sofiaecho.com/article/bulgar ias-champion- taxpayers/id_8902/catid_23
- Sokolov, Sergei, 1991. Sovyetskiy kapital za rubezhom. Ekonomika i Zhizn. No. 41. p. 7.
- Spacecom (web). Spacecom website. http://www.spacecom.ee/firmast\_rus.php
- Staneva, Milena, 2002. Russia's new strategy for control over Eastern Europe. CSIS Prospectus 3:3. http://www.csis.org/pubs/prospectus/02 fall_staneva.htm
- Szalai, Zoltán, 2002. Beszáll a Lukoil (Lukoil contributes). Népszabadság. July 20. Szeghalmi, Örs, 2001. Meghatározatlan ideig bezárják a timföldgyárat (Alu- mina plant closes for uncertain pe- riod). Bihari Napló. November. http://www.hhrf.org/biharinaplo/01nov/ bn11123.htm The Baltic Course 2005. Russia's Euro- chem enters Lithuania. The Baltic Course. No. 18, Summer. http://www.tozsdeforum.hu/index2.phtm l?menu=4&submenu=onearticle&news_id =340807
- Tőzsdefórum 2005. Be akarják perelni a Lukoil-t (They want to sue Lukoil).
- Tőzsdefórum, March 9. http://www.tozsdeforum.hu/index2.phtm l?menu=17&submenu=onearticle&news_i
- U.S. Commercial Service (web). Serbia and Montenegro Investment Climate. In: Website of the U.S. Commercial Ser- vice. http://www.buyusa.gov/yugoslavia/en/7 1.html Új Szó 2003. A MOL-é lehet a horvát INA (Croatian INA may be MOL's). Új Szó. July 15. http://www.ujszo.sk/clanok.asp?vyd=20 030715&cl=63708
- UKMIN 2004. Ministry of Economy of the Republic of Lithuania -Annual Report 2003. http://www.ukmin.lt/ukmin\_ataskaita\_2 003/en/ukmin_energetika.html UKMIN 2005. Ministry of Economy of the Republic of Lithuania -Annual Report 2004. http://www.ukmin.lt/ukmin\_ataskaita\_2 004/32.html, http://www.ukmin.lt/ukmin\_ataskaita\_2 004/34.html UNCTAD 2005. Case study on outward foreign direct investment by Russian enterprises. United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (TD/B/COM.3/EM.26/2/Add.4), No- vember 2. UNCTAD cross-border M&A database. UNCTAD FDI Database Update. http://stats.unctad.org/fdi/eng/ReportFol ders/Rfview/Explorerp.asp?CS_referer= UNCTAD FDI database. Unipetrol (web). Unipetrol website. http://www.unipetrol.cz/html/index.php ?s1=1&s2=5&s3=1&lng=2
- UVZ & AVR (web) UVZ & AVR PLC's website. http://www.uvzavr.com/?m=1
- Vahtra, Peeter, and Kari Liuhto 2004a. Expansion or exodus? -Foreign opera- tions of the Russia's largest corpora- tions. Electronic Publications of Pan- European Institute. Turun Kauppa- korkeakoulu Turku School of Econom- ics and Business Administration, Turku. No. 8.
- Vahtra, Peeter, and Kari Liuhto 2004b. Russian corporations abroad -seeking profits, leverage or refuge? Conference paper 'New Europe 2020. Visions and Strategies for Wider Europe'. Turku School of Economics and Business Ad- ministration, Turku. August 27-8. http://www.tukkk.fi/pei/NewEurope/Sess ionA1/Vahtra_Liuhto.pdf
- Vatahov, Ivan 2002. TCP tobacco bid rises to top. SofiaEcho.com. July 25. http://www.sofiaecho.com/article/tcp- tobacco-bid-rises-to-top/id_4974/catid_5
- Vedomosti 2004. TMK acquired another plant In: Russian Institute of Directors website. Article based on Vedomosti. February 13. http://ricd.ru/news.php?news\_id=6426&l =en Ventspils Nafta (web). About Ventspils Nafta. In: Ventspils Nafta website. http://www.vnafta.lv/vnafta/info/?cid=1
- Világgazdaság 2005a. Romba döntheti az eurócsatlakozási terveket Oroszország (Russia may wreck Euro-accession plans). Világgazdaság. June 27. http://vg.hu/index3.php?app=cikk&datu m=2005-07-27&d=2005-07- 27&c=146&fr=hk Világgazdaság 2005b. Eladják a legnagyobb román áramszolgáltatót (Biggest Romanian power provider sold). Világgazdaság. July 29.
- Voica, Sorina (n.d.). Success must con- quer prejudices. Invest Romania. http://www.investromania.ro/publication /print_art.php?pid=20&aid=24&cap=SU
- RVEY Weiner, Csaba, 2005. Russian investments in Hungary. Ms.
- Wetzel, Hayden, 2004. Latvia Country Commercial Guide FY 2003. http://strategis.ic.gc.ca/epic/internet/ini mr-ri.nsf/en/gr112755e.html WIR 2001. World Investment Report 2001. Promoting Linkages. New York/Geneva: UNCTAD. WIR 2002. World Investment Report 2002. Transnational corporations and export competitiveness. New York/Geneva: UNCTAD. WIR 2003. World Investment Report 2003. FDI policies for development: na- tional and international perspectives. New York/Geneva: UNCTAD.
- WIR 2004. World Investment Report 2004. The shift towards services. New York/Geneva: UNCTAD.
- WIR 2005. World Investment Report 2005. Transnational corporations and the internationalization of R&D. New York/Geneva: UNCTAD.
- Wisniewski, Anna, 2004. Olajgate Lengye- lországban (Oil-gate in Poland).
- FigyelőNet. December 4. http://figyeloplusz.fn.hu/cikk.php?id=4& cid=90701
- Yambaeva, Renata, 2004. The locomotive of Severstaltrans economics. Russian machinists buy Latvian factory. Kom- mersant. August 6. http://www.kommersant.com/page.asp?i dr=1&id=495187 YUKOS (web). YUKOS' Marketing Activities. In: YUKOS website. http://www.yukos.com/RM/Marketing.a sp Zashev, Peter, 2004. Russian investments in Lithuania -politics, business, corpo- rate culture. Electronic Publications of Pan-European Institute. Turun Kauppa- korkeakoulu Turku School of Econom- ics and Business Administration. No.
- Zaslavsky, Alexander, 2003. Kremlin sup- port of Transneft hinders private Rus- sian pipeline projects. Oil and Gas Journal. 10, 31-4. ZGG 2005. Group financial statements (IFRS) 2004 of ZGG-Zarubezhgaz- Erdgashandel-Gesellschaft mbH (ZGG).