Mapping the Conceptual World of the Student Writer (original) (raw)
Related papers
Molinari, J. (2022). What makes writing academic: Rethinking theory for practice. Bloomsbury
Discourse and Writing/Rédactologie, 2022
What Makes Writing Academic: Rethinking Theory for Practice (Molinari, 2022) joins a long-standing debate about the genre of academic writing—and what it is that makes it academic. The book opens with a useful overview provided in the “Foreword” by Chrissie Boughey which introduces the key issues that will follow and sets the tone for the reader. The book itself explores the knowledge work that academic writing traditionally accomplishes whilst also exploring the liberatory potential of what academic writing could be. Molinari recognises that the development of a genre of academic writing involved the loss of the oral and visual from academic culture and hence problematizes the notion of access and widening access to higher education. If writing itself remains unchallenged and untransformed then access de facto means indoctrination into exclusionary, reified unchallengeable forms rather than making space for new people, new voices, and new ontologies via new forms.
‘Academic literacies’: sustaining a critical space on writing in academia
Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education, 2019
In this paper, I briefly track the emergence and foci of academic literacies as a field of inquiry, summarising its contributions to understandings about writing and meaning making in academia. Writing from my specific geohistorical location in the UK, I foreground the importance of early key works that encapsulated concerns about deficit orientations to students’ language and literacy practices (e.g. Ivanič, 1998; Lea and Street,1998). I also underline the transnational dimension to the development of academic literacies which has helped drive forward intellectual debates about the relationship between academic language and literacy practices, and participation in academia. I argue that academic literacies provides an important space for critically exploring what are often taken-for-granted assumptions about the nature and value of academic writing conventions, and the ways these (both assumptions and conventions) impact on opportunities for participation in knowledge making. This ...
Improving student writing in Higher Education: putting literacy studies to work
This article builds on research into academic writing and student literacy, arguing that a focus on epistemology and institutional context should inform the teaching of writing in higher education. It explores the experience of UK undergraduate students of English, including those studying joint honours, to demonstrate their negotiation of complex and conflicting institutional and literacy practices. The article suggests that the epistemology of humanities and social science subjects could be made more explicit to students; and proposes pedagogy to demystify the nature of academic writing and to develop the collaborative writing skills appropriate to a literate and critical society.
Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 2012
Three writing development initiatives carried out at King's College London UK are discussed in this article to illustrate the need to draw on different theoretical models to create effective methods of teaching academic writing. The sequence of initiatives resembles a journey: the destination is to develop academic writing programmes suitable for students from all backgrounds; the point of departure was the dominant institutional provision of extra-curricular 'study skills' courses. The Academic Literacies model subsequently offered useful guidance for moving away from this provision towards disciplineembedded approaches. However, Academic Literacies could not easily be applied to instructional practice, because its preference for issues such as identity, power relations and institutional practices over text seemed to be at conflict with students' preferences. This finding led to a change in direction towards a genre-based approach to writing instruction. It is argued that the analysis of discipline-specific texts is the best starting point for teaching and learning of academic writing, and that students will be more willing to take a critical perspective when they are able to understand and control disciplinary discourses.
Journal of Academic Writing, 2012
High-achieving students are not often the focus of studies in academic transition. In the UK, the driver has frequently been the widening participation and retention agendas, resulting in an emphasis on supporting the 'non-traditional' student. This exploratory case study based in the Faculty of Modern and Medieval Languages at Cambridge University took academic writing as one aspect of transition and compared two transition points for undergraduate students of Modern Foreign Languages (MFL): from school or college into the first year and then into the year abroad as students adapt to expectations for dissertation writing. In a context where weekly tutorials arguably offer the ultimate space for development of student writing, the study unpacks students' interpretations of institutional, disciplinary, tutor and genre-based expectations. The study drew on theories of academic literacies ) by viewing writing as socially constructed and 'literacy' as dependent on disciplinary context. Findings revealed the significance of the multi-disciplinary nature of the MFL course to students' ability to adapt to writing at university. It is suggested that a focus on the end product rather than the writing process might hinder the students' ability to adapt to new expectations and make the most of their tutorial time.
2014
This thesis shifts the traditional emphasis around academic writing and writing development from students’ shortcomings as writers to an exploration of an under-researched aspect of the debate, namely lecturers’ perspectives of academic writing (their own and students). It draws on a New Literacy Studies (NLS) approach that locates academic writing and writing development in higher education, within a critical and situated theory of practice. The research is located within a postmodern, post-structural paradigm and involves a deliberate deconstruction of methodologies involved in traditional qualitative research (Stronach and MacLure, 1997). Foucault’s concept of ‘disciplinary power’, Lather’s suspicion of scientism (1986) and the work of feminist theorists like Pillow (2000), and Richardson (1997) are used to challenge traditional notions around qualitative research. Post-qualitative research methods and ideas (St. Pierre, 2011) are used to deterritorialise and reterritorialise tra...
Invited book review of "Genres across the Disciplines: Student Writing in Higher Education"
& Genres Across the Disciplines: Student Writing in Higher Education by Hilary Nesi and Sheena Gardner is an ambitious descriptive and comparative 4-year study of academic writing across more than 30 disciplines in higher education in the United Kingdom, drawing on the British Academic Written English (BAWE) corpus. As the authors note, "there is considerable confusion amongst students and writing instructors regarding the kinds of writing students are required to produce across disciplines and levels of study" (p. 3). One of the main achievements of this book is that it appeals to practitioners interested in providing greater academic writing support to their students by learning more about what they are expected to accomplish through their writing for different disciplines, as well as to researchers engaged in analyzing academic discourse and exploring how disciplinary social functions and practices shape writing expectations and demands.
Students’ navigation of the uncharted territories of academic writing
Africa Education Review, 2012
Many students enter tertiary education unfamiliar with the 'norms and conventions' of their disciplines. Research into academic literacies has shown that in order to succeed in their studies, students are expected to conform to these norms and conventions, which are often unrecognized or seen as 'common sense' by lecturers. Students have to develop their own 'map' of their programme's expectations in order to make sense of the seemingly mysterious practices they are expected to take on. This study, undertaken at a University of Technology in South Africa, details students' perceptions of their writing difficulties and their attempts to navigate their way through various writing tasks. The findings reveal that students experience a range of difficulties and that the students often feel unsupported in their travails with academic writing. Research Method This research study was located in the Durban University of Technology (DUT) 1 .