A ritual civil execution": public shaming meetings in the post-Stalin Soviet Union (original) (raw)
The resurgence of public shaming campaigns in modern societies has important antecedents in the relatively recent past. The paper addresses the practice of prorabotka, a ritual of public shaming that took place in schools, universities and workplaces in the Soviet Union. Prorabotka, whose genealogy can be traced to early post-revolutionary years, was aimed at the reinforcement of social norms challenged by political and moral deviance. Public shaming was applied to a wide range of behaviours, including ideological and moral deviations such as public drunkenness, marital infidelity by party members, planned emigration to Israel, etc. The paper applies a theoretical framework that builds on Durkheimian and neo-Durkheimian approaches to ritual, Garfinkel’s outline of the theory of public degradation ceremonies, and Zizek’s account of split law. It shows that, in addition to an official script, the meetings had a supplementary script that unleashed a jouissance of punitiveness but also ...
Sign up for access to the world's latest research.
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Related papers
Politinformation as a ritual practice of the soviet life
This research work is aimed at showing politinformation as a ritual practice providing the soviet reality construction within the framework of ideological pressure reduction in the late soviet period. The notion of ritual will and determined and distinguished from such notions as ceremony, etiquette, rite and custom, traditionally tied with the reproducing stereotype activity. The notion of a ritual and the research concept settled by it will be the basis to analyze recollections about politinformation in the late soviet period. The mechanism of sovietness's construction on both pragmatic and discourse levels will also be revealed. (Sovietness is a special way of life with appropriate ideological features and models of behavior).The basis of succession of the soviet rituality with the contemporary discursive and ritual practice will be revealed in the conclusion of the research work.
The early stages of legal purges in Soviet Russia (1941-1945)
Cahiers du monde russe 49, no.2, Sortie de guerre, L'URSS au lendemain de la Grande Guerre patriotique, 2008
European postwar “legal purges” have been largely investigated by scholars who explored their different forms, evolution through time, perception by their various protagonists, and meaning.
Drawing on the writings of criminologists and psychiatrists in the late imperial and early Soviet periods, the article argues that Soviet biopsychological constructions of the socially deviant have their origins in the efforts of tsarist liberals to identify and contain the crime and social disorder that accompanied Russia's modernization. While the historiography has traditionally portrayed the Bolshevik Revolution as a tragic overthrow of liberal ideas and values, the article points to important continuities that span the 1917 divide. In the late imperial period, the human sciences began to categorize individuals who posed a biopsychological threat, a "social danger," to the social order. In the wake of the revolution, these ideas became radicalized under the impact of Soviet Marxism to generate indictments of entire social groups and classes.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.