Elmer G. Beamer and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants: The Pursuit of a Cognitive Standard for the Accounting Profession (original) (raw)
Related papers
The history of the decline and fall of the American accounting profession
International journal of economics and accounting, 2013
There have been many articles and books published on the development of accounting and the accounting profession in the U.S., both historically and sociologically. Some have critically examined actions taken by the AICPA, and others that have studied the effects of legislation on the accounting profession such as the Sixteenth Amendment or the creation of the PCAOB. Still others have observed the decline in the American accounting profession's status and image as a result of various failures such as Enron. This is the first to combine systematically a sociological analysis of the accounting profession in the U.S. with the historical development of the profession's power and status, and the subsequent loss of its power and status. A sociological analysis of the American accounting profession strongly suggests that it is no longer a profession as conceived by sociologists.
A Reexamination of the Development of the Accounting Profession - Critical Events from 1912–1940
Accounting Historians Journal
This study reexamines the accounting profession's response to opportunities and incentives given it during three unique periods in its history to foster reliable accounting, reporting and auditing practices. By profession, we mean the auditors of publicly held companies as represented by the American Institute of Accountants and its predecessor, the American Association of Public Accountants (AAPA). We use two models of professionalism, the Functionalist and the Conflict models, to interpret the profession's response to these events. We find that both self interest and the public interest may have motivated many of the actions taken. These motivations are not, however, mutually exclusive and both may be used to interpret the same behavior.
Preparing an Accounting Professional: The Articles of Clerkship (1892–1897) of George Oliver May
The Accounting historians journal, 2014
George O. May, one of, if not 'the' leading spokesman for the American Institute of CPAs for most of his lifetime, was the product of British education and an articled clerkship. This paper reviews the features and information about May's clerkship (indentureship) articles, including aspects of what is now called professional responsibility. Also mentioned are selected highlights and sources related to his career in public accounting, including his 'cameo' role at the l904 World Congress of Accountants in St. Louis where he participated with prominent leaders of the emerging United States CPA community, including Staub, Sterrett, Montgomery, and Sells, as well as his countrymen Pixley and Dickinson [Official Record, p. 164]. This study of George O. May's preparation provides details about a relatively unnoticed chapter in the career of an individual who was among the first group of inductees, in l950, along with William A. Paton and Robert H. Montgomery, to the Accounting Hall of Fame at The Ohio State University. Additionally, May's clerkship requirements are indicative of the role of professional responsibility in the decade before the turn of the twentieth century.
Myth and Technology in the American Accounting Profession
Journal of Management Studies, 1982
The American accounting profession attempts to provide the public with efficient and effective financial reports; but to succeed, it must satisfy an environment of diverse, often conflicting, institutions. This article critically interprets the profession's development, arguing that it displays an interplay of myth and technology. This interplay generates structural flaws in the profession as well as a bias against reform.
Traditional accountants and business professionals: Portraying the accounting profession after Enron
Accounting, Organizations and Society, 2010
going research to a wider audience and to facilitate intellectual exchange and debate. The papers have been through a refereeing process and will subsequently be published in a revised form. Requests for permission to reproduce any article or part of the Working Paper should be sent to the publisher of this series. The School of Management, Royal Holloway University of London has over 65 academic staff who are organised into different research groups. Currently research groups include: Accounting, Finance and Economics Strategy and International Business Marketing Technology and Information Management Organisation Studies and Human Resource Management Public Services Management
Revista Contabilidade & Finanças, 2021
This study aims to identify the requirements demanded of accounting practitioners by the market in the second half of the 19th century in the state of Pará. Standing out from the existing literature, this study broadens the understanding of the history of the accounting profession as an occupation, through the use of concepts derived from the sociological theory of professions. The relevance of the topic chosen lies in understanding the impact of the requirements demanded of accounting practitioners on the professionalization process and on the modeling of the limits of the occupational structure. The evidence provides the possibility of strengthening the research in the area of accounting history by demonstrating the difficulty of defining what an “accounting practitioner” was, since the expression covered an infinity of employment situations, the performance of various tasks, and included specialized sub-occupations. The study involves archival research, based on job advertisement...
The Portrayal of Accounting and Accountants Following the Enron Collapse
2007
The dramatic collapse of Enron, among other corporations including WorldCom in the USA, HIH in Australia and Equitable Life Assurance Society in the UK, combined with the demise of Arthur Andersen in the early 2000s, brought professional accountants and the international accounting profession under intense scrutiny. This latest round of financial scandals provides the opportunity to examine how professional accountants, and accounting under duress, are portrayed in popular culture. The paper examines the array of books written on the failures themselves and their implications for corporate governance and the survival of the financial system. Changing public stereotypes of accountants may lead to renegotiation or even termination of the "social contract" between society and key organisations (such as the large international accounting firms). The paper explores how commentators have drawn on the history of accounting to analyse the changing activities of accountants (including the rise of consulting) and to contrast the personalities of "founding fathers" of the US accountancy profession with their early 21 st-century successors. The paper concludes that episodes such as Enron and the public reaction to the role of auditors in corporate collapse may be "negative signals of movement" for the accountancy profession, creating threats to the ongoing professionalisation project. 1 Bougen (1994, p. 320), in his review of humour and the accountant stereotype, also quotes from the famous UK television comedy show Monty Python's Flying Circus broadcast by the BBC on 21 December 1969: "Our experts describe you as an appallingly dull fellow, unimaginative, timid, lacking in initiative, spineless, easily dominated, no sense of humour, tedious company, irrepressibly drab and awful.. And whereas in most professions these would be considerable drawbacks, in chartered accountancy they are a positive boon." (The full text of the "Vocational Guidance Counsellor" sketch from Episode 10 of Monty Python's Flying Circus is available on-line at several locations, including http://orangecow.org/pythonet/sketches/vocation.htm).
Overcoming barriers: Early African-American certified public accountants* 1
Accounting, Organizations and Society, 1994
National 4-1t Council Chevy Chase Al mtract This study challenses the notion that public accounting firms in the United States have provided equality of oplmrmnity. Umi~ing theories of racism and recognizing the importance of hishlishfln 8 hidden histories, it e-omines the early history of African Americans in public accounting Through examinations of the literature and interviews with several of the first African Americam to obtain the CPA, this paper demomumes that African Americans were actively excluded from full participation in the field fur most of 0gs century. L Too I, too, sing America I am the darker brother, They send me to eat in the kitchen When compmy comes, But i m~n, And eat welL And growstrong Tomorrow, Ill be at the table When company comes. 1 The studies cited herein do not make explicit that their analyses focus only on white women, but the content of the articles makes this clear (Hammond & Preston, 1992).
Further tales of the schism: US accounting faculty and practice credentials
Journal of Accounting Education, 2014
Several writers have asserted the existence of a "schism" between accounting practitioners and accounting faculty. This paper attempts to document and chart the trajectory of such a division by observing the extent to which academic accountants possess the essential practice credentials. The absence of such credentials suggests a growing departure in the training and values of the two groups. The results show a considerable decline in the tendency for accounting faculty to hold practice credentials such as the CPA. This trend occurs in most segments of the professoriate, but is more pronounced for the tenure track faculty or doctoral institutions, for more junior faculty and for faculty employed by more prestigious academic organizations.
Abacus, 2017
Nineteenth century US railroads were the first 'big businesses' and had profound influence on society. This paper addresses one source of talent for the early US public accounting profession-railroads. Following the end of the US Civil War (1861-65), industrial expansion was a revolutionary experience, with large trusts appearing in the wake of the railroad's maturing influence on the development of a vast continental economy. Accounting practice also was impacted by railroads. For example, the development of annual reports, income measurement, the standardization of reporting by regulators, developing fixed and variable cost, and throughput concepts for capital intensive business-all were related to the railroads. This paper focuses on a significant link between the emerging public accounting profession and the railroads by examining how an early major US public accounting firm relied upon accounting skill developed within railroads as an important source of talent. Arguably, talent is the most important resource of a professional firm. While it is a commonly held view that the immigration of UK accountants in the late nineteenth century was the source of public accounting talent, this paper provides evidence of a competing explanation-the sourcing of talent from a firm (Haskins & Sells) that continues to the present day as Deloitte. Key leadership and personnel of that time gained their experience while working on the domestic railroads.