Towards an inclusive student partnership: rethinking mentors’ disposition and holistic competency development in near-peer mentoring (original) (raw)
Related papers
Students as Partners in Peer Mentoring: Expectations, Experiences and Emotions
Innovative Higher Education
Increasing emphasis in recent years has been placed on how faculty, staff and students in higher education can be drawn into more collaborative learning relationships through partnership working. The significant challenges in terms of negotiating shifting roles and responsibilities have been well documented. Less attention has been paid to the affective challenges, and particularly the emotional labour involved. This paper focuses on the adoption of a partnership approach to first year peer mentoring and orientation in a large Social Science programme. Peer mentors played a critical role as designers of the programme, as partners delivering the programme, and as co-researchers, offering a unique understanding and insight into aspects of the peer mentor experience that often remain hidden. Our findings draw attention to the need to consider and manage more carefully the impact of students on each other in mentoring relationships but also suggest an opportunity to harness the mentorin...
Researching the Impact of Student Mentoring in the Community
International Journal of Social Work and Human Services Practice, 2013
This research explores the impact of mentoring relationships on student mentors at the University of Central Lancashire (UCLan). More specifically, it looks at student experiences, personal and professional development from mentoring in the community over one academic year. This interpretive, methodological approach incorporated both qualitative and quantitative methods in order to draw comparisons and detailed insight into the interactions of all parties involved in the mentoring programme, including the mentor, the mentee and the community organisation. The findings revealed that mentors receive an 'invisible gift' that is not formally acknowledged. The 'gift' is manifested as key skills for lifelong learning and employability. Also, the findings highlighted that mentoring has a significant impact on the mentee regarding enhancing confidence, self esteem, skill development and engagement in pro-social behavior; thus, identifying 'hard' and 'soft' outcomes from UCLan Students engaging with the community in a mentoring capacity. This research concludes that the mentoring process utilises a 'mentee-centred approach.' A balance of both 'instrumental and 'expressive' processes in order to support, encourage and guide mentees to achieve their full potential.
Peer-to-peer academic mentoring has the potential to contribute to retention and progression goals as programmes benefit mentors, mentees and staff. Although there are necessarily common elements, programmes that include academic mentoring vary in their focus and structure. Each programme must also be deliberately designed to address the unique character of individual institutions and their students. From programmes at two very different institutions-one in a rural town in the United States and one in a major city in the United Kingdom-the approaches to and outcomes from peer mentoring activities are considered and the literature surrounding mentoring models is discussed.
Mentorship in Higher Education
GiLE Journal of Skills Development
Although mentorship in business settings is typical, its emergence as a tool in education started only recently. Consequently, this new opportunity has initiated a discussion about mentorship and its principal elements in an academic context. Aspects like the mentor profile, the relationship built between mentors and mentees, and the scope of mentorship have been constantly explored and debated by researchers in this field. All contributions are invaluable; however, the information on what the authors consider the fundamental elements of mentorship is scattered throughout many sources. This is precisely what we are attempting to do in this article; by presenting insights from a literary review and investigating the principal aspects of a successful mentorship program in Higher Education, we are answering the most fundamental mentorship-related questions – what mentorship involves; what the qualities of the ideal mentor are; what the student-mentor interaction entails; what the role ...
Student Mentor's Ideal Features: Peer Choice
Education and New Developments 2021, 2021
Introduction: A student mentor is someone who shares his or her knowledge with a less experienced colleague in order to help the other developing his or her full academic potential by providing him/ her with the right guidance and support during his learning, social and academic integration processes. Objective: To assess the features higher education students consider to be the most effective characteristics their Student Peer Mentor should possess. Method: A descriptive-exploratory study, with a cross-sectional focus, involving a sample of 306 higher education health students, with a mean age of 21.15 (± 3,540) years. 81.7% of the participants are female. Data collection was achieved using Cunha’s Ideal Mentor Faces Scale (2017) with images adapted from Botas, Gabriel & Welling, (1997/1998). Results: Results show that 61.8% of the students surveyed would like to be student mentors and that most participants (54.2%) look at their ideal mentor as someone who possesses positive featu...
This article focuses on academic development (AD) practitioners' approaches to student mentoring at the residences of a South African university that has instituted mentoring as part of its student support strategy. The article is based on semi-structured interviews with relevant AD practitioners who are responsible for student mentoring in the residences. I draw on the work of Tinto (1975) and Keeling et al (2004) to analyse the functional tensions that exist in the way in which student mentor programmes are conceptualised. My analysis shows that student mentoring has a dual focus, namely academic and psychosocial. I will argue that the AD practitioners conceptualise student mentoring at university residences within this duality. I suggest that mentoring should be conceptualised as an interconnection between the academic and the psychosocial aspects of student learning.
Mentor and mentoring: Negotiating relationships
Mentoring in higher education is a vital component of the professional development of young academics. Mentoring relationships is special in the sense that it is a collaborative partnership in which both parties work towards common goals in terms of professional and personal development. An action research approach is followed since we consider it the most appropriate research design when it comes to professional development. In this article two sets of data are presented, namely a quantitative set on the learning style preference of all participants and a qualitative set consisting of narratives and discussed against the backdrop of literature. The narrative of Pam, an individual I as first author mentored for a period of time, is offered as well as my own experiences while being mentored by Jane and Pieter and mentoring Pam. The main themes that seem to permeate the narratives are those of trust, openness to professional learning, communication, negotiation and equal partnerships as they all reflect within the mirror of our own thinking preferences. The new concept of whole brain mentoring is constructed since we implemented mentoring in tandem with the principles of whole brain learning. Keywords: Mentoring, whole brain learning, learning styles, professional development of academic staff, professional learning, action research, narratives