The Molnár Debate of 1950: Hungarian Communist Historical Politics and the Problem of the Soviet Model (original) (raw)
2017, East Central Europe
By tracing the developments that led to a historical debate in 1950, this article questions some assumptions concerning the Stalinization of Hungarian history writing, in particular the notion of a predetermined continuity between the national-communist line followed by Hungarian communists before and after 1949. Contrary to the understanding of the Sovietization of historiography in Hungary as a straightforward process, guided by a firmly-established ideological line, this article shows that the period between early 1949 and 1950 was characterized by a certain level of uncertainty, caused, on the one hand, by the ideological and institutional changes brought about by Sovietization, and, on the other, by a temporary lack of firm interpretative guidance from the Party leadership. A closer look into the efforts to elaborate a new periodization of Hungarian history reveals not only the existence of competing Marxist interpretations (a “national” state-oriented and an “internationalist”...
Related papers
The Squaring of the Circle: The Reinvention of Hungarian History by the Communist Party in 1952
Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism, 2008
This article analyses a document, published by the Hungarian Academy of Science as a gift for the dictator Mátyás Rákosi's sixtieth birthday in 1952. The document tries to legitimate governance by the Communist Party, which emerged victorious from the political struggles in the post-war period (1945–1949). The Party had no tradition of public political life and its politics and ‘collective identity’ lacked national roots. For this reason, professional historians with leading positions in the Communist Party used raw material from Hungarian history in its attempt to achieve congruent communist and national traditions. They therefore introduced new heroes to the pantheon and removed others. This new narrative justified the elimination of potential enemies and promised a bright future for the nation. The article highlights the technique of realigning temporal references along a theoretical guideline, which is derived from a specific worldview, and examines the extent to which a new narrative can be successful when forced temporal references and the administrative creation of the past is too obvious. This article assumes that only closed societies enable such a ‘squaring of the circle’.
Revisiting Hungarian Stalinism
In Tismaneanu, Vladimir (ed.), Stalinism Revisited The Establishment of Communist Regimes in East-Central Europe. Budapest, 2009, CEU Press, 231-254. Paper begins by clarifying the meaning of two concepts in the context of this study: of Stalinism, and of Hungarian Stalinism. Then comes a word on three periods in the historiography of Hungarian Stalinism. The third part sets out to pinpoint the main historical problems raised by Hungarian Stalinism.
Klimo1956_1942_HungarianHistoricalReview2016 (1).pdf
Two acts of mass violence that occurred during World War II have strained relations between Hungarians and Serbs for decades: the murder of several thousand civilians in Novi Sad (Újvidék) and the surrounding villages in January 1942, committed by the Hungarian army and gendarmerie, and Tito’s partisan army’s mass killings and incarceration of tens of thousands civilians, most of them Hungarians, at the end of the War. This was particularly the case when the Communist regimes in Hungary and Yugoslavia based the legitimation of their authority on anti-Fascist narratives and interpretations of the war, which stood in ever starker contrast to everyday realities. When Kádár began to renew the Anti-Fascist narrative and develop a (moderate) critique of Stalinism in the 1960s, the remembrance of the 1942massacre changed. In Yugoslavia, the weakening of the central government in the 1960s contributed to a local re-appropriation of the memory of 1942, while the 1944 killings remained a strict taboo until 1989.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.