Public Philology: Text Criticism and the Sectarianization of Hinduism (original) (raw)
Related papers
A New Public Theology: Sanskrit and Society in Seventeenth-century South India
This dissertation, entitled A New Public Theology: Sanskrit and Society in Seventeenth-century South India, examines the rise of Hindu sectarianism as the defining feature of public religious culture in south India. I document for the first time the origins of the Smārta-Śaiva community of the Tamil region, which first emerged as a distinct religious tradition during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Beginning in this period, Sanskrit public intellectuals forged an unprecedented alliance with new religious institutions, including monasteries and temple complexes, fundamentally transforming the shape of public religious culture in south India. In particular, I demonstrate that the public Śaiva religiosity of contemporary Tamil Nadu owes its shape to the theological enterprises of seventeenth century intellectuals, whose polemical encounters defined the boundaries, both conceptual and institutional, between competing sectarian traditions.
Religion and the Public Sphere in Premodern India
When in 1962 Habermas formulated his theory of the public sphere as " a society engaged in critical debate " he sought to describe something he felt was unique to the modern liberal democratic Western world. Yet the creation of discursive spheres where people across lines of social difference debate questions of the common good, mutual interest, and forms of equality long predates the modern era and flourished well outside the " Western " world. This essay adapts Habermas' influential concept to highlight the emergence of a nascent public sphere at the earliest layers of Marathi literary creation in 13th century India. At this inaugural stage of a regional language's full shift to writing, we see traces of a debate in the language of everyday life that struggled over the ethics of social difference, a public deliberation that might presage key aspects of Indian modernity and democracy today.
Early Hindu Sectarian Printed Books: An Analysis of a Tamil Library
Philological Encounters, 2021
On a trip to South India in the early 1850s, the German missionary Karl Graul collected a library of Tamil books. His library contains some of the first books that Tamils edited and published for Tamil audiences. This article analyses the Shaiva and Vaishnava works in this collection, arguing that in this early period of Tamil publishing, Tamil Hindus turned to print in part to counter Christian evangelisation. The article focuses on Tamil Shaiva editors, who often cooperated across sectarian lines in order to produce corpora of sectarian books that would counter the huge number of Christian printed books circulating at the time.
Public Space, Public Canon: Situating religion at the dawn of modernity in South India
What is 'early modern' about religion in South India? In theorizing early modernity in South Asia, the category of religion has been viewed with scepticism, perhaps to avoid painting India as the exotic 'Other' that failed to modernize in the eyes of Western social theory. And yet, Western narratives, drawn from secularization theory, fail to do justice to our historical archive. As a vehicle for approaching the experience of religion in early modern South India, this article invokes the category of space as a medium for the publicization and contestation of meaning across diverse language, caste, and religious publics. In the process, it excavates the codification of the 'Sacred Games of´Siva' as public religious canon of the city of Madurai, exemplifying the distinctive role played by religion in public space in early modern South India.
Patterns in Religious thought in early south India: A study of Classical Tamil Texts
1988
This thesis is an analytic study of specific patterns of religious thought in early south India as found in the earliest extant literary texts in Tamil, one of the classical languages of India and one of the oldest living languages of the world. commonly known in the Tamil tradition as the cankaa literature, this corpus of poetry is generally assigned to the early centuries of the Comaon Era, and is thought of as constituting the classical heritage of Taail culture. There has not been a major attempt to investigate the importance of this reaarkable body of literature to the development of religious thought in south India, a region which is widely acknowledged as the birth place of a number of religious movements including the great devotional aovement of the early medieval tiaes, called the bhaktl religion. The reluctance on the part of historians of Indian religious thought to take up the study of classical Tamil texts was partly due to a perception that the classical Tamil texts ...
It is commonly held that one of the distinguishing features of modern Hinduism is its all-inclusive tolerance and comprehensive openness for religious plurality. However, this universalism contrasts in important ways with the traditional inclusivism found in the writings of classical and medieval Indian brahmanical thinkers. In this paper, I wish to reflect on the inherent complexity and modalities of religious inclusivism in the early modern period. How was inclusivism theoretically construed and defended by Sanskrit intellectuals of this period? How do inclusivist models relate to broader concepts of identity, tradition and scriptures? I will approach these questions mainly with reference to the work of Appaya Dīkṣita, one of the foremost Sanskrit scholars of 16th-century South India. I will focus on a series of arguments he presents in his Śivārkamaṇidīpikā, his magnum opus of Śivādvaita Vedānta, in connection with his rejection of the Pāñcarātra tradition and his take on the authority of Śaivāgamas.
2013. Reorienting the Past: Performances of Hindu Textual Heritage in Contemporary India
International Journal of Hindu Studies
How is Indic Hindu antiquity made relevant to an India that is rewriting itself? The contributions in this special issue take a trans-regional and multi-disciplinary approach in order to suggest some junctures between India's heritage, its temporally complex present, and its trajectory for the future through the medium of "Hindu texts." This project has connected philologists, anthropologists, historians and geographers, as well as performers and practitioners. Our aim is to arrive at a holistic interpretation of "the classical" in contemporary Hindu India and, thereby, at an appreciation of continuities and disjunctures between contemporary and classical sources in ritual and textual contexts. Viewing Hindu scripture in such terms allows us to consider texts as entities used by actors, as abstract entities with cultural force, and also as actors in ethnographic play with those who use them.
Religious Sentiment and Politics of Defining Hindu Texts
In the context of rightwing student protest on Delhi University campus in 2011 to demand the withdrawal of an essay written by Prof A K Ramanujan, there developed a politico-legal situation in which students deployed both political pressure as well as legal suit to achieve their goal. This incident raised not only questions of political involvement in defining what Hinduism should be and how its sacred texts ought to be read, but the debate also attempted to shape the 'sacred text' by carefully and systematically obfuscating select materials to fit in with the viewpoint from a particular section of the Hindu society. In this paper I wish to examine some of the underlying issues in regard to the broader issue of religious sentiment. I examine the issue of rationalizing Hindu texts through moral discourse, the role of Hindutva ideology in rationalizing Hindu texts, and the role of modern Hindu tendency to restrict Hinduism to Vedānta ideas and thereby creating an unintended consequence toward a prejudicial understanding of Hinduism. I also wish to analyze the role of rightwing organizations in taking the neo-Vedānta ideas and using them for their own political agenda. I wish to argue that by rejecting Ramanujan's essay the Hindu rightwing students effectively defined what Hindu texts ought to have contained in them by denying the fact that any other narratives ever existed in the 'sacred' texts of the Hindus.