Trusting in others' biases: Fostering guarded trust in collaborative filtering and recommender systems (original) (raw)

2004, Knowledge, Technology & Policy

Abstract

Collaborative filtering is being used within organizations and in community contexts for knowledge management and decision support as well as the facilitation of interactions among individuals. This article analyzes rhetorical and technical efforts to establish trust in the constructions of individual opinions, reputations, and tastes provided by these systems. These initiatives have some important parallels with early efforts to support quantitative opinion polling and construct the notion of "public opinion." The article explores specific ways to increase trust in these systems, albeit a "guarded trust" in which individuals actively seek information about system foibles and analyze the reputations of participants.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (105)

  1. Altheide, D. (2000). "Identity and the Definition of the Situation in a Mass-Mediated Context," Symbolic Interaction, 23(1 ), 1-27.
  2. Ansari, A., Essegaier, S. and Kohli, R. (2000). "Internet Recommendation Systems," Journal of Marketing Research, 37(3), 363-375.
  3. Applbaum, K. (1995). "Marriage with the Proper Stranger: Arranged Marriage in Metropolitan Ja- pan," Ethnology, 34(1), 37-52.
  4. Armstrong, C. (2001). "Review of Bowling Alone," Knowledge, Technology andPolicy, 13(4), 124-130.
  5. Baba, M. (1999). "Dangerous Liaisons: Trust, Distrust, and Information Technology in American Work Organizations," Human Organization, 58(3), 331-347.
  6. "Backlash against Business" (2002). Economist, 364(8280), 27-28.
  7. Baier, A. (1985). Postures of the Mind: Essays on Mind and Morals. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
  8. Barone, M. (1996). "Why Opinion Polls are Worth Less," U.S. News & World Report, 121(23), 52.
  9. Bennett, W.L., and Edelman, M. (1985). "Toward a New Political Narrative," Journal of Communica- tion, 35, 156-171.
  10. Bigley, G. and Pearce, J. (1998). "Straining for Shared Meaning in Organization Science: Problems of Trust and Distrust," Academy of Management Review, 23(3), 405-422.
  11. Borchers, A., Herlocker, J., Konstan, J., and Riedl, J. (1998). "Ganging Up on Information Over- load." IEEE Computer, 3I(4), 106-108.
  12. Cambridge, D. (1999). "Supporting the Development of a National Constellation of Communities of Practice in the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning through the Use of Intelligent Agents." In Hoadley, C. and Roschelle, J. (eds.) Proceedings of the Computer Support for CoUaborative Learning (CSCL) 1999 Conference, 12-15 December, Stanford University, Palo Alto, CA. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  13. Carlson, S. (2000). "Web Site Uses Sophisticated Programming to Offer Movie Advice," Chronicle of Higher Education, 46(38), A53.
  14. Cheney, G. and Carroll, C. (1997). "The Person as Object in Discourses in and around Organizations," Communication Research, 24(6), 593-631.
  15. Clemons, E. and Wang, Y. (2000). "Special Issue: Technology Strategy for Electronic Marketplaces," Journal of Management Information Systems, 17(2), 5-8.
  16. "Collaborative Filtering Goes Bad" (2001). <http:llwww.plastie.com/article.pl?sid=Oll02/19/ 1413236&mode=thread, accessed 26 June 2001.
  17. Davis, B. and Halliday, J. (2000). "'Firestone Prepares Effort to Rebuild Damaged Brand," Advertising Age, 71(51), 8.
  18. Dean, J., Brandes, P., and Dharwadkar, R. (1998). "Organizational Cynicism," Academy of Manage- ment Review, 23(2), 341-353.
  19. Dellarocas, C. (2000a). Immunizing online reputation reporting systems against unfair ratings and discriminatory behavior. Proceedings of the Second ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce, Minneapolis, MN, October 2000.
  20. Dellarocas, C. (2000b). Mechanisms for coping with unfair ratings and discriminatory behavior in online reputation reporting systems. Proceedings of the 21st International Conference on Infor- mation Systems (ICIS), Brisbane, Australia, December 2000.
  21. Eysenbach, G., Diepgen, T. and Coiera, E. (1998). "Towards Quality Management of Medical Infor- mation on the Internet: Evaluation, Labelling, and Filtering of Information," BMJ: British Medical Journal, 7171, 1496-1501.
  22. Fallows, J. (2000). "Can the Net Govern Itself?." American Prospect, 11(10), 48.
  23. Figallo, C. and Rhine, N. (2001). "'Tapping the Grape Vine," EContent, 24(3), 38-43.
  24. Frick, R. (2000). "Pick of the Flicks," Kiplinger's Personal Finance Magazine, 54(12), 34.
  25. Gamson, W. (1989). "Media Discourse and Public Opinion: A Constructionist Approach," American Journal of Sociology, 95, 1-37.
  26. Garfield, B. (2001). "Firestone Bid to Rebuild Trust Comes Too Late for the Wary," Advertising Age, 72(18), 35.
  27. Giddens, A. (1990). The Consequences of Modernity. Cambridge: Polity.
  28. Gladwell, M. (1999). "The Science of the Sleeper," New Yorker, 75(29), 48-55.
  29. Goldberg, D., Nichols, D., Old, B., and Terry, D. (1992). "Using Collaborative Filtering to Weave an Information Tapestry," Communications of the A CM, 35(12), 61-70.
  30. Goldman, D. (1998). "The Quiz Show Scandal," Biography, 2(12), 20-22.
  31. Gozzi, R. (1999-2000). "The Power of Metaphor," ETC." A Review of General Semantics, 56(4), 380405.
  32. Granovetter, M. (1985). "Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness," American Journal of Sociology, 91,481-510.
  33. Gurak, L. (1997). Persuasion and Privacy in Cyberspace. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
  34. Hamilton, J. (2001 ). "A Wide Web of Advice," Business Week, 3 716, EB 18-EB20.
  35. Haynes, C. (2002). "Playing Rhetoric: Language, Computer Games, and Hacker Pedagogy," Com- puter Games in School Symposium. Grafisk Multimedia Pedagogik Institute-Stockholm Univer- sity, Sweden, June 2002.
  36. Herbst, S. (1993). Numbered Voices: How Opinion Polling Has Shaped American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1993.
  37. Herlocker, J., Konstan, J., and Riedl, J. (2000). "Explaining Collaborative Filtering Recommenda- tions," CSCW '00 Proceedings, 2-6 December 2000, Philadelphia, PA.
  38. Herz, J. (2001). "Evolution of the Online Species," Brandweek, 42(10), SR12-13.
  39. Holt, D. (2002). "Why Do Brands Cause Trouble? A Dialectical Theory of Consumer Culture and Branding," Journal of Consumer Research, 29(1), 70-91.
  40. Horton, W. (1990). "Visual Rhetoric for Online Documents," IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 33(3), 108-113.
  41. Houston, D. (2001). "Trust in the Networked Economy: Doing Business on Web Time," Business Horizons, 44(2), 38-45.
  42. Hughes, R. and Costello, D. (2001). "The Electronic Yard Sale," Wall Street Journal, 237(107), W1.
  43. Hussong, S. (2000). "Medical Records and Your Privacy: Developing Federal Legislation to Protect Patient Privacy Rights," American Journal of Law & Medicine, 26(4), 453-475.
  44. Hwang, Y. and Fesenmaier, D. (2001). "Collaborative Filtering: Strategies for Travel Destination Bundling," In Payline, J., WSber, K. and Fesenmaier, D. (eds.) Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism 2001: Proceedings of the International Conference of ENTER 2001. Montreal, Canada, 167-175.
  45. Katyal, N. (2001). "Criminal Law in Cyberspace," University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 149(4), 1003-1115.
  46. Kautz, H., Selman, B. and Shah, M: (1997). "ReferralWeb: Combining Social Networks and Collabo- rative Filtering," Communications of the ACM, 40(3), 63-65.
  47. Khare, R. and Rifldn, A. (1997). "Weaving a Web of Trust," World Wide Web Journal, 2(3), 77-112.
  48. Koehn, D. (1996). "Should We Trust in Trust?" American Business Law Journal, 34(2), 183-204.
  49. Kollock, P. (1999). "The Production of Trust in Online Markets," In Lawler, E.J., Macy, M., Thyne, S., and Walker, H.A. (eds.) Advances in Group Processes (Vol. 16). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
  50. Larson, S. (1999). "Public Pinion in Television Election News: Beyond Polls," Political Communica- tion, 16(2), 133-146.
  51. Lashkari, Y. (1998). "Subject: RE: Social Filtering or Collaborative Filtering?" <http:// www.sims.berkeley.edu/resources/mailing-lists/collab/0110.html> (accessed June 26, 2001).
  52. Latour, B. (1999). Pandora's Hope: Essays on the Reality of Science Studies. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  53. Lee, C. (1992). "The Rhetoric of an On-Line Document Retrieval System," Proceedings of the ACM Tenth International Conference on Document Retrieval Systems, 25-45.
  54. Lewicki, R. and Mcallister, D. (1998). "Trust and Distrust: New Relationships and Realities," Acad- emy of Management Review, 23(3), 438, 21.
  55. Lynch, C. (2000). "From Automation to Transformation," Educause Review, 35(1), 60-69.
  56. Maes, P. (1994). "Agents That Reduce Work and Information Overload," Communications of the ACM, 37(7), 31-40.
  57. Maybury, M., D'Amore, R., and House, D. (2000). "Automating the Finding of Experts," Research Technology Management, 43(6), 12-16.
  58. McCloskey, D. (1992). "The Art of Forecasting: From Ancient to Modern Times," CATO Journal, 12(1), 23-44.
  59. McDonald, D. and Ackerman, M. (1998). "Just Talk to Me: A Field Study of Expertise Location," Proceedings of CSCW '98. Seattle: ACM Press, 315-324.
  60. McMaster, M. (2001, July). "Too Close for Comfort," Sales and Marketing Management, 42-48.
  61. "Media Manipulation, Carnival, American Puritanism, and Yahoo! News" (2001). <http:// www.plastic.com/article.pl?sid=01/03/02/1622245&mode=thread> (Accessed 26 June 2001.)
  62. Nadel, M. (2001). "The Consumer Product Selection Process in an Internet Age: Obstacles to Maxi- mum Effectiveness and Policy Options," Harvard Journal of Law and Technology, 14(1), 182- 262.
  63. Oravec, J. (1996). Virtual Individuals, Virtual Groups: Human Dimensions of Groupware and Computer Networking. New York: Cambridge University Press.
  64. Pearson, C. and Misra, S. (1997). "Managing the Unthinkable," Organizational Dynamics, 26(2), 51-65.
  65. Pennock, D., Horvitz, E., and Giles, C.L. (2000). "Social Choice Theory and Recommender Systems: Analysis of the Axiomatic Foundations of Collaborative Filtering," Proceedings of Seventeenth National Congress of AAAI/IAAL 729-734.
  66. Peters, J. (1995). "Historical Tensions in the Concept of Public Opinion," In Glasser, T. and Salmon, C. (eds.), Public Opinion and the Communication of Consent. New York: Guilford Press, 3-32.
  67. Phelps, J., Nowak, G., and Ferrell, E. (2000). "Privacy Concerns and Consumer Willingness to Provide Personal Information," Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 19(1), 27-42. "Punch Line" (1999). liE Solutions, 31(i0), 66.
  68. Putnam, R. (1996). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.
  69. Raghavan, P. (2001). "Social Networks on the Web and in the Enterprise." Lecture Notes in Computer Science, LNAI 2198. New York: Springer-Verlag, 58-60.
  70. Recker, M., Walker, A. and Wiley, D. (2000). "An Interface for Collaborative Filtering of Educational Resources." Proceedings of the 2000 International Conference on Artificial Intelligence (1C- AI'2000), 26-29 June 2000, Las Vegas, Nevada, 317-323.
  71. Resnick, P. (1997). "Filtering Information on the Internet," Scientific American, 276(3), 62-65.
  72. Resnick, P. and Varian, H. (1997). "Recommender Systems: Introduction to the Special Section." Communications of the ACM 40(3), 56-58.
  73. Resnick, P., Zeckhauser, R., Friedman, E., and Kuwabara, K. (2000). "Reputation Systems," Commu- nications of the ACM, 43(12), 45-48.
  74. Resnick, P. (2002). "Beyond Bowling Together: SocioTechnical Capital," In Carroll, J. (Ed.) Human- Computer Interaction in the New Millennium. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
  75. Sanders, L. (1999). "Democratic Politics and Survey Research," Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 29(2), 248-281.
  76. Schneider, M. and Teske, P. (1997). "Networks to Nowhere: Segregation and Stratification in Net- works of Information about Schools," American Journal of Political Science, 41(4), 1201-1224.
  77. Selznick, P. (1994). The Moral Commonwealth: Social Theory and the Promise of Community. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
  78. Shapiro, S. (1987). "The Social Control of Impersonal Trust," American Journal of Sociology, 93, 623-658.
  79. Shardanand, U. and Maes, P. (1995). "Social Information Filtering: Algorithms for Automating Word of Mouth," A CM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI-95), 210-217.
  80. Sitkin, S. and Roth, N. (1993). "Explaining the Limited Effectiveness of Legalistic "Remedies" for Trust/Distrust," Organization Science, 4, 367-392.
  81. Sobel, R. (1998). "Portraying American Public Opinion toward the Bosnian Crisis," Harvard Inter- national Journal of Press~Politics, 3(2), 16-34.
  82. Start, B., Ackerman, M., and Pazzani, M. (1996). "Do-I-Care: A Collaborative Web Agent," CHI-96 Proceedings, Short Papers. New York: ACM Press, 256-259.
  83. Stenmark, D. (2000/2001). "Leveraging Tacit Organization Knowledge," Journal of Management Information Systems, 17(3), 9-25.
  84. Stiglitz, J. (2000). "The Contributions of the Economics of Information to Twentieth Century Eco- nomics," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115(4), 1441-1479.
  85. Szymanski, D and Henard, D. (2001). "Customer Satisfaction: A Meta-Analysis of the Empirical Evidence," Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 29(1), 16-36.
  86. Tatemura, J. (1999). "Visual Querying and Explanation of Recommendations from Collaborative Filtering Systems," Intelligent User Interfaces. New York: ACM, 189.
  87. Tovey, J. (1996). "Computer Interfaces and Visual Rhetoric: Looking at the Technology," Technical Communication Quarterly, 5(1), 61-76.
  88. Troman, G. (2000). "Teacher Stress in the Low-Trust Society," British Journal of Sociology of Education, 21(3), 331-354.
  89. Tynan, D. (2000). "Privacy 2000: In Web We Trust?" PC World, 18(6), 103-112.
  90. Urban, G., Sultan, F., and Qualls, W. (1999). "Design and Evaluation of a Trust-Based Advisor on the Internet. Cambridge, MA: MIT Sloan School of Management working paper, <http:// ebusiness.mit.edu/research/papers/forum/>.
  91. Urban, G., Sultan, E, and Quails, W. (2000). "Placing Trust at the Center of your Internet Strategy," Sloan Management Review, 42(1), 39-49.
  92. Uslaner, E. (2000). "The Internet and Social Capital," Communications of the ACM, 43(12), 60-64.
  93. Warren, K. (2001). In Defense of Public Opinion Polling. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
  94. Weber, T. (2000). "To Build Virtual Trust, Web Sites Develop "Reputation Managers." Wall Street Journal--Eastern Edition, 236(10), B 1.
  95. Werry, C. (1999). "Imagined Electronic Community: Representations of Virtual Community in Contemporary Business Discourse," <http://firstmonday.org/issues/issue4 9/werry/#notel> (ac- cessed 27 January 2001).
  96. Whitmeyer, J. (2000). "Effects of Positive Reputation Systems," Social Science Research, 29(2), 188- 208.
  97. Wilkinson, S. and Kitzinger, C. (2000). "Clinton Faces Nation: A Case Study in the Construction of Focus Group Data as Public Opinion," Sociological Review, 48(3), 408-425.
  98. Williams, J. (2002). "6 Hot Technologies with a Purpose," Library Journal, 127(2), 51.
  99. Wring, D., (1998). 'q'he Media and Intra-Party Democracy: 'New' Labour and the Clause Four Debate in Britain," Democratization 5(2), 42-61.
  100. Wyner, G. (1998). "Collaborative Filtering: Research or IT?" Marketing Research, I0(3), 35-38.
  101. Wyner, G. (2000). "Life (on the Internet) Imitates Research: More Internet Processes Feel Like Research Processes," Marketing Research, 12(2) 38-39.
  102. Ye, L. and Johnson, E (1995). "The Impact of Explanation Facilities on User Acceptance of Expert Systems Advice," MIS Quarterly, 19(2), 157-173.
  103. Zacharia, G. and Maes, E (2000). "Trust Management through Reputation Mechanisms," Applied Artificial Intelligence 14(9), 881-907.
  104. Zacharia, G., Moukas, A., and Maes, R (1999). "Collaborative Reputation Mechanisms in Electronic Marketplaces," Proceedings of the 32nd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 323-327.
  105. Zimmerman, J. and Kurapati, K. (2002). "Exposing Profiles to Build Trust in a Recommender," Proceedings of CHI 2002, Minneapolis, MN, April 2002. AMC Press, 608-609.