Some recommendations for experimental work in magnetobiology, revisited (original) (raw)

Abstract

sparkles

AI

This paper revisits the field of magnetobiology, addressing historical controversies regarding the effects of weak magnetic fields on biological systems. It emphasizes the ongoing challenges of replicating experimental results and suggests essential recommendations for future research, including the use of Faraday cages and specific culture containers to minimize interference and improve experimental robustness. The authors advocate for interdisciplinary collaboration to enhance the quality and credibility of magnetobiological studies.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (91)

  1. Adair RK. 1991. Constraints on biological effects of weak extremely-low-frequency electromagnetic fields. Phys Rev A 43:1039-1048.
  2. Adair RK. 1992. Reply to "Comment on 'Constraints on biologi- cal effects of weak extremely-low-frequency electromag- netic fields'. Phys Rev A 46:2185-2187.
  3. Belyaev IY. 2010. Dependence of non-thermal biological effects of microwaves on physical and biological variables: implications for reproducibility and safety standards. In: Giuliani L, Soffritti M, editors. Non-Thermal Effects and Mechanisms of Interaction Between Electromagnetic Fields and Living Matter. Bologna, Italy: National Institute for the Study and Control of Cancer and Environmental Diseases "Bernardino Ramazzini". pp 187-218.
  4. Belyaev IY, Alipov ED. 2001. Frequency-dependent effects of ELF magnetic feld on chromatin conformation in Escher- ichia coli cells and human lymphocytes. Biochim Biophys Acta 1526:269-276.
  5. Belyaev IY, Alipov YD, Harms-Ringdahl M. 1999. Effects of weak ELF on E-coli cells and human lymphocytes: role of genetic, physiological, and physical parameters. In: Bersani F, editor. Electricity and Magnetism In Biology And Medicine. New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum. pp 481-484.
  6. Belyaev IY, Alipov YD, Matronchik AYu. 1998. Cell density dependent response of E. coli cells to weak ELF magnetic fields. Bioelectromagnetics 19:300-309.
  7. Belyaev I, Dean A, Eger H, Hubmann G, Jandrisovits R, Kern M, Kundi M, Moshammer H, Lercher P, M€ uller K, Oberfeld G, Ohnsorge P, Pelzmann P, Scheingraber C, Thill R. 2016. EUROPAEM EMF Guideline 2016 for the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of EMF-related health problems and illnesses. Rev Environ Health 31:363-397.
  8. Belyaev IY, Matronchik AY, Alipov YD. 1994. Effect of weak static and alternating magnetic fields on the genome conformational state of E. coli cells: evidence for the model of modulation of high frequency oscillations. In: Allen MJ, editor. Charge and Field Effects in Biosystems. Singapore: World Scientific Publish. pp 174-184.
  9. Binhi VN. 2002. Magnetobiology: Underlying Physical Problems. San Diego, CA: Academic Press. pp 29-329.
  10. Binhi VN. 2007. A few remarks on 'Combined action of DC and AC magnetic fields on ion motion in a macromolecule'. Bioelectromagnetics 28:409-414.
  11. Binhi VN. 2011. Principles of Electromagnetic Biophysics (in Russian). Moscow, Russia: Fizmatlit, pp 40-127.
  12. Binhi VN, Prato FS. 2017a. A physical mechanism of magneto- reception: extension and analysis. Bioelectromagnetics 38:41-52.
  13. Binhi VN, Prato FS. 2017b. Biological effects of the hypomag- netic field: an analytical review of experiments and theories. PLoS ONE 12:e0179340.
  14. Binhi VN, Rubin AB. 2007. Magnetobiology: the kT paradox and possible solutions. Electromag Biol Med 26:45-62.
  15. Binhi VN, Savin AV. 2002. Molecular gyroscopes and biological effects of weak extremely low-frequency magnetic fields. Phys Rev E 65:051912.
  16. Blackman CF. 2017. Potential causes for nonreplication of EMF bioeffect results, and what to do about it. In: Markov M, editor. Dosimetry in Bioelectromagnetics. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. pp 69-86.
  17. Blackman CF, Blanchard JP, Benane SG, House DE. 1996. Effect of AC and DC magnetic field orientation on nerve cells. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 220:807-811.
  18. Buckner CA, Buckner AL, Koren SA, Persinger MA, Lafrenie RM. 2015. Inhibition of cancer cell growth by exposure to a specific time-varying electromagnetic field involves T- type calcium channels. PLoS ONE 10:e0124136.
  19. Campos Albuquerque WW, Pedrosa Brandão Costa RM, Salazar e Fernandes T, Figueiredo Porto AL. 2016. Evidences of the static magnetic field influence on cellular systems. Prog Biophys Mol Biol 121:16-28.
  20. Carlberg M, Koppel T, Ahonen M, Hardell L. 2017. Case-control study on occupational exposure to extremely low-frequency electromagnetic fields and glioma risk. Am J Ind Med 10:22707.
  21. Castello PR, Hill I, Sivo F, Portelli L, Barnes F, Usselman R, Martino CF. 2014. Inhibition of cellular proliferation and enhancement of hydrogen peroxide production in fibrosar- coma cell line by weak radio frequency magnetic fields. Bioelectromagnetics 35:598-602.
  22. Couzin-Frankel J. 2013. When mice mislead. Science 342: 922-923, 925.
  23. Del Re B, Bersani F, Agostini C, Mesirca P, Giorgi G. 2004. Various effects on transposition activity and survival of Escherichia coli cells due to different ELF-MF signals. Radiat Environ Biophys 43:265-270.
  24. Di Barba P, Fassina L, Magenes G, Mognaschi ME. 2017. Shape synthesis of a well-plate for electromagnetic stimulation of cells. Int J Numer Model e2259.
  25. Dumas-Mallet E, Button K, Boraud T, Munafo M, Gonon F. 2016. Replication validity of initial association studies: a comparison between psychiatry, neurology and four so- matic diseases. PLoS ONE 11:e0158064.
  26. Edmonds DT. 1993. Larmor precession as a mechanism for the detection of static and alternating magnetic fields. Bioelec- trochem Bioenerg 30:3-12.
  27. Engels S, Schneider NL, Lefeldt N, Hein CM, Zapka M, Michalik A, Elbers D, Kittel A, Hore PJ, Mouritsen H. 2014. Anthropogenic electromagnetic noise disrupts magnetic compass orientation in a migratory bird. Nature 509:353-356.
  28. Feynman RP, Leighton RB, Sands M. 1964. The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Mainly Electromagnetism and Matter (Volume 2). Palo Alto, CA: Addison-Wesley Publishing. pp 14-9 to 14-10.
  29. Fiorillo F. 2002. DC and AC magnetization processes in soft magnetic materials. J Magn Magn Mater 242-245:77-83.
  30. Funk RHW, Monsees T, € Ozkucur N. 2009. Electromagnetic effects-from cell biology to medicine. Prog Histochem Cytochem 43:177-264.
  31. Galland P, Pazur A. 2005. Magnetoreception in plants. J Plant Res 118:371-389.
  32. GavoS ci E, Zironi I, Remondini D, Virelli A, Castellani G, Del Re B, Giorgi G, Aicardi G, Bersani F. 2013. ELF magnetic fields tuned to ion parametric resonance conditions do not affect TEA-sensitive voltage-dependent outward Kþ cur- rents in a human neural cell line. Bioelectromagnetics 34:579-588.
  33. Giorgi G, Pirazzini C, Bacalini MG, Giuliani C, Garagnani P, Capri M, Bersani F, Del Re B. 2017. Assessing the combined effect of extremely low-frequency magnetic field exposure and oxidative stress on LINE-1 promoter methyl- ation in human neural cells. Radiat Environ Biophys 56:193-200.
  34. Goodman EM, Greenebaum B, Marront MT. 1995. Effects of electromagnetic fields on molecules and cells. Int Rev Cytol 158:279-338.
  35. Gottardi G, Mesirca P, Agostini C, Remondini D, Bersani F. 2003. A four coil exposure system (tetracoil) producing a highly uniform magnetic field. Bioelectromagnetics 24: 125-133.
  36. Greenebaum B. 2003. Editorial: "It's D ej a vu all over again". Bioelectromagnetics 24:529-530.
  37. Greenebaum B. 2009. Comment: did undetected AC components affect a DC magnetic field experiment? (Vashisth A, nagarajan S. 2008. bioelectromagnetics 29:571-578). Bio- electromagnetics 30:249-249.
  38. Greenebaum B. 2017. Necessary characteristics of quality bioelec- tromagnetic experimental research. In: Markov M, editor. Dosimetry in Bioelectromagnetics. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. pp 139-156.
  39. Gresits I, Necz PP, J anossy G, Thur oczy G. 2015. Extremely low frequency (ELF) stray magnetic fields of laboratory equip- ment: a possible co-exposure conducting experiments on cell cultures. Electromag Biol Med 34:244-250.
  40. Hannson Mild K, Wil en J, Mattsson MO, Simko M. 2009. Background ELF magnetic fields in incubators: a factor of importance in cell culture work. Cell Biol Int 33:755-757.
  41. Hore PJ, Mouritsen H. 2016. The radical-pair mechanism of magnetoreception. Annu Rev Biophys 45:299-344.
  42. Hu JH, St-Pierre LS, Buckner CA, Lafrenie RM, Persinger MA. 2010. Growth of injected melanoma cells is suppressed by whole body exposure to specific spatial-temporal config- urations of weak intensity magnetic fields. Int J Radiat Biol 86:79-88.
  43. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). 2002. Non- ionizing radiation, Part 1: Static And Extremely Low- Frequency (ELF) Electric And Magnetic Fields [Internet].
  44. Lyon, France: International Agency for Research on Cancer, p 338. Available from https://monographs.iarc.fr/ ENG/Monographs/vol80/mono80.pdf [Last accessed 2 Feb- ruary 2017].
  45. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). 2002b. Ibid IARC [2002], pp 261-270.
  46. Guidelines-"For limiting exposure to time-varying electric and magnetic fields (1 Hz À 100 kHz)". Health Phys 99: 818-836.
  47. Kabuto M, Nitta H, Yamamoto S, Yamaguchi N, Akiba S, Honda Y, Hagihara J, Isaka K, Saito T, Ojima T, Nakamura Y, Mizoue T, Ito S, Eboshida A, Yamazaki S, Sokejima S, Kurokawa Y, Kubo O. 2006. Childhood leukemia and magnetic fields in Japan: a case-control study of childhood leukemia and residential power-frequency magnetic fields in Japan. Int J Cancer 119:643-650.
  48. Kirschvink JL. 1992. Comment on "Constraints on biological effects of weak extremely-low-frequency electromagnetic fields". Phys Rev A 46:2178-2184.
  49. Kirschvink JL. 1992b. Uniform magnetic fields and double- wrapped coil systems: improved techniques for the design of bioelectromagnetic experiments. Bioelectromagnetics 13:401-411.
  50. Lednev VV. 1991. Possible mechanism for the influence of weak magnetic fields on biological systems. Bioelectromagnetics 12:71-75.
  51. Liboff AR. 1985. Geomagnetic cyclotron resonance in living things. J Biol Phys 13:99-102.
  52. Liboff AR. 2006. The ion cyclotron resonance hypothesis. In: Barnes FS, Greenebaum B, editors. Bioengineering and Biophysical Aspects of Electromagnetic Fields (Handbook of Biological Effects of Electromagnetic Fields), 3rd edition. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Taylor and Francis. pp 261-290.
  53. Lin JC. 2014. Reassessing laboratory results of low-frequency electromagnetic field exposure of cells in culture. IEEE Antennas Propag Mag 56:227-229.
  54. Makinistian L. 2016. A novel system of coils for magnetobiology research. Rev Sci Inst 87:114304.
  55. Makinistian L, Belyaev I. 2018. Magnetic field inhomogeneities due to CO 2 incubators shelves: a source of experimental confounding and variability? Royal Soc Open Sci 5:172095.
  56. Marcantonio P, Del Re B, Franceschini A, Capri M, Lukas S, Bersani F, Giorgi G. 2010. Synergic effect of retinoic acid and extremely low frequency magnetic field exposure on human neuroblastoma cell line BE(2)C. Bioelectromag- netics 31:425-433.
  57. Martin LJ, Koren SA, Persinger MA. 2004. Thermal analgesic effects from weak, complex magnetic fields and pharmaco- logical interactions. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 78: 217-227.
  58. Martino CF, Portelli L, McCabe K, Hernandez M, Barnes F. 2010. Reduction of the Earth's magnetic field inhibits growth rates of model cancer cell lines. Bioelectromagnetics 31:649-655.
  59. Matronchik AI, Alipov ED, Beliaev II. 1996. A model of phase modulation of high frequency nucleoid oscillations in reactions of E. coli cells to weak static and low-frequency magnetic fields (in Russian). Biofizika 41:642-649.
  60. Matronchik AY, Belyaev IY. 2008. Mechanism for combined action of microwaves and static magnetic field: slow non uniform rotation of charged nucleoid. Electromag Biol Med 27:340-354.
  61. McLyman WMT. 2011. Transformer And Inductor Design Handbook, 4th Edition. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. pp 1- 1 to 1-16.
  62. Misakian M, Sheppard AR, Krause D, Frazier ME, Miller DL. 1993. Biological, physical, and electrical parameters for in- vitro studies with ELF magnetic and electric fields-a primer. Bioelectromagnetics 14:1-73.
  63. Mognaschi ME, Di Barba P, Magenes G, Lenzi A, Naro F, Fassina L. 2014. Field models and numerical dosimetry inside an extremely-low-frequency electromagnetic biore- actor: the theoretical link between the electromagnetically induced mechanical forces and the biological mechanisms of the cell tensegrity. Springerplus 3:473.
  64. Muehsam D, Lalezari P, Lekhraj R, Abruzzo P, Bolotta A, Marini M, Bersani F, Aicardi G, Pilla A, Casper D. 2013. Non- thermal radio frequency and static magnetic fields increase rate of hemoglobin deoxygenation in a cell-free prepara- tion. PLoS ONE 8:e61752.
  65. Muehsam DJ, Pilla AA. 1994. Weak magnetic field modulation of ion dynamics in a potential well: mechanistic and thermal noise considerations. Bioelectrochem Bioenerg 35:71-79.
  66. Muehsam DJ, Pilla AA. 2009a. A Lorentz model for weak magnetic field bioeffects: part I-Thermal noise is an essential component of AC/DC effects on bound ion trajectory. Bioelectromagnetics 30:462-475.
  67. Muehsam DJ, Pilla AA. 2009b. A Lorentz model for weak magnetic field bioeffects: part II-Secondary transduction mechanisms and measures of reactivity. Bioelectromag- netics 30:476-488.
  68. Nie Y, Du L, Mou Y, Xu Z, Weng L, Du Y, Zhu Y, Hou Y. 2013. Effect of low frequency magnetic fields on melanoma: tumor inhibition and immune modulation. BMC Cancer 13:582-593.
  69. Novikov VV, Novikov GV, Fesenko EE. 2009. Effect of weak combined static and extremely low-frequency alternating magnetic fields on tumor growth in mice inoculated with the Ehrlich ascites carcinoma. Bioelectromagnetics 30: 343-351.
  70. Panagopoulos DJ, Karabarbounis A, Margaritis LH. 2002. Mecha- nism for action of electromagnetic fields on cells. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 298:95-102.
  71. Pazur A, Schimek C, Galland P. 2007. Magnetoreception in microorganisms and fungi. Cent Eur J Biol 2:597-659.
  72. Pinzon-Rodriguez A, Muheim R. 2017. Zebra finches have a light-dependent magnetic compass similar to migratory birds. J Exp Biol 220:1202-1209.
  73. Portelli LA. 2017. Uncertainty sources associated with low- frequency electric and magnetic field experiments on cell cultures. In: Markov M, editor. Dosimetry in Bioelectro- magnetics. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. pp 25-67.
  74. Portelli LA, Falldorf K, Thur oczy G, Cuppen J. 2018. Retrospec- tive estimation of the electric and magnetic field exposure conditions in in vitro experimental reports reveal consider- able potential for uncertainty. Bioelectromagnetics 39: 231-243.
  75. Portelli LA, Schomay TE, Barnes FS. 2013. Inhomogeneous background magnetic field in biological incubators is a potential confounder for experimental variability and repro- ducibility. Bioelectromagnetics 34:337-348.
  76. Prato FS, Kavaliers M, Carson JJL. 1996. Behavioural evidence that magnetic field effects in the land snail, Cepaeanemor- alis, might not depend on magnetite or induced electric currents. Bioelectromagnetics 17:123-130.
  77. Ritz T, Thalau P, Phillips JB, Wiltschko R, Wiltschko W. 2004. Resonance effects indicate a radical-pair mechanism for avian magnetic compass. Nature 429:177-180.
  78. Rodgers CT, Hore PJ. 2009. Chemical magnetoreception in birds: the radical pair mechanism. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106:353-360.
  79. Sarimov R, Alipov ED, Belyaev IY. 2011. Fifty hertz magnetic fields individually affect chromatin conformation in human lymphocytes: dependence on amplitude, temperature, and initial chromatin state. Bioelectromagnetics 32:570-579.
  80. Schuderer J, Oesch W, Felber N, Sp€ at D, Kuster N. 2004. In vitro exposure apparatus for ELF magnetic fields. Bioelectro- magnetics 25:582-591.
  81. Sch€ uz J. 2011. Exposure to extremely low-frequency magnetic fields and the risk of childhood cancer: update of the epidemiological evidence. Prog Biophys Mol Biol 107: 339-342.
  82. Schwarze S, Schneider N-L, Reichl T, Dreyer D, Lefeldt N, Engels S, Baker N, Hore PJ, Mouritsen H. 2016. Weak broadband electromagnetic fields are more disruptive to magnetic compass orientation in a night-migratory songbird (Erithacusrubecula) than strong narrow-band fields. Front Behav Neurosci 10:55.
  83. Scopus. Available from http://www.scopus.com [Last accessed 22 December 2017].
  84. Shupak NM, Prato FS, Thomas AW. 2003. Therapeutic uses of pulsed magnetic-field exposure: a review. Radio Science Bulletin 307:9-32.
  85. Tatarov I, Panda A, Petkov D, Kolappaswamy K, Thompson K, Kavirayani A, Lipsky MM, Elson E, Davis CC, Martin SS, DeTolla LJ. 2011. Effect of magnetic fields on tumor growth and viability. Comp Med 61:339-345.
  86. Usselman RJ, Hill I, Singel DJ, Martino CF. 2014. Spin biochemistry modulates reactive oxygen species (ROS) production by radio frequency magnetic fields. PLoS ONE 9:e93065.
  87. Valberg PA. 1995. Designing EMF experiments: what is required to characterize "exposure"? Bioelectromagnetics 16: 396-401.
  88. Villeneuve PJ, Agnew DA, Johnson KC, Mao Y, Canadian Cancer Registries Epidemiology Research Group. 2002. Brain cancer and occupational exposure to magnetic fields among men: results from a Canadian population-based case-control study. Int J Epidemiol 31:210-217.
  89. Weaver JC, Vaughan TE, Astumian RD. 2000. Biological sensing of small field differences by magnetically sensitive chemi- cal reactions. Nature 405:707-709.
  90. World Health Organization (WHO). 2007. Extremely Low Frequency Fields, Environmental Health Criteria 238 [Internet].
  91. Zhadin MN, Barnes F. 2005. Frequency and amplitude windows in the combined action of DC and low frequency AC magnetic fields on ion thermal motion in a macromolecule: theoretical analysis. Bioelectromagnetics 26:323-330.