Secularism and the Muslim Women Question: A Critique of Secularism as a Frame of Reference for Gender Equality (original) (raw)
Related papers
Gender: Religion, Secularism, and Women’s Empowerment
Religion and European Society: A Primer, 2019
This chapter argues that the ways of opposing religion and secularity in relation to gender produce forms of polarization between religious and secular actors that are undesirable and stand in the way of perceiving and hearing what women may need. It outlines how and why religious and secular approaches to issues of gender and women's empowerment so often seem to clash and sketches some of the critiques that have been articulated by feminist scholars from within cultural anthropology, history, and religious studies. The chapter focuses on the European context, and on religion in its association with minority groups, since this is where religion is usually problematized in relation to gender and sexuality. The complexity of minority–majority relations, and the ways this is informed by gender and religion, is often a minefield for policymakers on all levels of society.
Gender and Research 20 (2): 26-46,, 2019
The Western focus on 'Islamic feminism' takes two extreme forms: it is often dismissed as an oxymoron for attaching a religious (patriarchal) adjective to an emancipatory feminist project, or it is hailed as a road to a liberal, reformed Islam. Many Muslim feminists refuse to use this term; some reject feminism outright. There is consequently a tension within the term that many Muslim women activists acknowledge. In order to gain a better understanding of how religious and secular discourses combine in 'feminism in Islam', this text aims to examine the place of religion in women's emancipatory strategies. When we look at the history, strategies, discourses, and especially at the concept of 'religion' Muslim women activists and thinkers deal with, a complex landscape emerges. 'Islam' ceases to be a reference to a given religious paradigm but becomes itself a contested terrain, one with religious, but also political, legal, and institutional actors. Theological, hermeneutical, post-foundationalist, reformist, legal, and social activism all envisage 'Islam' from different perspectives and locate the discriminatory aspects they resist in different fi elds of the Islamic paradigm or practice. The aim is to explore the meaning and practice of 'feminism in Islam' while taking a critical approach to an essentialist understanding of both Islam and Islamic feminism. While gender equality has been a persistent demand in Muslim societies for more than a century, and while feminist activism was at the forefront of many recent social movements in Muslim societies, the notion of 'Islamic feminism' remains veiled in a series of questions and doubts. Not only sceptical Westerners but also Islamists and GENDER AND RESEARCH
2011
The book aims to assess how women’s ways of understanding and experiencing religiosity fit within the broader context of religion in ‘the West,’ and, in particular, how the analyses of female religiosities inform our understanding on secularisation. By exploring diverse ways in which women approach religion in ‘the West,’ the volume scrutinises female religiosities in an interdisciplinary gaze. The book has been divided into three main sections. The first, deals with Christianity, the second with ‘Alternative Spiritualities,’ and the third, with Islam.
The Muslim World, vol. 103, no. 3., 2013
Secular frameworks of rights and empowerment have failed to deliver effective solutions to social issues in many contexts where religious revivalism is on the rise. This has been particularly poignant in the case of secular feminism in Muslim-majority countries. The realisation that social problems such as patriarchal gender relations, violence, and poverty must be approached from an Islamic perspective to have a raison d’être in such contexts has encouraged women to independently seek thorough Islamic education.
Final 13 Feb 2019_Contestations of Feminism, Secularism and Religion_NJRS.docx
equality. Yet, contemporary feminist and women's movements in the West are largely understood as secular, and as rejecting religion, and religion is often perceived as the antithesis of empowerment and emancipation. In this article I problematise the relationship between feminism, secularism and religion via a discussion of secular feminist views on women and religion, and religious women's views on secular feminism. Bringing together previously separate strands of work, this article provides an original analysis of how both secular feminist women and non-feminist religious women engage in discursive articulations of Othering, constructing inferior subjects who are (dis-)placed outside the boundary of 'women like us'. Such discursive representations, which are rooted in perceptions of feminism and religion as unitary and static, contribute to the construction and maintenance of sharp boundaries between secular and religious women, thus hindering the potential for dialogue and collaboration in support of women's rights and gender equality.
Secularism is a Women's Affair
New Perspectives Quarterly, 2008
The drama between the secularist legacy of Ataturk and the popular surge of Islamistrooted politics continues in Turkey, centered on the debate over the headscarf. Is it a sign of religious reaction, or a sign of non-Western modernization that will ensure higher education for Muslim women? We represent here all sides of the debate.
This article presents a macro-national perspective of gender equality in employment in two Muslim majority countries, Turkey and Pakistan. The article examines and compares the institutional implications of secularism and Islamic shariah for gender equality in employment in the two countries. Drawing on case studies of a selection of influential public and private sector organizations engaged in promoting and implementing gender equality in Turkey and Pakistan, the article argues that secularism and shariah as dominant ideologies present poor agendas for gender equality. Indeed, secularism and shariah hijack gender equality discourses paying only partial lip service to genuine demands for equality. The article argues that there is a need to rescue gender equality from the clasp of ideology and bring in genuine processes of equal opportunity and social justice in the workplace.
Nordic Journal of Religion and Society
Secular and religious women have a history of fighting for women's rights and gender equality. Yet, contemporary feminist and women's movements in the West are largely understood as secular, and as rejecting religion, and religion is often perceived as the antithesis of empowerment and emancipation. In this article I problematise the relationship between feminism, secularism and religion via a discussion of secular feminist views on women and religion, and religious women's views on secular feminism. Bringing together previously separate strands of work, this article provides an original analysis of how both secular feminist women and non-feminist religious women engage in discursive articulations of Othering, constructing inferior subjects who are (dis-)placed outside the boundary of 'women like us'. Such discursive representations, which are rooted in perceptions of feminism and religion as unitary and static, contribute to the construction and maintenance of sharp boundaries between secular and religious women, thus hindering the potential for dialogue and collaboration in support of women's rights and gender equality.