A behavioural model of minority language shift: Theory and empirical evidence (original) (raw)
Related papers
Economics and (Minority) Language: Why is it so Hard to Save a Threatened language?
Linguistic and cultural diversity is a fundamental aspect of the present world. It is therefore important to understand how this diversity could be sustained. Certainly, the education system, the justice system, and the economic decisions will play an important role. Our view is that a key agent in keeping diversity is the minority language speaker. Thus, we focus on the bilinguals' language choice behavior in societies with two official languages: A, spoken by all, and B, spoken by the bilingual minority. This kind of bilinguals is thought of as a population playing repeatedly a game that decides the language they will use in each interaction. We make the hypothesis that bilinguals have reached a population state with strong stability properties. Then we take the evolutionary stable mixed strategy Nash equilibrium of the game to build an economic model of linguistic behavior. It is shown that model-based predictions fit well the actual use data of Basque, Irish and Welsh. Some language policy prescriptions are provided to increase the use of B.
The fate of bilingualism in a model of language competition
2007
In the general context of dynamics of social consensus, we study an agent based model for the competition between two socially equivalent languages, addressing the role of bilingualism and social structure. In a regular network, we study the formation of linguistic domains and their interaction across the boundaries. We analyse also a small world social structure, in order to capture the effect of long range social interactions.
Minority Language and the Stability of Bilingual Equilibria
2010
We investigate a society with two official languages: A, shared by all individuals and B, spoken by a bilingual mirority. Thus, it is only B that needs t increase its population share, and therefore, only the language dynamics that derive from the intearctions that occur inside the bilingual population are both empirically and theoretically relevant. To this end, a model
Modelling bilingualism in language competition: the effects of complex social structure
2007
In the general context of dynamics of social consensus, we study an agent based model for the competition between two socially equivalent languages, addressing the role of bilingualism and social structure. In a regular network, we study the formation of linguistic domains and their interaction across the boundaries. We analyze also the dynamics on a small world network and on a network with community structure. In all cases, a final scenario of dominance of one language and extinction of the other is obtained. In comparison with the regular network, smaller times for extinction are found in the small world network. In the network with communities instead, the average time for extinction is not representative of the dynamics and metastable states are observed at all time scales.
Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, 2013
An in-depth analytic study of a model of language dynamics is presented: a model which tackles the problem of the coexistence of two languages within a closed community of speakers taking into account bilingualism and incorporating a parameter to measure the distance between languages. After previous numerical simulations, the 1 model yielded that coexistence might lead to survival of both languages within monolingual speakers along with a bilingual community or to extinction of the weakest tongue depending on different parameters. In this paper, such study is closed with thorough analytical calculations to settle the results in a robust way and previous results are refined with some modifications. From the present analysis it is possible to almost completely assay the number and nature of the equilibrium points of the model, which depend on its parameters, as well as to build a phase space based on them. Also, we obtain conclusions on the way the languages evolve with time. Our rigorous considerations also suggest ways to further improve the model and facilitate the comparison of its consequences with those from other approaches or with real data.
Dynamics of the competition between two languages
SeMA journal, 2020
This paper reports a new kind of mathematical model for language competition dynamics using compartmental epidemiological modeling approach. The model describes the competition between two languages, say the predominant one called language 1, and the less spoken language 2, both in the same community. We distinguish three groups of population building the concerned community: one majority speaking language 1, one minority speaking language 2 and a last minority speaking neither language 1 nor language 2. The study of the proposed model includes an analysis of the evolution of the number of speakers over time. This model predicts that language 2 can inevitably disappear if the threshold parameter R 0 is less than one. We show that our model is well-posed mathematically and linguistically. We also show that the model has basically two linguistic equilibrium points. A monolingual equilibrium point that corresponds to the case where only one language is spoken: some individuals speak only the language 1 and some others do speak neither language 1, nor language 2. A bilingual equilibrium point which corresponds to the case where all the languages are spoken: some individuals speak both languages 1 and 2, some others speak only language 1, while a third group does speak only language 2, and the last group speaks none of the two languages. In this bilingual equilibrium point, both languages coexist. Depending on the threshold parameter, we demonstrate the stability of these equilibria. The model presents on one hand, a direct bifurcation phenomenon, in which we have a stable equilibrium point without bilingual speakers when the associated basic reproduction number is less than one. On the other hand, it presents a stable bilingual equilibrium point when the number of associated basic reproductions is greater than one. The analysis of the overall sensitivity of the model is performed and the impact of the system parameters on the basic reproduction number was performed using sensitivity analysis to determine the impact of each parameter of the system on bilingualism. The numerical simulations carried out are in agreement with the presented theory
Modeling Two-Language Competition Dynamics
Advances in Complex Systems, 2012
During the last decade, much attention has been paid to language competition in the complex systems community, that is, how the fractions of speakers of several competing languages evolve in time. In this paper we review recent advances in this direction and focus on three aspects. First we consider the shift from two-state models to three state models that include the possibility of bilingual individuals. The understanding of the role played by bilingualism is essential in sociolinguistics. In particular, the question addressed is whether bilingualism facilitates the coexistence of languages. Second, we will analyze the effect of social interaction networks and physical barriers. Finally, we will show how to analyze the issue of bilingualism from a game theoretical perspective.
Modelling endangered languages: The effects of bilingualism and social structure
The mathematical model for language competition developed by Abrams and Strogatz allows the evolution of the numbers of monolingual speakers of two competing languages to be estimated. In this paper, we extend the model to examine the role of bilingualism and social structure, neither of which are addressed in the previous model. We consider the impact of two strategies for language maintenance: (1) adjusting the status of the endangered language; and (2) adjusting the availability of monolingual and bilingual educational resources. The model allows us to predict for which scenarios of intervention language maintenance is more likely to be achieved. Qualitative analysis of the model indicates a set of intervention strategies by which the likelihood of successful maintenance is expected to increase. #