Seismic Fragility Assessment for Steel Buildings with Different Performance Levels (original) (raw)
Related papers
Fragility Analysis for Seismic Vulnerability Assessment of Buildings: A Review
Fragility analysis is one of the trending probabilistic seismic performance methodologies. With the advancement in computational methodologies and large database of existing buildings, fragility analysis can be implemented for precise vulnerability assessment of buildings. The vulnerability curves can be categorized into three groups-empirical, analytical and hybrid. Empirical approach includes-Damage Probability Matrices and Vulnerability Functions, which depend on the damage-motion relationship statistics observed after an earthquake. Analytical curves adopt damage distributions simulated from the analyses of structural models. Hybrid curves overcome the deficiencies of the above two approaches by combining post-earthquake damage statistics with simulation techniques. This paper reviews the importance of fragility analysis using existing methodologies and focuses on their key features highlighting limitations. The paper suggests the way forward for selection of appropriate assessm...
Assessment of seismic damage of multistory structures using fragility curves
Performance-based design, PBD, is gaining popularity and its concept hasbeen applied in many international seismic building codes. In this research, five real structures designed according to the Egyptian Building Code, which does not consider PBD, are considered and modeled in a three dimensional way using the software SeismoStruct in order to assess their performance under expected earthquakes. The structures are 2-story, 4-story, 6-story, 8-story and 10-story reinforced concrete framed structures. The structural system of these structures is of the moment-resisting frame type, with and without shear walls. The structures weredesigned under dead, live and seismic forces of " Zone 3 " with a design acceleration of 0.15g.The models were analyzed using incremental dynamic analysis, IDA, considering 12 real records of historical earthquakes. IDA curves were developed for all analyzed models, considering four damage states. Fragility curves were subsequently developed to provide an overview of the expected seismic performance of a typical low or mid-rise multistory reinforced concrete framed structure in Egypt as designed in accordance with thecurrent Egyptian Building Code.
Seismic aftershock fragility analysis of steel buildings based on stochastic ground motions
2018
This paper proposes a probabilistic seismic fragility analysis framework for building structures that explicitly incorporates the cascading impact of mainshock-triggered aftershock earthquake events. The effect of aftershocks is considered by proposing a methodology for generating seismic hazard-consistent mainshock-aftershock sequences for different levels of hazard intensity. This methodology integrates probabilistic seismic hazard deaggregation analysis, empirical seismological models and stochastic ground motion modeling. Application of the proposed framework to a characteristic steel moment resisting frame building in California allows for the evaluation of mainshock-induced damage state-dependent aftershock fragilities and comparison with classic mainshock only fragilities. This comparison highlights the importance of incorporating aftershock seismic events in the seismic hazard characterization, since it is shown that the structure is significantly more vulnerable when it is ...
Development of analytical seismic fragility functions for the common buildings in Iran
Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering
One of the main components for the development of regional seismic risk models is the fragility functions for common building types. Due to the differences between the national design codes, construction practices, and construction materials, it is necessary to develop speci c fragility functions for the common building types which are constructed in each region. One of the existing challenges is the lack of classi ed, reliable, and cogent local seismic fragility functions for common buildings in Iran. For this reason, the present study is devoted to lling this essential gap. Therefore, at the rst step, a comprehensive study was performed on the existing building types in the country. Finally, the Iranian common buildings are classi ed into 35 categories regarding material, lateral-loadresisting system, age, height, and code level. Also, by conducting comprehensive studies on all previously performed researches in the country, structural and dynamic parameters have been collected for buildings in each class. This information was used to compute a large set of backbone curves for Iranian buildings taxonomy. In the next steps, a large set of ground motion records were selected. Then non-linear time-history analyses were performed on the generic backbone curve for each type of building, and the structural responses were used to derive fragility functions for building classes. Then nearly three hundred appropriate fragility functions were generated for Iranian common buildings considering both record-to-record and building-to-building response variability using cloud analysis. Based on the existing empirical data from past earthquakes in the country, the validation of the resulting fragility functions was carried out. The resulted fragility functions can be utilized in seismic risk assessment studies in the country.
A Review on Earthquake Vulnerability Assessment
2017
Majority of human beings live in earthquake prone areas. Earthquake causes significant loss of life and damage of property every year. It is required to identify the damage of a structure caused due to varying ground motion intensities. This identification results will help an engineer to take necessary action against the after-effects of an earthquake. The vulnerability of a structure has to be found out under various ground motion intensity measures (IM) such as Peak Ground Acceleration (PGA). From this, fragility curves can be developed. Fragility analysis is a probabilistic approach, which is commonly used now-a-days. As per this method, different Damage states (DS) have to be defined and then probable damage of the structure in connection with the IM can be found. Fragility curves are generated from multiple Incremental Dynamic Analysis or IDA curves with the help of traditional curve fitting technique.
E3S Web of Conferences, 2022
History records that Aceh has been hit by earthquakes several times, including the largest recorded, on December 26, 2004 with a magnitude of 9.3 SR. In connection with the history of disasters that have occurred, there is a need for safety and disaster preparedness. It is very important to conduct a feasibility study of the existing public buildings used in disaster preparedness for vulnerability against earthquakes. The type of building damage caused can predicted by referring to the fragility curve. This research conducted on evaluating the seismic performance of existing buildings in Banda Aceh City by developing a fragility curve based on Incremental Dynamic Analysis (IDA). The existing buildings that are the main focus of this study include the Tsunami Vertical Evacuation (TVE) of Lambung, TVE Alu Deah Teungoh, TVE TDMRC, SDN 48 Banda Aceh, SMPN 11 Banda Aceh, Baiturrahim Ulee Lheu Mosque, and the Subulussalam Punge Mosque. The IDA method is applied to predict and estimate the...
Seismic Vulnerability Curves for Industrial Steel Structures
2018
The reliable assessment of structural damage after an earthquake event is essential to organize the emergency response and to facilitate the structural and economic losses. Fragility curves are basic components in the process of earthquake loss estimation. They give the probability of exceeding a number of damage states as a function of an intensity measures (IM) such as ground motion. In this paper, fragility curves were developed for steel frames in industrial buildings. Those structures have high impact for the financial prosperity of a region. Fragility curves for those steel structures are not common met in civil engineering literature. Non – linear dynamic analysis has been performed for a 3D steel frame and statistical process of the results in order to obtain the fragility curves for five different damage stages (ds). The damage stages were the three level of inter-story drift according to the literature and additional three more stages which are the yielding and buckling of...
Development of Simulation-Based Fragility Relationships for the Seismic Risk Assessment of Buildings
2015
A number of driving engines are required for earthquake loss estimation and mitigation, including an inventory of exposed systems, seismic hazards of the study area and fragility relationships. The number of existing buildings in the UAE that may be at risk because of insufficient seismic design provisions cannot be underestimated. A crucial role in the recovery period following an earthquake is also played by emergency facilities. Therefore, a systematic seismic vulnerability assessment of a diverse range of reference structures representing pre-seismic code buildings and emergency facilities, in a highly populated and seismically active area in the UAE, has been conducted in this study. Detailed structural design and fiberbased modeling were carried out for nine reference structures. Forty earthquake records were selected to represent potential earthquake scenarios in the study area. Three limit states, namely Immediate Occupancy, Life Safety and Collapse Prevention, were selected based on inelastic analysis results as well as the values recommended in previous studies and code provisions. Over 8000 inelastic pushover and incremental dynamic analyses are performed to assess the lateral capacity and to derive a wide range of fragility relationships for the reference structures. Vulnerability functions were also developed for the buildings that proved to have unsatisfactory performance, and hence proposed to be retrofitted using different mitigation techniques. It was concluded that pre-code structures were significantly more vulnerable than emergency facilities. This is particularly true for low-rise buildings due to their inefficient lateral force resisting systems. Far-field records have much higher impact compared with near-source ground motions. The results reflect the pressing need for the seismic retrofit of pre-code structures to reduce the probability of collapse, and for certain emergency facilities to ensure their continued vii service. Four retrofit approaches are therefore assessed, namely reinforced concrete jacketing, fiber reinforced polymers wrapping, adding buckling restrained braces and installing externally unbonded steel plates. The highest positive impact of retrofit are observed on the pre-code buildings, especially frame structures, since they were only designed to resist gravity and wind loads. The reductions achieved in the vulnerability of the retrofitted structures confirmed the effectiveness of the techniques selected for upgrading the seismic performance of buildings and mitigating earthquake losses in the study area.
Engineering Structures, 2013
This paper presents a new procedure to derive fragility functions for populations of buildings that relies on the displacement-based earthquake loss assessment (DBELA) methodology. The recent developments in this methodology are also presented herein, such as the development of new formulae for the calculation of the yield period or the consideration of infilled frame structures. In the fragility method proposed herein, thousands of synthetic buildings have been produced considering probabilistic distributions describing the variability in their geometrical and material properties. Then, their nonlinear capacity has been estimated using the DBELA method and their performance against a large set of ground motion records has been calculated. Global limit states are used to estimate the distribution of buildings in each damage state for different levels of ground motion, and a regression algorithm is applied to derive fragility functions for each limit state. The proposed methodology is demonstrated for the case of ductile and non-ductile Turkish reinforced concrete buildings with and without masonry infill walls, and compared with results obtained using nonlinear dynamic procedures and with the results from previous studies.
Seismic Fragility Curves of Industrial Buildings by Using Nonlinear Analysis
MATEC Web of Conferences
This study presents the steel fragility curves and performance curves of industrial buildings of different geometries. The fragility curves were obtained for different building geometries, and the performance curves were developed based on lateral load, which is affected by the geometry of the building. Three records of far-field ground motion were used for incremental dynamic analysis (IDA), and the design lateral loads for pushover analysis (POA). All designs were based on British Standard (BS 5950); however, Eurocode 8 was preferred for seismic consideration in the analysis because BS 5950 does not specify any seismic provision. The five levels of performance stated by FEMA-273, namely, operational phase, immediate occupancy, damage control, life safety, and collapse prevention (CP) were used as main guidelines for evaluating structural performance. For POA, Model 2 had highest base shear, followed by Model 1 and Model 3, even though Model 2 has a smaller structure compared with Model 3. Meanwhile, the fragility curves showed that the probability of reaching or exceeding the CP level of Model 2 is the highest, followed by that of Models 1 and 3.