AIDS Assassins”: Australian Media's Portrayal of HIV-Positive Refugees Who Deliberately Infect Others (original) (raw)
Related papers
Making monsters: heterosexuality, crime and race in recent Western media coverage of HIV
Sociology of health & illness, 2008
In the early HIV epidemic, Western media coverage encouraged the idea that infection was linked to ‘other’ identities located outside the ‘mainstream’; outside ‘proper’ heterosexuality. Today, however, HIV has become repositioned as a global heterosexual epidemic. Analyses show that since the 1990s Western media have shifted away from blame and hysteria to an increasingly routinised reporting of HIV as a health story and social justice issue. But recent years have seen the emergence of a new media story in many Western countries; the criminal prosecution for HIV-related offences, and with it a reframing of old discourses of ‘innocence’ and ‘guilt’, but now with heterosexuals in focus. We examine this story in recent domestic media coverage in Australia, a country where heterosexual HIV transmission is rare by global comparison. Echoing similar stories in other Western media, in Australian coverage the idea of criminal intent converges with the symbolic weight of black sexuality and African origins to produce a ‘monstrous’ masculinity, which at the local level taps into contemporary racial tensions and, in so doing, conjures an imagined Anglo-heterosexuality at once vulnerable to and safe from HIV in a globalised epidemic and world.
Archetypes of infection: people with HIV/AIDS in the Australian press in the mid 1990s
Sociology of Health & Illness, 1999
This article presents the findings of an interpretive analysis of the representation of people with HIV/AIDS in the Australian press in a three-year period between 1994 and 1996. Three major archetypes of people with HIV/AIDS dominating reports -the 'AIDS victim', the 'AIDS survivor' and the 'AIDS carrier' -are discussed for what they reveal not only about contemporary approaches to HIV/AIDS but also about more general notions of morality and self-control related to the body, medicine, health and illness. It is argued that these dominant archetypes inevitably draw from previous representations of HIV/AIDS, but at the same time demonstrate evidence of changing discourses and meanings. One feature of particular interest is that moral judgements related to people with HIV/AIDS presented in these news texts appear to be based less on how they acquired the virus than the manner in which they deport themselves once infected.
"African AIDS": The Media and Audience Beliefs
AIDS: Rights, Risk and Reason, 1992
If we relinquish the compulsion to separate true representations of AIDS from false ones and concentrate instead on the process and consequences of representation and discursive production, we can begin to sort out how particular versions of truth are produced and sustained; and what cultural work they do in given-contexts. Such an approach ... raises questions not so much about truth as about power and representation. (Treichler, 1989, p. 48) The prevalence of HIV infection in Africa and the question of the origins of HIV are contentious and much debated topics. The scientifIc validity of the African origin theory has been called into question, and the 'Green Monkey Theory' (the idea that HIV originated among African monkeys and then spread to human beings) has now been rejected by some of the scientists who fmt propounded it (Chirimuuta and Chirimuuta, 1989). The prevalence of infection in different African countries is also not a straightforward matter. For example, the early HIV "antibody test cross-reacted with the antibodies to malarial plasmodium, 'resulting in a huge number of false positive results' (Patton, 1990, p. 26). I?lack scientists, activists, grassroots workers and researchers have challenged the assumptions of much Western scientifIc theorizing about the origins of HIV, and analysts of the media have highlighted racist subtexts in reporting about AIDS and Africa (see However, there is little empirical research exploring how media reporting might actually relate to audience understandings. This chapter focuses On audiences and the role of the media in changing, reinforcing or contributing to Ideas about AIDS, Africa and race. It does not argue that HIV either does, or does not, originate in Africa, nor does it seek to deny the terrible suffering caused by HIV in certain parts of Africa. Here weare not directly addressing questions about where the virus 'really' came from or the actu'aI distribution of infection. Instead we are focusing on how different answers to these questions are produced, framed and sustained, what these tell us about the construction of, AIDS' and 'Africa', 'and what socio-political consequences they carry with them. This chapter addresses 'questions such as: 28 ..
Reflections of inequalities: The construction of HIV/AIDS in Africa in the Australian print media
Health Sociology Review, 2009
The HIV/AIDS pandemic in sub-Saharan Africa prompted industrialised nations to initiate a coordinated global response, which to date has been inadequate in reducing the pandemic's impact in Africa. To better understand this response, this article explores the portrayal of the pandemic in the Australian print media using critical discourse analysis to unpack the discourses surrounding the construction of the pandemic. In particular, it examines how issues of power, ideology, causation and responsibility are expressed and utilised to validate certain stances and responses. The findings demonstrate that the media presents a particular perspective on the pandemic that favours the agendas of industrialised nations. Linguistic devices uncovered racist, medical and development discourses that gave voice to industrialised nations and silenced those from sub-Saharan Africa, limiting discussion on alternative responses. These findings highlight the utility of critical discourse analysis in understanding power structures that construct and influence responses to public health issues.
Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal, 2020
Media coverage of HIV criminal cases has deployed sexualized and racialized tropes, and portrayed defendants as villains. Several media analyses of HIV criminal trials have been conducted, though only one was in the US, and none involved young Black gay men, who are disproportionately impacted by HIV. We conducted content and textual analyses of 91 media stories focused on the 2015 case of Michael Johnson, a Black gay college student living with HIV who was convicted under Missouri’s HIV non-disclosure laws. To capture both dominant and resistant meanings in news stories, we included mainstream news outlets, as well as HIV-related, African American and GLBT community-oriented outlets. Open and axial coding were carried out by a team of four researchers and thematic analysis was used to explore how media framed Johnson, his sexual activities, condom use, and alleged nondisclosure. Results showed that media stories portrayed Johnson as dishonest and sexually predatory by drawing on na...
Mass Media Coverage of HIV/AIDS: The Unintended Consequences
The reach of mass media is large and it creates awareness at a very fast pace. Several studies have pointed it out and vouched for its use to create awareness about the issues of HIV/AIDS community. Furthermore, researches all over the world have concurred that collaborating with mass media is not free from challenges. The present study conducted in the Ganjam district of Orissa, with 78 percent of rural population and one of the 14 districts of India with high HIV Prevalence among ANC (Antenatal Clinic) attendees (HIV Sentinel Surveillance by NACO, 2006), explores some of the unexplored dimensions of mass media coverage. The study uses the Grounded Theory method (Strauss & Corbin) and finds out that the coverage of mass media especially the vernacular print media is ineffective in its very purpose of creating awareness on the disease, reducing HIV/AIDS stigma and discrimination in society and fighting for the rights of PLHA (People Living with HIV/AIDS). Biased and prejudicial med...
Media Framing on the HIV/AIDS Related Epidemic
2018
Media plays an important role in the social landscape that helps to shape audience perceptions and it also facilitates public discourse and debate by defining acceptable parameters for discussion. According to Collins (2004), media serves as sense-makers to world and become the primary presenters of ideology for the large audience consumption, integrating the fact that media is vital as most commonly shared source of information. Controversial social issues and concerns become the common strengths for the conventional and mainstream media practices and it is represented in various media context (Hart, 1999). Based on Hart’s view, Piontek (1992) also claimed the issues on sexuality especially on homosexuality is dominantly geared by the media representation. He added these representations are fundamentally equipped with the intention to strengthen the society’s knowledge and perception towards their understanding on epidemic diseases such as the Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (A...