Resolving the migrant paradox: Two pathways to coalescence in the late precontact U.S. Southwest (original) (raw)
2018, Journal of Anthropological Archaeology
Migrants are viewed as either disruptive and associated with upheaval or socially and economically beneficial to society. This contradiction constitutes a "migrant paradox" that must be resolved to form sustainable multicultural societies. Social and political scientists view contemporary cosmopolitan societies as successful multicultural organizations, but give little attention to the historical processes through which such societies form. This essay takes a deep historical perspective on migration and resultant multicultural societies, often called coalescent societies by North American archaeologists. We examine four dimensions of migration (scale, organization, and pre-migration conditions in homeland and destination) and the resultant coalescent trajectories in two intensively studied cases from the late pre-contact U.S. Southwest. These are Kayenta migrations into southern Arizona and Mesa Verde migrations into the Northern Rio Grande Valley, which resulted in two different coalescent trajectories that resolved the migrant paradox with variable success. Lessons drawn from these cases have contemporary relevance for resolving and providing perspective on the current migration "crisis." One important finding is that migrant skill and identity persistence, and social distance between migrants and locals are at least as important as the scale of migration in predicting outcomes. Another lesson is that coalescence, especially among socially distant groups, is typically a multigenerational process. Migration crises are often short-term and more perceived than real when viewed from a deep historical perspective. A final lesson is that inclusive institutions and ideologies that foster interaction between migrants and locals with minimal hierarchy greatly facilitate the coalescence process. These institutions and ideologies may already exist within local sociopolitical organizations or may develop within the migrant community as a result of migrant-local interaction. The twenty-first century will be the century of the migrant. At the turn of the twenty-first century, there were more migrants than ever before in recorded history Nail, 2015:187 Daily headlines provide a constant reminder that millions of people are on the move. Changing political and economic conditions across the globe have generated inequalities in wealth and security at such vast scales that large segments of the world's poor and persecuted are embarking on perilous journeys in search of better lives elsewhere. The
Sign up to get access to over 50M papers
Related papers
We are Entering a New Epoch: the Century of the Migrant [Aeon Magazine]
Today there are more than 1 billion regional and international migrants, and the number continues to rise: within 40 years, it might double due to climate change. While many of these migrants might not cross a regional or international border, people change residences and jobs more often, while commuting longer and farther to work. This increase in human mobility and expulsion affects us all. It should be recognised as a defining feature of our epoch: the 21st century will be the century of the migrant.
The Figure of the Migrant (Stanford University Press, 2015)
Buy at Stanford: http://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=23425
This book offers a much-needed new political theory of an old phenomenon. The last decade alone has marked the highest number of migrations in recorded history. Constrained by environmental, economic, and political instability, scores of people are on the move. But other sorts of changes—from global tourism to undocumented labor—have led to the fact that to some extent, we are all becoming migrants. The migrant has become the political figure of our time. Rather than viewing migration as the exception to the rule of political fixity and citizenship, Thomas Nail reinterprets the history of political power from the perspective of the movement that defines the migrant in the first place. Applying his "kinopolitics" to several major historical conditions (territorial, political, juridical, and economic) and figures of migration (the nomad, the barbarian, the vagabond, and the proletariat), he provides fresh tools for the analysis of contemporary migration.
Building Civil Society Among Indigenous Migrants
2005
The past and future of the Mexican nation can be seen in the waves of the tens of thousands of indigenous people who each year set out on their voyages to the north, as well as the many others who have already settled in countless communities within the United States. To understand indigenous Mexican migrants in the United States today requires a binational lens, taking into account basic changes in the way Mexico is increasingly recognized as a nation of migrants, a society whose fate is intimately linked with the economy and culture of the United States. But the specific indigenous migrant experience also requires recognizing that Mexico is a multiethnic society where basic questions of indigenous rights have made it onto the national agenda but remain fundamentally unresolved. Mexico’s national indigenous population is the largest in the hemisphere, with approximately one-quarter of the Indians in the Americas as a whole. At least one-tenth of the Mexican population is of indigen...
"This edited collection focuses on global migration in its inter-regional, international and transnational variants, and argues that contemporary migration scholarship is significantly advanced both within anthropology and beyond it when ethnography is theoretically engaged to grapple with the social consequences and asymmetries of twenty-first century capitalism’s global modalities. Drawn from settings across the globe, case studies explore the nuanced formations of class and power within particular migration flows while addressing the complex analytics of a contemporary critical political economy of migration. Subjects include global migrants as capitalists, entrepreneurs and "cosmopolitans," as well as workers and immigrants who are subject to varying degrees of precariousness under intensified competition for profits within contemporary global economies. By re-addressing the question of the relationship between changes in global capitalism and migration, the book aims for a timely intervention into the debates on migration which have come to be one of the most contentious emotionally fraught issues in North America and Europe. 1. Migration, Political Economy and Ethnography Pauline Gardiner Barber and Winnie Lem Part I: Perspectives 2. Panoptics of Political Economy: Anthropology and Migration Winnie Lem 3. Migration and Development Without Methodological Nationalism: Towards Global Perspectives on Migration Nina Glick Schiller 4. Theorizing Transnational Movement in the Current Conjuncture: Examples from/of/in the Asia Pacific Donald M. Nonini Part II: Cases 5. With Crossings In My Mind: Trinidad's Multiple Migration Flows, Policy and Agency Belinda Leach 6. Selecting, Competing, and Performing as ‘Ideal Migrants’: Mexican and Jamaican Farmworkers in Canada Janet McLaughlin 7. In Search of Hope: Mobility and Citizenships on the Canadian Frontier Lindsay Bell 8. Constructing a "Perfect" Wall: Race, Class, and Citizenship in U.S.–Mexico Border Policing Josiah McC. Heyman 9. The Aftermath of a Rape Case: The Politics of Migrants´ Unequal Incorporation in Neo-Liberal Times Bela Feldman-Bianco 10. Gender, Migration and Rural-Urban Relations in Postsocialist China Yan Hairong 11. "Value Plus Plus": Housewifization and History in Philippine Care Migration Pauline Gardiner Barber and Catherine Bryan 12. Migration, Political Economy and Beyond Pauline Gardiner Barber and Winnie Lem"
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
Related papers
Between the worlds: Migrants, margins, and social environment
Maeva, M., Slavkova, M., Stoyanova, P., Hristova, M. (eds.). Between the worlds: Migrants, margins, and social environment. Vol. 3. Sofia: IEFSEM-BAS & Paradigma, 2021